On Tue, 15 Aug 2023 16:41:35 GMT, Lance Andersen <lan...@openjdk.org> wrote:

>> This PR  updates the extra field validation added as part of 
>> [JDK-8302483](https://bugs.openjdk.org/browse/JDK-8302483)  to deal with 
>> issues seen with 3rd party tools/libraries where a ZipException may be 
>> encountered when opening select APK, ZIP or JAR files.  Please see refer to 
>> the links provided at the end the description for the more information ::
>> 
>>> ZipException: Invalid CEN header (invalid zip64 extra data field size)
>> 
>> 1. Extra field includes padding :
>> 
>> 
>> ----------------#1--------------------
>> [Central Directory Header]
>>   0x3374: Signature    : 0x02014b50
>>   0x3378: Created Zip Spec :    0xa [1.0]
>>   0x3379: Created OS   :    0x0 [MS-DOS]
>>   0x337a: VerMadeby    :    0xa [0, 1.0]
>>   0x337b: VerExtract   :    0xa [1.0]
>>   0x337c: Flag      :   0x800
>>   0x337e: Method     :    0x0 [STORED]
>>   0x3380: Last Mod Time  : 0x385ca437 [Thu Feb 28 20:33:46 EST 2008]
>>   0x3384: CRC       : 0x694c6952
>>   0x3388: Compressed Size :   0x624
>>   0x338c: Uncompressed Size:   0x624
>>   0x3390: Name Length   :   0x1b
>>  0x3392: Extra Length  :    0x7
>>              [tag=0xcafe, sz=0, data= ]
>>                              ->[tag=cafe, size=0]
>>   0x3394: Comment Length :    0x0
>>   0x3396: Disk Start   :    0x0
>>   0x3398: Attrs      :    0x0
>>   0x339a: AttrsEx     :    0x0
>>   0x339e: Loc Header Offset:    0x0
>>   0x33a2: File Name    : res/drawable/size_48x48.jpg
>> 
>> 
>> The extra field tag of `0xcafe` has its data size set to `0`.  and the extra 
>> length is `7`.   It is expected that you can use the  tag's data size to 
>> traverse the extra fields.
>> 
>> 
>> 2. The [BND tool](https://github.com/bndtools/bnd) added [problematic data 
>> to the extra field](https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/FELIX-6622):
>> 
>> 
>> ----------------#359--------------------
>> [Central Directory Header]
>>    0x600b4: Signature        : 0x02014b50
>>    0x600b8: Created Zip Spec :       0x14 [2.0]
>>    0x600b9: Created OS       :        0x0 [MS-DOS]
>>    0x600ba: VerMadeby        :       0x14 [0, 2.0]
>>    0x600bb: VerExtract       :       0x14 [2.0]
>>    0x600bc: Flag             :      0x808
>>    0x600be: Method           :        0x8 [DEFLATED]
>>    0x600c0: Last Mod Time    : 0x2e418983 [Sat Feb 01 17:12:06 EST 2003]
>>    0x600c4: CRC              : 0xd8f689cb
>>    0x600c8: Compressed Size  :      0x23e
>>    0x600cc: Uncompressed Size:      0x392
>>    0x600d0: Name Length      :       0x20
>>    0x600d2: Extra Length     :        0x8
>>              [tag=0xbfef, sz=61373, data=        
>>   0x600d4: Comment Length   ...
>
> Lance Andersen has updated the pull request incrementally with one additional 
> commit since the last revision:
> 
>   Revise retrieval of jdk.util.zip.disableZip64ExtraFieldValidation and tweak 
> a comment

src/jdk.zipfs/share/classes/jdk/nio/zipfs/ZipFileSystem.java line 3100:

> 3098:                     if (sz == 0) {
> 3099:                         if ( csize == ZIP64_MINVAL || size == 
> ZIP64_MINVAL ||
> 3100:                                 locoff == ZIP64_MINVAL) {

Minor nit but you can drop the space in "( csize)" and put the third condition 
on L3099 to make it easier to read.

For the comment, it looks like it is missing a comma after "== 0". Either that 
or change it to start with "Some older version of Apache Ant and Apache Commons 
...".

-------------

PR Review Comment: https://git.openjdk.org/jdk/pull/15273#discussion_r1294956354

Reply via email to