Jones Beene wrote: > -----Original Message----- > From: Jed Rothwell > >> I never have a hidden agenda. My view of the > Ni-CF research is clearly stated in my book. > > > Your significant and long-standing contributions to LENR, in both time and > money, are of the highest order - and should always be recognized... > > ... and your agenda of minimalizing the importance of Mills' theory to LENR > is also known and not secret.
>From what I've seen Jed's "agenda" here is to ignore Mills' theory, just as he ignores all theories of how LENR might work, and pay attention only to Mills' *replicated* results. Since replications of Mills' work are still few, as far as I know, and such replications as exist are of somewhat debatable independence (or so it has been claimed), Jed's "agenda" on the results is to wait and see. Anyhow that's how it's appeared to me in his posts. > Correspondingly, his agenda of claiming to > have the answer to everything is equally over-reaching, and should be > mentioned. The truth lies somewhere in between. I must disagree with your last statement. I don't think the truth can lie in between. It's almost certainly at one extreme or the other. Either Mills hits a home run, and shakes the foundations of physics (and maybe gets a Nobel, forget a few scraggly patents), or he strikes out and is not even a footnote in the history of science. There isn't any middle ground, as far as I can see. Because either hydrinos are for real and totally revolutionary, and when the evidence is all in Mills will be recognized as a giant on the landscape of physics, or they are not real, and in the latter case there is nothing of value in Mills' work; hydrinos can't be "a little bit real". > > Secrecy, if there is any which is applicable to the Piantelli paper, would > relate to the influence of another unknown party. > > ... and that is why the comment about confusing and conflating "disproof" > with "null results" was meant to be a general thing, not aimed at anyone > specifically, and why your name was not mentioned in the previous posting. Yes, indeed, let's all stay on the same page here. The claim Jed made was *not* that they failed to replicate; it was that they *succeeded* in their replication, *and* they looked at the published data, *and* they found a mundane explanation for the apparent excess heat, *and* they showed that the mundane explanation fully accounted for the results of their *successful* replication. That's completely different from the claim that 95 failures to replicate "disprove" the claims of one successful scientist, which is tautologically false. > > If I am not mistaken, you have probably said something very similar, perhaps > uncomfortably similar (and probably many times) - to past comments from > skeptics of cold-fusion, who were fond of saying in the nineties that null > results "disproved" the phenomenon. > > Jones > > >

