Re: Muhammad and His return to Mecca

2006-07-06 Thread smaneck
It is said that the Jihad is only to defense, and historians (no- believers) can argue that Muhammad was only a big merchant and He want the hegemony of the trade in the region, so He returned to Mecca to fight and get this aim. Dear Hasan, I don't know any historians who have made this

Re: delivering wives in Bible texts

2006-07-22 Thread smaneck
I think Shi`ah consider the `ismah (infallibility) of `ali, Fatimih, Imam Hasan, Imam Husayn, etc., etc. on par with the infallibility of the Prophet Muhammad. I guess the Shaykhi school adopts a very extremist view of the exalted station of imams. But I think Baha'u'llah does not accept

Re: delivering wives in Bible texts

2006-07-22 Thread smaneck
As to the question you raise about the perfection of the Manifestations, I think you can find a direct answer in Some Answered Questions. In that book Abdu'l Baha explains that the apparent rebukes to the Prophets are indirect rebukes to the Prophet's followers rather than to the Prophet

Re: Lincoln's Statement

2006-07-22 Thread smaneck
I can't get the link to work. - Original Message - From: Dean Betts [EMAIL PROTECTED] Date: Friday, July 21, 2006 8:36 pm Subject: Lincoln's Statement To: Baha'i Studies bahai-st@list.jccc.edu The Baha'is do not have a temple in Haifa. We have shrines. Why would Mr. Lincoln refer

Re: Fwd: delivering wives in Bible texts

2006-07-22 Thread smaneck
But if it has been so decidedly rejected, why would Bahais in India present Bahaullah as an Avatar? Because it is the closest concept Hinduism has to Manifestation. But we do usually explain we don't literally mean incarnation. warmest, Susan The information contained in this e-mail

Re: delivering wives in Bible texts Prophets' station

2006-07-22 Thread smaneck
i disagree with mark about this, but i understand his view. in a discussion in which frequently we see terms like most Moslems think and some poets say there is a strong appearance that the words are constructs of a culture. I think it would be more precise to say, words have no meaning,

Re: delivering wives in Bible texts Prophets' station

2006-07-22 Thread smaneck
The verse recommended to me that the meanings of words are actually given by God; and that man must recognise those meanings if he is to understand the relationship between his existence and the Revelations of God. Otherwise, I believe, he will live in a confusion of words. Dear

Re: the London Times and the Gleanings

2006-07-22 Thread smaneck
A Rabbi is calling for Muslims and Christians to revise the Koran and the New Testament, excising the passages that preach ill-will towards others.Dr Jonathan Romain, the Rabbi of Maidenhead Synagogue, says that Jewish scholars should also delete some verses from the Hebrew bible.** snip

Re: Muhammad and His return to Mecca

2006-07-22 Thread smaneck
Dear Hasan, Here's a URL that explains it: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treaty_of_Hudaybiyyah warmest, Susan - Original Message - From: Hasan Elias [EMAIL PROTECTED] Date: Thursday, July 6, 2006 2:42 pm Subject: Re: Muhammad and His return to Mecca To: Baha'i Studies

Re: Fwd: delivering wives in Bible texts

2006-07-22 Thread smaneck
Gilberto, these are points to bear in mind from the book Making the Crooked Straight (a book made in response to attacks from an ex-bahai Francesco Ficichia): Hasan, do you have an electronic version of this book? The information contained in this e-mail and any attachments thereto

Re: Is there self examination in Islamic societies

2006-07-23 Thread smaneck
Dear Albert, If you follow Al-Jazeera you will find there is plenty of self- criticism in the Arabic world. warmest, Susan The information contained in this e-mail and any attachments thereto (e-mail) is sent by the Johnson County Community College (JCCC) and is intended to be

Re: Is there self examination in Islamic societies

2006-07-23 Thread smaneck
References? Google for the English language pages of al-Jazeera. My son and I were reading those just yesterday. The information contained in this e-mail and any attachments thereto (e-mail) is sent by the Johnson County Community College (JCCC) and is intended to be confidential and

Re: Words and Meanings

2006-07-24 Thread smaneck
words have no meaning, people have meanings. I would appreciate it very much if someone could explain what this means. Dear Tim, I can tell you what I meant by that. ;-} Words in and of themselves have no instinsic meaningm they are just sounds. But those that use them intend

Re: Is there self examination in Islamic societies

2006-07-24 Thread smaneck
Dear Friends, If you want to see an even-handed approach to the ramifications of Islam in geo-political terms I would recommend you look at the book *Good Muslim, Bad Muslim: America, the Cold War, and the Roots of Terror* by Mahmood Mamdani. But I do not want to see this list become a

Re: Words and Meaning

2006-07-26 Thread smaneck
I see this the same way. Words do have meaning, but only because people agree that they do. Dear Tim, And that's what Mark Foster meant by a 'social contract.' However, in my experience each individual tends to use terminology in ways that are often specific to them. So when analyzing a

Re: Is there self examination in Islamic societies

2006-07-30 Thread smaneck
Dear Albert, You can't get access to that unless you are subscribed. But let's keep on topic with the Baha'i Faith, please. warmest, Susan The information contained in this e-mail and any attachments thereto (e-mail) is sent by the Johnson County Community College (JCCC) and is

Re: alcohol in meals

2006-08-02 Thread smaneck
But I'm not about to give up my extracts, which have 30 to 90 per cent alcohol by volume, because Shoghi Effendi said not to eat flaming rum puddings or sip a toast. I think we need to use some common sense. My understanding is that rum puddings have quite a lot of alcohol left in them.

Re: Fwd: delivering wives in Bible texts

2006-08-02 Thread smaneck
Any chance you could send me a copy to my gmail address? (Not this one, it will crash.) I have a hard copy of the book, but I'd like to be able to quote it when appropriate. - Original Message - From: Hasan Elias [EMAIL PROTECTED] Date: Wednesday, August 2, 2006 10:49 am Subject: Re:

Re: alcohol in meals

2006-08-02 Thread smaneck
(this happened before I became a Baha'i, so I had no excuse not to eat it). ;-) Uh huh. Like you were looking for one. ;-} Didn't 'Abdu'l-Baha (or maybe Shoghi Effendi) say something once about not making an issue of alcohol content in food when we're somebody's guest, in order to

Re: RE: alcohol in meals

2006-08-03 Thread smaneck
What about Jesus, Moses or the other Manifestations? Jesus and Moses did not. You have to keep in mind that in this time period water was not save to drink and people didn't know about boiling it. But wine was often mixed with water which disinfected it. Also, in those days it was not

Re: RE: alcohol in meals - and gambling

2006-08-03 Thread smaneck
I infer that gambling as source of bahá?ís funds is forbidden (also gambling as an occupation is inadvisable), but I don?t think it is completely forbidden for recreation purposes. As far as individuals are concerned, we have carefully studied the Writings of 'Abdu'l-Bahá and Shoghi

Re: RE: alcohol in meals

2006-08-03 Thread smaneck
My recollection is that alcohol is only gradually prohibited in the Qur'an itself. At first the Qur'an merely says there is good and bad in wine, but the bad exceeds the good. Then it says don't go to prayer drunk, something hard to do if you imbibe at all and pray five times a day. Afterwards

Re: RE: alcohol in meals - and gambling

2006-08-04 Thread smaneck
Hi Susan, I have played Bingo, poker, etc. in family meetings (there are azar games)... In the other hand (azar games as recreation to earn a bit money ;-) Are you saying that we cannot play lottery anytime? Dear Hasan, No, I didn't say that. Lotteries are for charitable purposes. Even

Re: Why 'Abdu'l-Baha doesn't qualify to be a Prophet

2006-08-04 Thread smaneck
Could someone come up with an actual reason as to why 'Abdu'l-Baha's Writings don't make the grade we should expect to find in those of a Prophet? Dear David, Yes, Book in this context infers not simply Writings but a Book of Laws such as the Kitab-i Aqdas. Abdu'l-Baha did not reveal

Re: with loving bahá'í greetings

2006-08-06 Thread smaneck
Much time I have asked why we (some of us, even institutions) used to say good-bye in letters/e-mails with these words with loving bahá'í greetings, I think we should not try to differentiate loves or to change the current good-bye forms. Dear Hasan, I have always taken the 'Baha'i' as a

Re: with loving bahá'í greetings

2006-08-07 Thread smaneck
i personally think it came about as a differentaiting praxis, so that the firends wouldn't ask well, if we're not some kind of Moslem, why are we saying Alla'u'Akhbar? and they were given an alternative. We usually use Allah'u'Abha as a greeting. That's not how Muslims use Allah'u'akbar.

Re: with loving bahá'í greetings

2006-08-08 Thread smaneck
This is interesting; could you resume how this kind of platonic love is? Dear Hasan, I'm just saying it is a way of saying 'love' with no erotic overtones. I don't see any necessity to use this good-bye form, it seems we differentiate a superior love here; this could dislike

Re: bahá'í view on sports

2006-08-09 Thread smaneck
Dear Hasan, I'm hoping young Shoghi Effendi's essay might silence those who insist there is something wrong with Baha'is playing competitive games. warmest, Susan - Original Message - From: Hasan Elias [EMAIL PROTECTED] Date: Wednesday, August 9, 2006 1:06 am Subject: bahá'í view on

Re: Needed: Video/DVD on Iranian History?

2006-08-29 Thread smaneck
Dear Dick, If you don't get a response here would you like me to forward you question to the Tarikh (history) list? warmest, Susan - Original Message - From: Dick Detweiler [EMAIL PROTECTED] Date: Tuesday, August 29, 2006 2:42 am Subject: Needed: Video/DVD on Iranian History? To:

Re: RE: Wrong quote attribution...

2006-09-06 Thread smaneck
BT, Wikipedia's entry: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lacordaire puts his death date as 1861. Is that too late for this quote? My wife sent this to me today. Does anyone know the correct way to correct such a thing? I suppose Mr. Lacordaire could have come up with it on his own but

Re: Wrong quote attribution...

2006-09-07 Thread smaneck
Could someone share what the Bahai version is for the quote? Dear Gilberto, I found various similiar passages. Here is where it is found in Baha'u'llah's Writings: Ye are all the leaves of one tree and the drops of one ocean. (Baha'u'llah, Tablets of Baha'u'llah, p. 27) And we

Re: When does one cease to be a youth?

2006-09-11 Thread smaneck
I mentioned how the Writings speak of youth and their responsbilities and that the Writings are obviously referring to a certain age group Dear David, Personally, I think Mr. Javeheri gave you the right answer. But why don't you post those passages from the Writings which you have in mind

Re: When does one cease to be a youth?

2006-09-12 Thread smaneck
Dear David, The term translated as Youth in reference to the Bab and more especially Baha'u'llah is usually ghulam which literally is a slave boy. It is an allusion to the story of Joseph. warmest, Susan The information contained in this e-mail and any attachments thereto (e-mail) is

Re: When does one cease to be a youth?

2006-09-13 Thread smaneck
Okay, I was wrong in saying that the Writings says anything like that.nbsp; I would have been referring to something Shoghi Effendi said about how youth are the most important for the Cause.nbsp; Should I provide a quote? Dear David, In that case I'm guessing he had in mind people under 30.

Re: voices recording

2006-09-21 Thread smaneck
By the way, I think there is a recording of the Master saying a prayer, Dear Husayn, That's correct. There are a couple of them in fact. There is also a silent movie. do you know if the Guardian's voice was recorded or if there is a film of him? Not that I know of. He was adverse to

Re: Is it okay? . . . .

2006-10-10 Thread smaneck
Congratulations, Scott. Tell us about your book. - Original Message - From: Scott Saylors [EMAIL PROTECTED] Date: Tuesday, October 10, 2006 7:30 am Subject: Is it okay? . . . . To: Baha'i Studies bahai-st@list.jccc.edu . . . to announce the publication of a novel I have written, with

Re: Is it okay? . . . .

2006-10-10 Thread smaneck
So this is an ebook? - Original Message - From: Scott Saylors [EMAIL PROTECTED] Date: Tuesday, October 10, 2006 3:12 pm Subject: Re: Is it okay? . . . . To: Baha'i Studies bahai-st@list.jccc.edu Okay, I'll bite the bullet. If it turns out it's not okay, just delete the message,

Re: Resurrection of Christ

2006-10-11 Thread smaneck
Dear David, Although Abdu'l-Baha does not say so explicitly, my reading of the early Christian sources, combined with Abdu'l-Baha's interpretation lead me to think that there were 'ressurrection' appearances of Jesus after the crucifixtion. They just weren't physical. warmest, Susan

Re: Resurrection of Christ

2006-10-12 Thread smaneck
This risen Christ issue was very big to him, I suppose in contrast to images of Catholic crucufixes. Dear Karen, That's kind of a one-upsman thing Protestants sometimes use against the Catholics. They claim because they (Protestants) wear empty crucifixes it represents the resurrection as

Re: what is a vision? was Re: Resurrection of Christ

2006-10-13 Thread smaneck
So what happened when someone says they saw a vision? Is it a God-induced hallucination only visible to one person? Is it an appearance visible to many people? What about these resurrection experiences? Physical? Dear Gilberto, I'm suggesting we don't really know. When Muhammad saw Jabreel

Re: Resurrection of Christ

2006-10-13 Thread smaneck
Dear Brent, I don't think that what the Baha'i Writings say about the Resurrection necessitate visionary experiences of the Resurrected Christ, but I don't think they preclude them either. My conclusions in this regard are based primarily on the historical evidence. warmest, Susan

Re: You never really know: transsexual or gay?

2006-10-30 Thread smaneck
So what will the Faith accept as defining gender? What medical experts say? Chromosomes? Body appearance? What the person believes his or her gender to be? If a female changes to a male and later enrolls in the Faith, can he serve on the House? If a male is born with ambiguous

Re: You never really know: transsexual or gay?

2006-10-31 Thread smaneck
Are you saying you know a case where the Baha'i Administration did not invalidate a marriage where one partner changed physical gender? Are there cases where a person who changed genders wished to remain married as before? Or are we just talking hypothetically? I would think if a person

Re: Daniel, the Prophet

2006-10-31 Thread smaneck
The century the Book of Daniel was composed in is disputed.nbsp; Generally, believers believe it was written in the sixth century BC, whereas non-believers believe it was written in the second century BC. Dear David, There are plenty of believers who also hold it was written in the second

Re: What's the truth of Astrology and Numerology?

2006-10-31 Thread smaneck
A long time ago it had occured to me that in the standard Christmas story, the claim that the magi from the east knew that the messiah was going to be born (if taken literally) strongly suggests that some form of astrology has some validity. Dear Gilberto, The Magi story may well have its

Re: You never really know: transsexual or gay?

2006-10-31 Thread smaneck
All I know is this, should such a case arrive, it woulod not be treated as setting a precedent for how the House would deal with it. There is no such thing as a precedent in Baha`i 'due process'. Each case would be unique and treated as such. Dear Scott, There may not be such a thing as

Re: virgin birth Re: What's the truth of Astrology and Numerology?

2006-10-31 Thread smaneck
Sure, but both the NT and the Quran are actually fairly clear on the point. I've not sure why you'd mention the above ambiguity. Dear Gilberto, They are clear that Jesus was born of a virgin, not that Jews expected this. warmest, Susan The information contained in this e-mail and

Re: Re: You never really know: transsexual or gay?

2006-10-31 Thread smaneck
I have known Baha'is who married members of the opposite sex in order to pass within the Baha'i community as heterosexual. I assume that they felt this was an acceptable approach to their struggles with sexual preference. Dear Bill, Oh, I realize that. It is rather common infact, inside and

Re: change of sex?

2006-11-01 Thread smaneck
Huh? - Original Message - From: Hasan Elias [EMAIL PROTECTED] Date: Wednesday, November 1, 2006 4:33 am Subject: change of sex? To: Baha'i Studies bahai-st@list.jccc.edu In bahá'í view a homosexual is a sick heterosexual or perturbed heterosexual. So change of sex doesn't exist.

Wilmette Institute

2006-11-03 Thread smaneck
The cost of the three-month course *Baha'i History, 1863-2000,* which was to start November 1, has just been cut in half to encourage more participation. Heretofore, individual tuition will be $75 and local study groups will cost $150. Don't miss this great opportunity to study the unfoldment of

Re: Wilmette Institute

2006-11-03 Thread smaneck
Dear Friends: The Wilmette Institute is pleased to announce its 2007 course schedule. Please spread this information around among your friends, take it to Feast, etc., Also, please let people know about our upcoming courses in November and December. We have a lot to offer over the next year

Re: Year of patience

2006-11-10 Thread smaneck
If a Baha'i is married to a non-Baha'i the non-Baha'i can get a divorce prior to the conclusion ofnbsp;a year of patience.nbsp; They can do this because Baha'i law is subordinate to civil law.nbsp; Dear David, It is possible for a Baha'i to get a civil divorce prior to the end of the year of

Wilmette Institute

2006-11-10 Thread smaneck
The Wilmette Institute is pleased to offer its course on the Ministry of Shoghi Effendi (1897-1957), again. Guardian of the Bahá'í Faith from 1921 until his passing, Shoghi Effendi devoted much of his early ministry to construction of the administrative order defined in `Abdu'l-Bahá's Will and

Baha'i Studies program at the AAR

2006-11-10 Thread smaneck
Renaissance Hotel, Washington, DC Meeting Room 18 Monday, 11/20/2006 4:00 PM - 6:30 PM Dr. Robert H. Stockman, DePaul University, presiding 4:00 Dr. Susan Maneck, Jackson State University, Jackson, Miss. The Bahá'í Covenant as

The Covenant as Responsiveness

2006-11-17 Thread smaneck
Dear friends, As the last announcement indicated, I'm presenting a paper at the American Academy of Religion this weekend. I've not written the conclusion yet, but I'd like to share with you what I have and get your feedback. warmest, Susan The Covenant as Responsiveness When Baha’is

Re: How much of Islamic culture is actually Arab?

2006-11-17 Thread smaneck
I have been thinking about this question for a few weeks. To what extent is modern global Islamic culture based on Arab culture? Dear Tim, I think it is probably true that Islam has carried more of the 'baggage' of the culture in which it was born than any of the other World Religions.

Re: RE: The Covenant as Responsiveness

2006-11-19 Thread smaneck
The equivalence between responsiveness shown toward the Lord of the Kingdom and responsiveness toward each of His servants was enunciated by Jesus, in this way: Dear Vaughn, You are quite right. I remembered that passage only a few minutes ago when I was responding to someone on

Re: How much of Islamic culture is actually Arab?

2006-11-19 Thread smaneck
Becasue the Baha'i Faith arose in Persia, our daughters have names in the Farsi form. But does that signify that we regard Persian culture as somehow more authentically Baha'i? The information contained in this e-mail and any attachments thereto (e-mail) is sent by the Johnson County

Re: Holy Grail

2007-01-01 Thread smaneck
Often I have wondered if the mystery of the Holy *Grail *is related to the archangel *Gabriel*, the messenger of the death, of the big news (in the Bible) and the developer of the Qur'án. Dear Badi, What mystery of the Holy Grail? warmest, Susan The information contained in this

Re: Holy Grail

2007-01-01 Thread smaneck
Dear Badi, I know what the Holy Grail is, I just don't see that there is any mystery behind it. People just made up a lot of fanciful tales about it. I don't see this has any connection to the Archangel Gabriel at all. I think you are being misled by the fact that the two words sound

Re: RE: Holy Grail

2007-01-02 Thread smaneck
In those stories, might the Grail be the holy Sign that fuses both ancient Celtic tribal traditions with the arrival of Christianity? Dear Susan B., That certainly seems to be the function of those sotries. warmest, Susan The information contained in this e-mail and any attachments

Re: limits of hikmat, righteous warfare, jihad, etc.

2007-01-06 Thread smaneck
Dear friends, Gilberto has been forwarding private correspondence to this list without permission. Please do not respond and encourage this kind of behavior. Gilberto, you are no longer welcome here. Susan The information contained in this e-mail and any attachments thereto (e-mail)

Re: limits of hikmat, righteous warfare, jihad, etc.

2007-01-07 Thread smaneck
They were basically rejected posts intended for soc.religion.bahai which I felt you were mischaracterizing and then rejecting. That doesn't give you the right to bring it here. As I said, you are no longer welcome on this forum. The information contained in this e-mail and any

Re: re: Young earth creationism - expiry date - ?

2007-01-07 Thread smaneck
As a Christian Baha'i, I can assure you that christians people make a clear difference between the Faith in the 7 days of creation of the world (as exposed in the Genese of the Bible)and the scientific knowledge about creation of the Earth, life, and humanity! Perhaps it seems idiot, but

Re: limits of hikmat, righteous warfare, jihad, etc.

2007-01-07 Thread smaneck
Anyway, I see some risks of censorship when I read some baha'i publications that have been reviewed, corrected, validated, re-reviewed... Dear Loic, What 're-reviewed' are you talking about? warmest, Susan The information contained in this e-mail and any attachments thereto

Re: re: Young earth creationism - expiry date - ?

2007-01-07 Thread smaneck
You are right, I have to make the precision. I was talking about Christians people you can meet in Europe : Roman Catholics, Protestants, Anglicans, Orthodox catholics... Dear Loic, Correct me if I'm wrong but I'm under the impression that French Catholics aren't all that religious

Re: limits of hikmat, righteous warfare, jihad, etc.

2007-01-07 Thread smaneck
What I meant is that I sometimes feel worried when I see so many warnings at the beginning or at the end of some Baha'i writings. examples given: this text has been translated by the X committee, reviewed by the Y committee, approved by Z, and might be later corrected by ZZ... Dear Loic,

Re: limits of hikmat, righteous warfare, jihad, etc.

2007-01-07 Thread smaneck
A simple word of the Faith : the Bayan, which could be easily translated in french by l'Annonce or l'Explication, but people are so afraid to translate that they keep the Bayan in their writings. Dear Loic, When it appears in the Writings we do translate it, normally as 'utterance'

Re: limits of hikmat, righteous warfare, jihad, etc.

2007-01-07 Thread smaneck
Dear Scott, It would be a mistake to interpret the House's April 7 letter as an attack on the notion of academic freedom. What they are criticizing is the attempt to misuse the term in a Baha'i religious context. Academic freedom is the freedom of teachers, students, and academic

Re: limits of hikmat, righteous warfare, jihad, etc.

2007-01-07 Thread smaneck
I have heard about these evangelical religions, they look to be more efficient than us in terms of number of conversions! ;-) Dear Loic, Yes, there seems to be resurgence of conservatism and literalism in religion all over the world. Our retention, bad as it is, is a bit better however.

Re: Year of patience

2007-01-07 Thread smaneck
Personaly I have never felt this repugnance toward my ex-wife. I always respect and appreciate her. but when I realized I was in love with someone else (and not just for a temporary pleasure time) I have prefered to talk with her about this. Dear Loic, I do not think that falling in love

Re: Baha'i considerations about alcohol...

2007-01-09 Thread smaneck
(and someone else can do the research!), I have long understood that non-alcoholic wine and beer AREN'T. They are simply sufficiently reduced in alcohol content as to avoid being labeled as regular beer or wine. One should be able to read labels (at least, in the U.S.) to see if it

Re: Baha'i considerations about alcohol...

2007-01-09 Thread smaneck
But as David mentioned earlier - there is non-alcoholic wine available and it can taste just as good as the alcoholic version with meals. Never tell a Frenchman that non-alcoholic wine is just as good.;-} The information contained in this e-mail and any attachments thereto (e-mail) is

Re: Baha'i considerations about alcohol...

2007-01-09 Thread smaneck
Non-alcoholic wine?! never heard about this! (may be an american creation!) it cannot be wine but just grape-fruits juice! (Frenchman point of view);-) Not exactly. There is sparkling grape juice as well which I quite often buy. But non-alcholic wine is where the grapes were allowed to

Call for papers

2007-01-09 Thread smaneck
31st Annual Conference of the Association for Bahá’í Studies–North America Mississauga, Ontario - August 16-19, 2007 Scholarship and Community-Building Theme Statement Community is the organic entity in which human spiritual and material potential can emerge. It is where people interact and

Re: There is a power in this Cause...

2007-01-11 Thread smaneck
... far, far, far away from the ken of men and angels; That starts a quote describing the Covenant that instantly struck a chord with me when I read it in The Power of the Covenant series pamphlets published in 1976. Shoghi Effendi quoted about as much of it as I have above and

Re: Provenance of an Hadith

2007-01-13 Thread smaneck
but would like proper provenance if available. By provenance do you mean the isnad? The information contained in this e-mail and any attachments thereto (e-mail) is sent by the Johnson County Community College (JCCC) and is intended to be confidential and for the use of only the

House of Justice on James Mock's passing

2007-01-23 Thread smaneck
Dear friends, James Mock's daughter was kind enough to share with me the House of Justice letter of condolence. I also have a letter from the NSA which I'll be posting presently. warmest, Susan TO: The National Spiritual Assembly of the Bahá’ís of the United States DATE: 7 January 2007

Re: Status of Promulgation

2007-01-24 Thread smaneck
The Guardian quotes a number of times from Promulgation in his letters and in God Passes By. He does not regard it as unreliable. Dear Brent, The Guardian sometimes quotes pilgrim's notes. That doesn't make them reliable as a body. At most, it might give some status to the specific

Re: Luck and salvation

2007-01-24 Thread smaneck
Dear David, Your question reminds me of the old Mutazalite/Asharite [Free will vs. Predestination] debate. There is a story associated with al-Asharite's breaking away from his Mutazalite teacher. You can read it hear: al-Ashari posed to his teacher the cases of three brothers whose fates

Re: Mahabad

2007-01-30 Thread smaneck
The Prophets of Mahábád, together with Zoroaster, were twenty- eight in number. Dear Richard, My understanding is that this statement is not from Baha'u'llah but was a quotation from Manakji's letter. Manakji wrongly believed the Dasatir was an authentic text whereas it was probably

Re: Tests

2007-01-31 Thread smaneck
Why didn't God send any tests? Well, you could also ask for them. But God has been so bountiful to me on this account that I've never felt any compulsion to pray for tests. The information contained in this e-mail and any attachments thereto (e-mail) is sent by the Johnson County

Re: Tests

2007-02-01 Thread smaneck
Are you saying you think the answer to my question Does God intervene to make bad things happen so as to test people? is yes? Asking surely indicates wanting God to intervene to make something happen? Dear David, I'm not one to speculate on what God will or will not do. I think of

Re: Praying for peace

2007-02-08 Thread smaneck
Many people say prayers for peace. For there to peace requires people to turn away from evil. I was wondering how God could answer prayers for peace without violating free will. If an answer to a prayer means God making more peace then wouldn't this require Him intervening to make

Re: Tests

2007-02-08 Thread smaneck
I don't recall seeing this before. I think I know what the benefits of this world are, but what are teh benefits of the next world spoken about? Dear David, What the Bab is talking about is seeking heaven or paradise for its own sake instead of seeking God Himself. . The Muslim

Re: Tests

2007-02-20 Thread smaneck
How is one to determine whether they have enough tests in their life? And if we grow from tests aren't we supposed to want more? Yes, we are *supposed* to want more. But we don't do the determiantion of when we've had enough. Tests don't stop until we die in any case. warmest, Susan

Re: People of the Book

2007-02-21 Thread smaneck
While the Magi or Fire Worshippers are mentioned in the Qu'ran, I don't think they're counted as People of the Book. Of course some Muslim scholars have a lose interpretation of this, and I have heard of some Moghuls even justifying People of the Book status for Hindus and Buddhists.

Re: Tests

2007-02-21 Thread smaneck
Tests don't stop until we die in any case. Would you please tell me where in the writings it says that there will be no more tests in the worlds after this one? Dear Tim, I'm presuming that is the case because of what Abdu'l-Baha indicated about progress in the afterlife

Re: Tests

2007-02-23 Thread smaneck
It says in the Writings that God doesn't burden a soul beyond its capacity. I'm just wondering how one could determine what a person's capacity is, so as to know what being burdened beyond one's capacity would look like. According to the Writings those who have committed suicide

Re: Tests

2007-02-23 Thread smaneck
I always thought the proverb in question applied any and all tests. Dear Dean, The context in which I've read the proverb did not say anything about tests whatsoever. It seems to have more to do with our not feeling over-burdened by obligations. Here are the contexts in which I found the

Re: to say the truth

2007-02-23 Thread smaneck
Well, I am someone who likes clear answers, I suppose we all agree with the fact that a bahai can't say the truth everytime. Do we agree? Dear Hasan, If like could be that black and white, then we would tell the truth all the time.;-} warmest, Susan The information contained in

Re: to say the truth (in spanish, :) )

2007-02-24 Thread smaneck
Susan, please could you explain if the use of hikmat allows to lie in some instances? (I'm not talking about confessions) Dear Hasan, I know that Baha'is *did* use it as an excuse to lie on occasion. Whether that was right, I'm not prepared to say. The only instance I know of where

Re: to say the truth (in spanish, :) )

2007-02-25 Thread smaneck
Thanks for answer, if this armed man says that he will kill everyone who is bahá'í? We accept this as martyrdom? Could this be martyrdom or foolishness? Dear Hasan, If such a person were to ask me where the Baha'is were, I would not tell him and I might even give some false information

ABS Annual Meeting

2007-03-05 Thread smaneck
31st Annual Conference of the Association for Bahá'í Studies-North America Mississauga, Ontario - August 16-19, 2007 Scholarship and Community-Building Theme Statement Community is the organic entity in which human spiritual and material potential can emerge. It is where people interact and

Tabernacle of Unity

2007-03-05 Thread smaneck
To all members of the WINEWS, ACADEMICS, and HIGHERED: The Wilmette Institute is pleased to offer a three-month web-based course on an important new translation of tablets by Baha'u'llah, *The Tabernacle of Unity,* starting March 15. The main tablet was revealed for Manikchi Limji Hataria, a

Re: Tabernacle of Unity

2007-03-06 Thread smaneck
Dear Donald, I'll have to ask Rob, but in my experience anyone who needs the discount gets it. warmest, Susan - Original Message - From: Donald Strong [EMAIL PROTECTED] Date: Tuesday, March 6, 2007 3:27 am Subject: Tabernacle of Unity To: Baha'i Studies bahai-st@list.jccc.edu

Re: Too stupid to be saved?

2007-03-16 Thread smaneck
The Baha'i Writings say one must believe in and follow the laws of the Manifestation to be saved: Dear David, Baha'u'llah doesn't use the word 'saved' that passage you cited. I don't think it is our place to make judgements as to why others believe or don't believe. We should concern

Re: Too stupid to be saved?

2007-03-17 Thread smaneck
Baha'u'llah doesn't use the word 'saved' that passage you cited. Okay, but doesn't it seem obvious that we can infer that meaning? Dear David, It is a misleading appropriation of Christian vocabulary. Baha'is are not obsessed with individual salvation the way Christians are and we shouldn't

Re: beast

2007-03-18 Thread smaneck
Who can say what this mean: And cast him into the bottomless pit, and shut him up, and set a seal upon him And who can say who is that beast, is it the Umayyad? Dear Hasan, That's what Abdu'l-Baha indicates: The beast that ascendeth out of the bottomless pit shall war against them, and

Re: Genius

2007-03-18 Thread smaneck
Dear Hasan, You mean genies or jinn, not genius. :-} Besides the quote from the letter written on behalf of the Guardian which you cited, I can add a little more which I think I got from Khazeh at one point or another. According to the Qur'an the Jinn are made from fire, unlike humanity

<    1   2   3   4   5   >