johansen-osdev at sun.com wrote: >>> Closed projects don't belong in an OpenSolaris consolidation. Can we >>> agree and move on? >> No. Clearly until a project can operate privately at least until comes >> to the ARC for the first time. > > A project can do whatever it wants. However, endorsed OpenSolaris > Projects should be operating openly. > >> The issue is when to force de-cloaking. > > I'm not interested in forcing anyone to be open. > > If a project wants to become open and be an endorsed OpenSolaris > Project, then what is the rationale for having closed review? I'm still > really confused about this. >
Alan's proposal was not related merely to projects on opensolaris.org, but projects integrating into OpenSolaris (i.e., ON, JDS, SFW, NWS, ...). A project that's on opensolaris.org but yet is holding closed reviews is obviously abominable in every respect, yes. -- Rich
