Axil, I feel it is counterproductive to the advancement of science for people to be proposing ideas willy nilly - ideas that have no bearing in reality and cleary violates known physical principles. Attempts at theory of these kinds are not helpful and adds a significant amount of noise that needs to be sifted thru and vetted. I think this is what Ed storms is lamenting from ideas coming in this forum.
Take your ideas of exotic substances (BEC soltions) shielding nanostructures from melting in high temps. Such "metaphasic shielding" ideas are counterproductive. Instead of cleary admitting that your ideas has a big hole - a clear violation of a known physical property; you propose this even more preposterous idea of metaphasic shielding for high temps to try to explain another created miracle. Each miracle requires a dozen more miracles to explain it. This is getting ridiculous. Tell me my friend; would you be so bold in proposing such ludricous ideas if people knew who you really are? Being anonymous affords you the opportunity to be as outrageous and senseless as you like without consequence. I am trying to say this without any attempt at a personal attack, but people has got to admit - this is part of the problem, and IMO, part of why Ed left this forum. Jojo ----- Original Message ----- From: Axil Axil To: vortex-l Sent: Thursday, August 07, 2014 3:44 AM Subject: Re: [Vo]:The 5 states of matter The whole discussion about different theories is way too adament in my opinion. It seems like if evry theory is having problems to be accepted by a wide group of scientists. Whenever there is a mystery in science, many theories are proposed to explain that mystery. Take for an example dark matter, there are hundreds of theories that have been put forth to explain that mystery. There is even a dozen categories in which these theories can be grouped. The debate that weighs each new piece of evidence against all those theories is very healthy. Over time, and with many iterations, one of the many will pull away in the theory sweepstakes.
