“Many of his supporters have reviewed the sparse data supplied during his
demonstrations and have convinced ourselves that it is real.”



There are different levels of SCAM that Rossi can be perpetrating. The one
level that I think currently applies to Rossi is the ability of his reactor
to function for months on end to provide industrial heat safely in a
factory setting. This he says he has now demonstrated but I find this very
hard to believe.



It is analogous to the Wright brothers claiming the ability to fly the
Atlantic after their first demo of powered flight.

At that time in the history of aviation, an enlighten observer could have
foreseen that this capacity to connect the continents of the world could be
developed in the future from the beginnings of the first airplane demo but
that observer would be foolish to buy a ticket to fly the Atlantic without
many transatlantic crossings routinely done clearly in the full glare of
the public eye.

This claim of sustained industrial heat production that Rossi is now making
is not believable even though the potential may eventually be there.

I think that Rossi like most entrepreneurs are sorely tempted to exaggerate
the current state of the capabilities of their invention to gain continued
funding for their R&D.









* *


On Fri, Nov 11, 2011 at 12:44 PM, David Roberson <[email protected]> wrote:

> OK Mary, you are correct in realizing that Rossi could be attempting a
> fake.  Many of his supporters have reviewed the sparse data supplied during
> his demonstrations and have convinced ourselves that it is real.  I am
> confident that we are seeing a real LENR device.  Rossi succeeded in
> operating a single core ECAT for a length of time that makes it dificult to
> be absolutely 100 % certain that it could not be faked.
>
> Now the game,  some atomic bombs are suitcase size and have a small
> yield.  I perform an underground test of a very large quaintly of
> conventional explosives that has a yield equal to the suitcase device that
> I show you before I safely lower it into the cavity to be sealed
> within.  Of course I do not allow you to inspect my setup before the test
> or bring your equipment as it is too dangerous for you to enter the
> cavity.  Who knows, you might break a finger nail or something. ;-) This is
> similiar to the proceedure that magicians use when they do their magic.
>
> No more games Mary.
>
> Dave
>
>
>  -----Original Message-----
> From: Mary Yugo <[email protected]>
> To: vortex-l <[email protected]>
> Sent: Fri, Nov 11, 2011 12:06 pm
> Subject: Re: [Vo]:Physorg comments : new Krivit Crusade
>
>
>
>
>  Mary, you seem to love to find ways to scam scientific tests or do magic
>> tricks or whatever.  Let me ask you a question.  Can you name one
>> scientific experiment that is impossible to scam from the past?  I tried
>> and can not come up with one, so give it a try.   There are many ways to
>> suggest a trick that could, maybe be done.  I will grant you this: Rossi
>> has left the possible field open to a lot of tricks.
>>
>> Give one example of an experiment that is fool proof to save me from
>> having to think too hard.  I bet the vortex can figure a way to fake any
>> you name.
>>
>
> OK, I'll play.  Fake an atomic bomb.
>
> But the argument is silly.  I agree almost any subtle looking and complex
> experiment can be faked.  THAT'S MY POINT.  And Rossi's experiments are so
> loosely done and so different from one to another that it's hard to follow
> what he's doing.  The whole purpose of having independent testing is to
> rule out fakery.  Sure, the experimenters can be in on a scam.  That's why
> they need to have no association with Rossi and an excellent reputation for
> skill and fairness.  That's why I named the companies and labs I did.
>
> You suggest that because we accept other experiments from the past that
> could have been faked, we should also accept Rossi's.   But that's
> defective reasoning.  The only evidence that Rossi's device works has
> always involved Rossi's equipment and methods.  That's the problem.  The
> problem is not that anything can be a scam.  It's that Rossi's device could
> fairly easily be a scam.  The corollary is that a scam can be easily ruled
> out except that Rossi, who has done all sorts of complicated and
> time/effort consuming maneuvers, won't allow it!
>

Reply via email to