NO!

Sorry, not correct. I'll state it again and this time with nothing else so it's clear:

Product searching in OFBiz does NOT use Lucene.

Please keep researching, and then feel free to continue this discussion.

-David

On Sep 10, 2008, at 7:56 AM, madppiper wrote:


Ah, yes indeed.

Sorry, about my mumbling today. To be a tiny bit more specific. I am of course only referring to the indexed product search. I know that Solr is
based on Lucene and that both use a similar way of indexing new listed
products (that is by adding, updating,removing new entities from/to the
index through XML files).

From as much as I understand, Lucene is the main search engine used within OFBiz (I hope we are NOT relying on cached Mysql-native Fulltext Queries here). New Products are added to or removed from the IndexTree through a xml script (just as they would in Solr). Lucene then provides the rest of the
OFBiz environment with a regular search mechanism, as well as ranked
indexing, sorting and yadayadayada.

Lucene however, does not allow advanced Facetting, nor is it a standalone application. Both of these advantages are something that Solr provides.
Therefore it would be great if one could easily switch both search
engines...


David E Jones wrote:


While this is an interesting discussion, I think you need to do more
research and be more specific before you can start a discussion.

It sounds like you are talking specifically about the product
searching, but please be explicit about the type of data you'd like to
search.

If it is about product searching then please do more research because
that does not use Lucene.

Also, in what was is Lucene "proprietary" or in other words, how is
solr less proprietary than Lucene? Sorry, that commented just sounded
really funny.

-David


On Sep 10, 2008, at 6:46 AM, madppiper wrote:


Hi,

I was curious whether it would be possible to replace the
proprietary Lucene
engine with solr ( http://apache.org/solr www.apache.org/solr ). The
question I am asking is because that could increase the overall
performance
and also allow the fancy facetting.

So in case it is possible (it should be: solr is based on lucene):
how are
products/catalogs added to lucene right now? is lucene running on a
certain
port? if so, would it be possible to simply switch ports?

Cheers,
Paul
--
View this message in context:
http://www.nabble.com/Replacing-Lucene-with-Solr-tp19412826p19412826.html
Sent from the OFBiz - Dev mailing list archive at Nabble.com.





--
View this message in context: 
http://www.nabble.com/Replacing-Lucene-with-Solr-tp19412826p19414154.html
Sent from the OFBiz - Dev mailing list archive at Nabble.com.


Reply via email to