In reply to  Alain Sepeda's message of Wed, 2 May 2012 06:57:41 +0200:
Hi,
[snip]
>> Note the "silliness" of this situation: First the proton acquires an
>> electron,
>> at great energy cost, to become a neutron, which, after being absorbed
>> against
>> it's will by T, then decays to a proton again - via slow beta decay - as
>> opposed
>> to rapid ejection of a neutron!
>>
>> Perhaps needless to say, I think models in which the proton is and remains
>> a
>> proton are far more likely to be correct.
>>
>why...
>the global reaction is exothermic

I just gave you three reasons, however only the first is valid.

1) A 782 keV endothermic requirement to create the neutron. (Note that in
contrast to this e.g. Hydrino production is exothermic.)

A closer look at http://atom.kaeri.re.kr/ton/nuc1.html reveals that there is a
low energy meta-state with spin +1/2 that is "stable". However if it is stable
doesn't this also mean that it doesn't beta decay, or perhaps it just has a very
long half life? In either case, it's not likely to be the source of 4He.

>
>
>
>>
>> >(this one is not classic, does somemone have reference on 4H
>> disintegration
>> >branching).
>>
>> According to http://atom.kaeri.re.kr/ton/nuc1.html it decays via neutron
>> emission to H3 (very rapidly - order 1E-22 sec.), so I find it hard to
>> believe
>> that H3 is going to absorb a neutron to become H4!
>> (Brillouin argues that the data used to create the table is
>> wrong/inapplicable.)
>>
>good point against Brillouin.
>Even if possible the idea that "table are wrong" is an easy solution.
>
>
>
>> IMO both Brillouin & WL suffer from the same false assumption that has
>> almost
>> the entire scientific community in thrall. They assume that only neutrons
>> can
>> penetrate the Coulomb barrier at low temps.
>>
>
>alternative are no better, and changing from coulomb barrier to weak
>interaction barrier is opening interesting possibilities.

The alternatives are much better. My calculations show that severely shrunken
Deuterinos could penetrate the Coulomb barrier in 22 micro-seconds. If my
version of the theory is correct, then the time could be much shorter.

In Horace's model the penetrating entity is completely neutral like a neutron,
and hence has no problem with the Coulomb barrier at all. I.e. the deuteron
takes an electron into the nucleus with it, like a shield, however this electron
doesn't need to actually partake in the nuclear reaction, and likely would only
do so if this were energetically favourable.


>
>no classic coulomb barrier breaking seems convincing...
>
>maybe WL abd Brillouin are not the good theories, but some ideas are
>interesting.
>neutrons, coherence,
>
>
>anyway all of those theories should be tested with good tools

Agreed! :)

Regards,

Robin van Spaandonk

http://rvanspaa.freehostia.com/project.html

Reply via email to