johansen-osdev at sun.com wrote:
>>> If a project wants to become open and be an endorsed OpenSolaris
>>> Project, then what is the rationale for having closed review? I'm still
>>> really confused about this.
>>>
>>>
>> Alan's proposal was not related merely to projects on opensolaris.org, but
>> projects integrating into OpenSolaris (i.e., ON, JDS, SFW, NWS, ...).
>>
>> A project that's on opensolaris.org but yet is holding closed reviews is
>> obviously abominable in every respect, yes.
>>
>
> I thought that the location of one's repository was separate from the
> OpenSolaris Project endorsement that a community group provides? Is
> this not so?
>
We are talking about ARC review of "projects" (note lower case "p") that
want to integrate into the code at some point (design review, really),
not community governance associated with Projects (note capital P).
-- Garrett
> -j
>
