>________________________________ > From: Rob Weir <[email protected]> >To: [email protected] >Sent: Saturday, June 2, 2012 6:20 PM >Subject: Re: Moving Category-B tarballs (was Re: [PROPOSAL] Starting the >graduation process) > >On Sat, Jun 2, 2012 at 6:04 PM, Joe Schaefer <[email protected]> wrote: >> This situation doesn't seem to be diffusing itself, >> even tho I have tried to explain that the 3.4.0 release >> deps "packaging" does not comply with infra policy. >> >> Surely there is a middle ground here- that the missing >> release deps package simply be generated from those >> tarballs in svn. So long as the source release uses >> >> deps from the (downloaded from mirrors) deps package >> >> instead of directly from svn, AFAICT this project will >> be in compliance with all legal and infra policies. >> > >So what would the status of the debs tarball be? Is it part of the >release? Do we vote on it? It has cat-b source in it, so one would >think that this could not be in a release, and not on the mirrors? Or >is there a recognized exception for dependencies provided as a >convenience?
There are few if any legal policy constraints on convenience artfacts- if you go through the mirrors you will find instances of non-open-source items (eg Windows installers, binaries, etc). Convenience artifacts do not form the basis of a release vote. I see no reason why the licensing on source artifacts that we distribute as a convenience should be more restrictive than the licensing on binaries- policy designed around Java artifacts isn't meant to place unreasonable limits on what AOO can reasonably distribute on the mirrors. Does that help? > > >> Whether that's best practice is debatable, but I don't >> believe it's so unreasonable that a rational person >> would withhold their participation in the project over it. >> >> >> HTH >> >> >> >> >>>________________________________ >>> From: Pedro Giffuni <[email protected]> >>>To: [email protected]; Jürgen Schmidt <[email protected]> >>>Sent: Saturday, June 2, 2012 5:52 PM >>>Subject: Re: Moving Category-B tarballs (was Re: [PROPOSAL] Starting the >>>graduation process) >>> >>>On 06/02/12 15:11, Juergen Schmidt wrote: >>>> ... >>>>> >>>>> Well I am a committer in the only big UNIX-like >>>>> distribution that is carrying Apache OpenOffice >>>>> nowadays. We would really like to use a source >>>>> distribution through ASF mirrors but since the ASF >>>>> doesn't provide one that works well we have been >>>>> rolling our own. Having a working source >>>>> distribution would help attract linux packagers, >>>>> I think. >>>>> >>>>> >>>> well if that is really the case you have failed on several levels >>>> >>>> - you didn't really have used or tried the source tarball >>>> - you didn't gave the appropriate and necessary feedback >>>> - you didn't helped to fix your concerns relating the source release. At >>>> least it seems you have some concerns >>> >>>Sure, I am not perfect but you can't really blame the >>>messenger if the package was broken. >>> >>>I have huge experience packaging stuff for my own selfish >>>purposes in the past (BRL-CAD, FEM utilities, stuff like that), >>>however I am not a ports committer/packager myself; >>>I am a src committer. You can see my work in some sound >>>drivers, the ext2fs implementation and some compiler >>>updates. I have been very busy between kernel coding >>>and the AOO SVN stuff to work also on the AOO >>>packaging. >>> >>>The vast packaging work in FreeBSD has been done by >>>Maho-san for several years and he has been so efficient >>>I haven't really had to intervene other than to give some >>>minor suggestions. He is a ports committer and I am so >>>glad he has been around to take care of things. >>> >>>I have been busy on some updates and I only noticed >>>a few days ago that we are not using the source tarballs >>>provided by Apache. I can't really test everything behind >>>a release and, with due respect, all I do is voluntary work >>>so I do have to spend my time in other activities too. >>> >>>I am attempting to provide some feedback here but >>>I would suggest you ask the guys doing Ubuntu or >>>Debian packaging if they are using the src tarballs >>>and how we can make the packaging easier. >>> >>>> That makes me really thinking ... >>> >>>Please stop imagining things. I know you guys are not >>>happy about having to do extra reshuffling in the tree >>>and playing with scripts to adapt things to what *I* >>>think is the Apache way. In all honesty let's admit I had >>>mentioned this was a grey area since a long time ago >>>and I have even offered to step aside and let >>>the project evolve on it's own. >>> >>>Pedro. >>> >>> >>> >>> > > >
