Michel Jullian wrote:
Duncan didn't bring in his own measurement system so he didn't see
the excess heat for himself.
Oh give me a break.
That's ridiculous. The technique was replicated as SRI and ENEA. CBS
sent one of the world top experts in calorimetry to confirm it. What
more do you want? Do you seriously think that Scott Little with his
MOAC would provide better confirmation than this?
Are you suggesting that Duncan can't recognize when an instrument is
malfunctioning? Or that they might have fooled him with fake
instruments? That is like suggesting that you could fool me into
thinking someone is speaking Japanese when they are speaking
gibberish. I can tell. It is my second language. Rob Duncan speaks
calorimetry the way Edward Seidensticker spoke Japanese.
You come up with such improbable reasons to disbelieve these results!
You are grasping at straws, the way Dieter Britz does. One day you
imagine that Rossi has somehow crammed $60 million of plutonium into
his cell, and the next you tell us that the world's top expert in
calorimetry may be so incompetent he doesn't know amps from volts.
How else can someone mistake 0.8 W for 20 W?
- Jed
