On 29 Aug 2002 at 21:27, Herb Chong wrote:

> simple. clear film to black has a larger dynamic range than orange base to
> black. don't mistake range for contrast itself. the scanner relies on and
> captures dynamic range, and stretching a negative's range after subtracting the
> orange mask and inverting in Photoshop starts to introduce color aliasing.

Hi Herb,

Not so if the dynamic pre-amplification is tailored to optimise the media being 
scanned or if you have a low noise image capture device followed by a precision 
low noise image sensor that can deliver 14bits per pixel?

The reality is that no system can never get back the information lost in the 
black of a shadow or in the blown out highlight in a slide. There are obviously 
certain lighting conditions natural or artificial that do suite slide films but 
where and what I shoot it's rarely the case hence my predilection for negative 
films. I'd rather a little noise than lack of detail.

BTW I have read your article "The Art of Scanning" and many more of a similar 
vein, I did appreciate your article but don't agree entirely :-)

Cheers,

Rob Studdert
HURSTVILLE AUSTRALIA
Tel +61-2-9554-4110
UTC(GMT)  +10 Hours
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://members.ozemail.com.au/~distudio/publications.html

Reply via email to