well said... i wud be happy if the discussion board in rediff for music reviews are totally ripped off...
On Tue, Oct 21, 2008 at 8:36 PM, Arijit Debnath <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Fools rely on threads/blogs to comment Rahman's music as > dissapointing.... > > Arijit > > 2008/10/21 Jahanzeb Farooq <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > > > The true fact is you are disapponinted with the music but its only >> > you. >> >> it is not only me. a proof is comments on the blog we are currently >> discussing. >> >> > they go to him because of the "MASS", CURRENT >> > MARKET not the "1996 popularity"..and these cant be given only by >> > Fans but a lot lot more people need to like the music. >> >> of course i and everyone here knows this. the point here what we are >> discussing is that with yuvvraaj ARR could not deliver an album which >> is as highly liked by the masses as taal, dil se etc. >> >> > here is the catch with ARR - The MASS you are talking about is >> > the "FANS". If ARR fans like it then it already reached the mass. be >> > assured about it. >> >> i don't agree. the masses are not fans. there are lots of his albums >> which were not liked by masses but of course were liked by his fans. >> >> > If you dont like it guess what? I pity you. You are >> > one of those small..tiny winy group who doesnt likes this..!!!! >> > sorry!! no Offense >> >> i never said i am not liking it, i am only saying it is not one of >> ARR's bests. and disappoints as album of a Ghai-ARR combo especially >> after masterpiece Taal. >> >> --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com <arrahmanfans%40yahoogroups.com>, >> "arunsoft2k" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> >> wrote: >> >> > >> > Jahanzeb, >> > >> > The true fact is you are disapponinted with the music but its only >> > you..but there is something called difference of opininion!!! >> > >> > a lot of people both here and orkut ARRahman communitiy..liked the >> > music. well you can always compare with Taal, Dilse, Rangeela. but >> > really you should spend some time reading the reviews came out when >> > those were out. I'm sure there will be another "Janhanzeb" trying to >> > make people understand how Arr disapointed yet again. but outof >> > nowhere it becomes a classic after a year for some of those. >> > >> > I have nothing against your taste...but Here is the most imp point >> > you migt havs missed!! >> > 1.ARR is the highly paid music director...paid big bugs!!! >> > 2."Big deal" producers still trying to get ARR as their film music >> > director. They wait more time than even a ARR-Fan waiting for ARR's >> > release. >> > Do you think the producers like ARRs divine feelings??..or they like >> > his recording theater,or place where he lives or they liked him >> > because he composed Roja, Dil se, Rangeela(hahaaaaaa). na na >> > na..this aint joke!! they go to him because of the "MASS", CURRENT >> > MARKET not the "1996 popularity"..and these cant be given only by >> > Fans but a lot lot more people need to like the music. >> > >> > but here is the catch with ARR - The MASS you are talking about is >> > the "FANS". If ARR fans like it then it already reached the mass. be >> > assured about it.If you dont like it guess what? I pity you. You are >> > one of those small..tiny winy group who doesnt likes this..!!!! >> > sorry!! no Offense...you asked for it bro.!! >> > >> > dont glue your eyes and ears to your music system with Yuvvraaj >> > playing..just relax yourslef.focus on your normal day to day life >> > and have this song played in yoru car,living room when you have >> > dinner..rom nowhere it hits you like a storm...!! >> > >> > --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com <arrahmanfans%40yahoogroups.com>, >> "Jahanzeb Farooq" >> > <jahanzebtippu@> wrote: >> > > >> > > man you have to accept it. although it is growing on us and we >> > have >> > > started liking more compared to the first time, but the fact >> > remains >> > > that it is not something liked by the masses. only one song Tu >> > meri >> > > dost would be liked by the masses but not the rest. even recent >> > ARR >> > > albums had many songs loved by masses (and critics) e.g., Tere >> > bina, >> > > Mayya mayya, Barso re (Guru), Pappu, Aditi, Kahin to (JTYJN) etc >> > etc. >> > > Furthermore the fact remains that Yuvvraaj does not have even a >> > single >> > > song which can be called just mibdblowing or plain awesome as per >> > the >> > > ARR standards etc. comparing to Taal it still remains a HUGE >> > > disappointment, if not for us (ARR fans) certainly it is for >> > masses. >> > > the weakest songs of Dil se, Taal or Bombay are still better than >> > > strongest song/s of Yuvvraaj. >> > > >> > > lets analyze it. Mastam mastam is good, it grows, melody is >> > Rahmanish, >> > > Sonu is perfect, but again it is not something instantly loved by >> > > masses. Zindagi is again good but nothing exceptional. it heavily >> > > relies on vocals, too little music, no traditional ARR interludes >> > etc. >> > > Man mohini is very good but alas too short, which is completely >> un- >> > > understandable, why did not ARR put a few more minutes to it??? >> > > strange. Dil ka risha is very good again, orchestra is great. it >> > would >> > > be loved more than Zindagi, Mastam, Man mohini by masses. however >> > it >> > > is a very situational song, not something you will find people >> > humming >> > > or playing on streets etc. Shano shano is one of the weakest songs >> > of >> > > ARR ever, people will not find anything special in it. it is not >> > very >> > > different than dozens of Pritam and others' songs releasing every >> > day. >> > > even Pappu (JTYJN) was far far far far far far better. so at the >> > end >> > > the only song remains is Tu muskura which will be liked by the >> > masses >> > > but again there is nothing very special in it. it is likable but >> > not >> > > something blockbuster etc. it is in the league of recent Tu bin >> > bataye >> > > (RDB) and Milo wahan wahan (Ada) though the two were far far >> > better. >> > > just think of some of ARR's biggest hits and ask yourself honestly >> > can >> > > we compare any of Yuvvraaj's songs with Satrangi, Dil se, Chaiyyan >> > > chaiyyan (Dil se) Taal se taal, ishq bina, ramta jogi (Taal), >> > Kehna hi >> > > kya, Hamma hamma, Tu hi re (Bombay) and those from Rangeela, >> > Saathiya, >> > > Lagaan, Roja, Sapnay etc etc or even recent lesser hits rang de >> > > basanti (RDB), khwaja mere khwaja, azeem-o-shaan (JA) etc and >> > those >> > > from Guru etc. and you will get the answer. >> > > >> > > hence i am certainly not surprised by the reactions of masses. ARR >> > > here really disappointed, because of Ghai-ARR combo people were >> > > expecting something as fantastic as Taal, but there is no >> > comparison >> > > between Taal and Yuvvraaj. at least if you ask me if i give 10/10 >> > to >> > > Taal i will give only 4/10 to Yuvvraaj. ARR should have >> > experimented >> > > in some other low profile album but certainly not in Yuvvraaj. >> > also a >> > > film solely based on music certainly required some instantly >> > classic >> > > music, like Taal. >> > > >> > > --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com <arrahmanfans%40yahoogroups.com>, >> "Chord" <purevibz@> wrote: >> > > > >> > > > Did anyone read the comments that followed the review? I can't >> > > > believe the ignorance, stupidity, and narrow mindedness of some >> > > people >> > > > out there!!!! >> > > > >> > > > >> > > > --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com<arrahmanfans%40yahoogroups.com>, >> "Sai Theodore" >> > <saitheodore@> >> > > > wrote: >> > > > > >> > > > > http://www.rediff.com/movies/2008/oct/21yuv.htm >> > > > > >> > > > >> > > >> > >> >> > >
