Hi Gerhard, seems the community is leaning towards a new submodule (Cagatay's -1 is only one of the many votes). But - as Mario said - let the code speak first!
regards, Martin On 4/9/08, Scott O'Bryan <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > I think so too. Having a sub-project of a sub-project might be a little > infrastructure heavy, there is nothing to say that Sev-en couldn't > become it's own MyFaces subproject that's intended to be used in a > MyFaces/Orchestra type environment. > > I also agree it should my a MyFaces wide decision because it impacts > expectations on the renderkits. > > Scott > > Kito D. Mann wrote: > > I think Mario has made some very good points... > > > > > >> -----Original Message----- > >> From: Mario Ivankovits [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] > >> Sent: Wednesday, April 09, 2008 5:14 AM > >> To: MyFaces Development > >> Subject: Re: [proposal] jsf validation with annotations > >> > >> Hi! > >> > >>> my position on this is we could make sev-en part of orchestra, if the > >>> orchestra crew really, really wants it. If not, this should just be a > >>> separate sub-module in MyFaces. It is interesting enough to stand on > >>> its own. > >>> > >>> > >> First, Orchestra is part of the MyFaces community, so it really, really > >> should be a decision the MyFaces community felt, and not a "Orchestra > >> Team" only one. > >> > >> Anyway, I think this is a question on how we position Orchestra. > >> If it is a strong position against JBoss Seam, then it probably might > >> make sense to include everything which makes life easier for the > >> developer into Orchestra - just as Seam tries to do. > >> However, then we loose one of the strongest arguments pro Orchestra: > >> Being a lightweight Conversation-Centric Library. > >> > >> If, we could add it as sub-module to Orchestra, but I think the best > >> place for sev-en (would like to see a new name anyway) is to be a > >> submodule of MyFaces. But first I'd like to see the technical details > >> of > >> how the sev-en core works. e.g. in the examples I've seen a lot of > >> converter wrapper stuff ... > >> > >> Building an official MyFaces Maven Artifact which bootup a development > >> environment (MyFaces Fullstack) with what we think on need for > >> development of any-range-sized applications would be more approriate > >> then. Such a project could include sev-en too. > >> > >> Ciao, > >> Mario > >> > > > > > > -- http://www.irian.at Your JSF powerhouse - JSF Consulting, Development and Courses in English and German Professional Support for Apache MyFaces
