Nicolas Williams wrote: > On Fri, Jun 08, 2007 at 02:50:36PM -0700, johansen-osdev at sun.com wrote: >> Closed projects don't belong in an OpenSolaris consolidation. Can we >> agree and move on? > > No. Clearly until a project can operate privately at least until comes > to the ARC for the first time. > > The issue is when to force de-cloaking. > > That could be: (a) before any ARC case(s) is(are) filed, (b) at ARC case > filing time, (c) at ARC inception review time, (d) at ARC commitment > review time, (e) at c-team inception review time, (f) at c-team > commitment review time, (g) at integration time. > > (a) is best. Anything later than (c) is unnaceptable (at least it > appears to be for all who've said anything in this thread). You think > even (c) is unacceptable. I'd prefer (b) but find (c) livable. >
For the sake of clarity, the way I thought about this when talking with Garrett was "What's the absolute latest I would possibly tolerate open review happening", not "what would I like to see happen". I would hope there would need to be *very* strong justification provided to do anything other than a or b. (I'm not sure how you'd conduct an open review of a case they haven't filed yet...) -- Rich
