Brian Schweitzer wrote:
> On Sat, Apr 10, 2010 at 12:24 AM, Leiv Hellebo wrote:
> > >
> > > There's 5 positions I know of which I've not tried to
> handle, as they
> > > all seem more like Location-Artist ARs to me, should we
> ever get
> > > Locations...
> > > Artist-in-residence
> > > Conductor-in-residence
> > > Composer-in-residence
> > > Concert Producer
> > > Music Supervisor
>
>
> Googling conductor-in-residence readily gives plenty of artist-artist
> relations, so I don't understand why you think Location-Artist is
> better.
>
As for -in-residence, that was my thought
> initially, and I saw the same from Google. Then I looked through a lot
> of those Google hits (somewhere around 300 of them), and all but 3 or 4
> really boiled down to "Foo is/was conductor/artist in residence to
> foundation/location Pez which is also the organization behind/location
> of orchestra/choir Bar". Hence why Foo-Pez and Pez-Bar
> ('location-artist' ARs) would both make more sense to me than a direct
> artist-artist AR.
I see this, but although there is another organisation paying the bill
and it is tied to a particular location, I think perhaps
ConductorA is/was conductor in residence with OrchestraB
is better anyway. ConductorA needs the Orchestra(s) of the location more
than he needs the location, and it seems more of a musical relationship.
For those rare cases where it really is a direct
> artist-artist, those seemed safely enough cat-corners to leave out for
> the moment, both to avoid growing the proposal even more and to avoid
> that majority of location-artist ARs being entered as artist-artist ARs,
> since we're currently lacking both locations and those much more correct
> (imho) artist-location ARs.
AFAIK there is no influx of users dying to add this data or complaining
about the lack thereof either, so I agree there is no rush to add this.
Leiv / leivhe
_______________________________________________
MusicBrainz-style mailing list
MusicBrainz-style@lists.musicbrainz.org
http://lists.musicbrainz.org/mailman/listinfo/musicbrainz-style
