<<I have become aware of what seems to be an element of disdain among some (many?) JMDLers for anyone who doesn't "cover" Joni's music "creatively" and this awareness has led to a sense of discomfort about performing Joni's music anymore anywhere.>>
I think you may be a bit over-sensitive on this issue, Marian...I've obviously been pretty tuned in to discussion about covers here, and I can't recall anyone expressing "disdain" over a lack of creativity...I admit, I take a special delight in hearing a singer or band take one of Joni's compositions where it's never been before, or simply being creative in their song choice. But I think there's a value in them all! When I hear your beautiful singing & playing, I hear your intense & sincere love of Joni's singing and guitar styling that shines through every time! I loved Jarrett's take on "All I Want", it just surprised me that for an artist who is sometimes given to extensive improvisation, he plays this one fairly straight up, and in less than 3 minutes. I also very much appreciated what Fred added to the discussion regarding the track. My main purpose in assembling this collection was to stimulate discussion about Joni's compositions and the interpretations of others. It's always disappointing to me that it so seldom takes place. And thankfully I was there when you were channelling Joni and playing "The Wolf That Lives In Lindsay"! I got chills, and still do whenever I hear it. There is always weighty artisitc value in performing and recording Joni's compositions, whether you're honoring her arrangements and tablature or re-inventing the composition in an innovative way. Bob NP: David Byrne, "you & eye"
