> You seem to be thinking in terms of improving the
> hard-wired defaults.   What I'd like is a "style"
> mechanism that lets a user develop a set of defaults.

Finale's libraries are supposed to do this.  The problem is that there are
so many different library types, that you must load seven or eight different
libraries to make a "style change."  I recommend that the library mechanism
be made more flexible.

For example:
One could theoretically make a "pseudo-Henle" library, with font
definitions, line thicknesses, slur and tie definitions, and almost all the
other settings.  The big problem becomes the articulations and expressions,
which are harder to manage.  When creating the library, you could specify
which settings you wanted to include in the library, and which settings not
to include (you would not want page-layout settings, for example).

RP's "Settings Scrapbook" plugin currently attempt something like this, but
does not have access to all of the settings in Finale (especially the newer
ones); with complete access for plugin developers from Coda, this entire
functionality could be done in a plugin.

But really, I think that Coda should start out with one or several initial
templates that were more professional: a classical template with better line
thicknesses, slur and tie settings, etc... if Coda wants specifics, they
should see J. Gebauer's page "Get the best out of Finale"
http://ourworld.compuserve.com/homepages/J_Gebauer/  The classical template
could also use a title font that was not quite so large, and a bold
"composer" box.

A few more suggestions:

The tenuto mark, as has been frequently mentioned on the list, is too thin.
Instead of modofying the Maestro font, which would create versioning
problems for everyone, the tenuto should be a graphical articulation (4.5
EVPUS thickness?).

When "Add group and bracket"ing, the brackets/braces should be closer to the
staff.  I don't think that there is a default setting for this; it must be
changed manually after-the-fact.

Another thing that would make Finale signifcantly more professional
"out-of-the-box" would be automatic "Patterson Beaming."  If they could get
Robert to give-away/sell/license his code, it should be fairly easy to
integrate this directly into Finale, and would make the scores more
professional-looking by default.

Lastly, note-spacing music with lyrical melismas often produces very bad
results.  The lyrics are wide, and Finale thinks they collide with the next
beat, even though on paper they don't.  A more-intelligent spacing mechanism
that calculated where lyrics were actually going to collide would improve
the spacing of a lot of vocal music.

** ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ **
**   Benjamin Smedberg, Director of Music    **
**   St. Patrick's Church, Washington D.C.   **
**  VOX 202-347-2713 x102 - FAX 202-347-1401 **
**           [EMAIL PROTECTED]          **
**             "Soli Deo Gloria"             **
** ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ **


_______________________________________________
Finale mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://mail.shsu.edu/mailman/listinfo/finale

Reply via email to