Daniel Rocha <danieldi...@gmail.com> wrote: Makes "no sense" is a word too strong.
It makes no sense to me! > I guess you are leaning to think he is a crank. I don't like the word "crank." He is one of the most eccentric people I know, and I know many eccentric people. (Come to think of it, a "crank" in the literal sense is eccentric in the literal sense.) Well, if you Jed, throw in the towel, I will do it too . . . Just because he is eccentric that is no reason to doubt his results. The correlation between the personality of an inventor and validity of the claim is weak. Straight-laced conventional people at IBM, Microsoft, and the plasma fusion program sometime come up with ludicrous ideas that will never work or products that will never sell. Strange people who seldom bathe sometimes come up with brilliant ideas. You have to judge the claim on its own merits. I think there is good evidence for Rossi's claims. I hope that Defkalion soon publishes good evidence for their claims, with more rigorous & professional reports than Rossi and Levi et al. have produced so far. I do not think that any of the arguments against Rossi have merit, especially not the ones that attempt to disprove the 18-hour flowing water test. - Jed
