I had some cases, when path INTEGRATE.HKL -> Aimless gave data, from which it was not possible to solve structure by Phaser. It looked like structure solved, but then I got 45-50% Rwork/free. There were no problems with XDS_ASCCI.HKL -> Aimless (Not scale, just merge) path.
Jan

On 11/24/2016 06:44 PM, Nishant Varshney wrote:
Thanks everyone  for your replies.
cheers
Nishant

On Mon, Nov 21, 2016 at 6:03 PM, Wei Wang <ww2...@columbia.edu <mailto:ww2...@columbia.edu>> wrote:

    My personal test shows that the different paths vary little with
    each other, as long as the scaling is done only once. Another way
    could be what is said on XDSwiki: Minimum I/Sigma=50,
    CORRECTIONS=MODULATION, NBATCH=1. Then the XDS_ASCII.HKL is handed
    over to Aimless with default settings.

    One question raised is that how can I move the 'aliens' with Z>20
    to REMOVE.HKL? I didn't find answer yet. Maybe I didn't read
    carefully over the documents, but I would appreciate it if someone
    can teach me.

    Regards,

    Wei


    On Mon, Nov 21, 2016 at 6:13 AM, Tim Gruene <tim.gru...@psi.ch
    <mailto:tim.gru...@psi.ch>> wrote:

        Dear Nishant,

        XDS_ASCII.HKL contains corrected, scaled, but not merged
        reflections.
        You can specifically ask XDS to merge your data, but I would
        not do so unless
        really necessary - you loose a lot of information.

        I would like to offer a different opinion to Graeme's:
        You can read XDS_ASCII.HKL into pointless and aimless and
        provide aimless with
        the option 'onlymerge'. This way aimless merges the data, but
        it does not
        rescale them.

        XDS performs a couple of corrections in the CORRECT step, the
        output of which
        is XDS_ASCII.HKL. And while XDS is extremely well documented,
        I am not sure
        aimless takes into account how XDS treats the data. I would
        therefore trust
        the step of scaling to the same author and continue with
        XDS_ASCII.HKL.

        Best,
        Tim


        On Monday, November 21, 2016 11:37:15 AM Nishant Varshney wrote:
        > Dear All,
        >
        > Just to understand more, the XDS_ASCII.HKL file generated
        after running XDS
        > contains scaled and merged reflections?
        >
        > Moreover, what happens exactly, if you use XDS_ASCII.HKL
        file in AIMLESS
        > instead of INTEGRATE.HKL file??
        >
        > I ran AIMLESS separately, one using already scaled
        XDS_ASCII.HKL and
        > another using INTEGRATE.HKL and I found that in the run
        using XDS_ASCII.HKL
        > little lesser total number of observation but marginally
        better statistics.
        >
        > Thanks
        > Nishant
        >
        > On Thu, Nov 17, 2016 at 10:08 PM, Andreas Forster
        <docandr...@gmail.com <mailto:docandr...@gmail.com>>
        >
        > wrote:
        > > Dear Wei,
        > >
        > > if you process your data with XDS, the best is probably to
        do the scaling
        > > in XDS (CORRECT) and be done with it.  If you want to use
        Aimless for
        > > merging, you can turn off scaling with the ONLYMERGE
        keyword or use SCALES
        > > CONSTANT.
        > >
        > > All best.
        > >
        > >
        > > Andreas
        > >
        > > On Thu, Nov 17, 2016 at 9:40 PM, Wei Wang
        <ww2...@columbia.edu <mailto:ww2...@columbia.edu>> wrote:
        > >> Hi,
        > >>
        > >> Is there a way to let xds_par use less than all
        processors/threads on the
        > >> machine? Sometimes I would like to process something else
        while XDS is
        > >> running.
        > >>
        > >> Another question is related to the scaling procedure. My
        understanding is
        > >> that the XDS already does the scaling during correction.
        So if I follow
        > >> the
        > >> XDS-Aimless route, then probably I should let Aimless do
        "skip scaling
        > >> and
        > >> only merge"? Please elucidate me on this issue.
        > >>
        > >> Regards,
        > >>
        > >> Wei
        >
        > --
        > Dr. Nishant Kumar Varshney,
        > IISc-ICTP Fellow
        > XRD2 Beamline, Elettra-Sincrotrone,
        > In Area Science Park,
        > Basovizza, S.S. 14, Km 163,5,
        > 34012 Trieste, Italy
        > +39-040-375 8737 <tel:%2B39-040-375%208737> (office ESP4 P1 031)
        > +39-040-375-8435 <tel:%2B39-040-375-8435> (XRD2 beamline)
        > +39 3318809798 <tel:%2B39%203318809798> (Mobile)
        --
        --
        Paul Scherrer Institut
        Dr. Tim Gruene
        - persoenlich -
        Principal Investigator
        Biology and Chemistry
        OFLC/102
        CH-5232 Villigen PSI

        Phone: +41 (0)56 310 5297 <tel:%2B41%20%280%2956%20310%205297>

        GPG Key ID = A46BEE1A





--
Dr. Nishant Kumar Varshney,
IISc-ICTP Fellow
XRD2 Beamline, Elettra-Sincrotrone,
In Area Science Park,
Basovizza, S.S. 14, Km 163,5,
34012 Trieste, Italy
+39-040-375 8737 (office ESP4 P1 031)
+39-040-375-8435 (XRD2 beamline)
+39 3318809798 (Mobile)

Reply via email to