Am 02.12.2011 22:31, schrieb Jed Rothwell:

1. There is no such thing as perfect insulation.
Yes. Especially not, when the surface is 60-80° hot. This is so poor, that I dont understand why did they isolate it at all. This reduces the thermal losses by less than 50%.

2. The insulation around the E-Cat reactor was far from perfect. A great deal of heat was coming through it. The surface was ~80°C. someone touched the pipe nearby and was burned three hours into the heat after death event.
80% means about 20% efficiency of the insulation.
Without insulation the surface where about 100%.
How can you assume Rossi is a good engineer if he cannot do it better? A plumber does this better.

I believe you are aware of these two facts. I have a feeling you may have been playing dumb, or bringing up irrelevant points to confuse the issue. Please do not do that. When you know that your example does not apply to the situation, you should start by pointing that out. You should write something like this:
 I believed you might be in error about these facts.

"It is true that Rossi's reactor would cool to room temperature because it was poorly insulated, but it is interesting to note that with a much better insulated container, you can cook food over 4 hours. For example during the Berlin blockade . . ."

Why didnt you write: "I believe in the Rossi device, because observers have noticed the surface heated up and because of this poor insulation it must cool down over 4 hours without power. Of course this assumes that Rossi did not use tricks with the input power, but I dont see any possibility how to do this".

Why should I be 150% accurate and complete, when your majesty is allowed to be 50% accurate and complete?
;-)

best regards,
Peter

Reply via email to