Chris writes:

>composer = "Composer"; (Initials then Surname, eg. "J. S. Bach")

What about names like "C. M. von Weber"? On the one hand, the
surname is "von Weber" (and not just "Weber"), but on the other
hand, in a composer's index, I would look under "W" rather than
under "v".
What about the format "<surname>, <initial|first name>*",
e.g. "von Weber, C. M."?

>instrument = "Whatever";

General MIDI (GM) defines 128 instruments; maybe we optionally want
to specify a MIDI instrument that comes close (perhaps as a separate
header field midi_instrument).

>date = "1882"; (if known)

I would like to suggest to optionally allow to specify
month and day. Using a fully-fledged standard date format like
GMT probably would be overkill; but with existing software in
mind (including standard databases software) that is able to parse
and operate on such standardized formats, one might at least want
to keep compatible.

Perhaps we want to have separate fields for
- the date when the composition was finished, and
- the date when it was performed for the first time?

>style = "Style" - Early
>                  Mediaeval
>                  Renaissance
>                  Baroque
>                  Classical
>                  Romantic
>                  Modern
>                  Jazz
>                  Ragtime
>                  Blues

What about the category (chant, song, fuga, sonata, chamber music,
missa, symphony, opera, ...)? What about hierarchical ordered styles?

E.g.

Mediaeval
        Gregorian Chant
                Ordinarium
                Graduale
        Early Multi-Voice Music (sorry, don't know the english term ;-)
                Parallel Organum
                Faux Bordun
        Troubadours
        Notre Dame Epoche
        Ars Antiqua
        Ars Nova
Jazz
        Ragtime
        Spiritual/Gospel
        New Orleans/Dixieland
        Bebop
        Swing
                Combo
                Big Band
        Cool
        Free
Rock
        Blues
        Rock & Roll
        Soft
        Hard
        Heavy Metal
Pop
        60s
        70s
        80s
        90s

etc.

However, it is quite a difficult task to find a good hierarchy, and it
may be even more difficult to classify single pieces...
Perhaps there are existing catalogs of music which structures that may
also applied on mutopia?

Bye,
     Juergen

Reply via email to