Hehehe... orang2 Islam emang selalu berebut unt jadi orang tolol nomor 1 di 
dunia.
 

From: Musik hari Ini <musikhari...@yahoo.com>
>To: "proletar@yahoogroups.com" <proletar@yahoogroups.com> 
>Sent: Friday, February 10, 2012 5:37 AM
>Subject: Re: [proletar] Re: Women Expose (safin _blanc yang berotak babi...)
>
>
>  
>Tidak ada yang pentig,tapi kanlu pernah joint accound dengan juspik tempo hari
>
>kalau lama malang melintang kudu tambah pinter tambah bijaksana
>siapa yang kabur?
>kalau cuman orang gila ya ditonton saja
>bukan begitu lumakin lama makin tolol!
>paham.
>
>________________________________
>From: item abu <item...@yahoo.com>
>To: "proletar@yahoogroups.com" <proletar@yahoogroups.com> 
>Sent: Thursday, February 9, 2012 5:31 PM
>Subject: Re: [proletar] Re: Women Expose (safin _blanc yang berotak babi...)
>
>
>  
>Hehehe ... si safin _blanc ini terus nuduh gua sbg Bukan Pedandaa. Nunjukin 
>betapa dungunya dia ini.
> 
>Orang di milis ini umumnya tau siapa Bukan Pedanda itu, dan orang2 yg udah 
>lama di milis jg tau bhw gua bukan Bukan Pedanda krn gua udah lama malang 
>melintang di milis. Makanya, orang2 di milis pada kabur kalo berhadapan dgn 
>gua, hehehe...
> 
> 
>
>From: safin _blanc <pandan.wangi...@gmail.com>
>>To: proletar@yahoogroups.com 
>>Sent: Thursday, February 9, 2012 11:20 AM
>>Subject: Re: [proletar] Re: Women Expose (safin _blanc yang berotak babi...)
>>
>>.. sdh gw bilang,.. lu ngaku ato tidak,.. gw kgak rugi juga kgak untung..
>>.. lu sendiri yg bisa ngitung, mau jujur apa kgak..
>>
>>.. gw kgak ngotot,.. santai aja....
>>.. yg suka ngotot dan sering kayak kambing kebakaran jenggot itu lu
>>sendiri, tem,..
>>..
>>
>>.. yg suka taik salman rusdi..
>>.. yg bejat!!!
>>.. dan bagian dari orang yg biadab!!!
>>..
>>..  ucapan slamat itu lebih cocok buat lu kunyah sendiri...
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>On 2/9/12, item abu <item...@yahoo.com> wrote:
>>> Jadi si dungu ini ngotot bhw gua orang yg sama dgn Bukan Pedanda.
>>>
>>> Selamat deh, lu udah nunjukin bhw lu ini orang super dungu, jauh lebih dungu
>>> dr orang2 Islam plus plus rata2 yg tahu siapa Bukan Pedanda itu dan bisa
>>> ngebedakan antara gua dgn Bukan Pedanda.
>>>
>>> Hehehe... semua orang Islam itu dungu, tp kadang ada jg yg super dungu.
>>>
>>>
>>> From: safin _blanc <pandan.wangi...@gmail.com>
>>>>To: proletar@yahoogroups.com
>>>>Sent: Wednesday, February 8, 2012 5:19 PM
>>>>Subject: Re: [proletar] Re: Women Expose (safin _blanc yang berotak
>>>> babi...)
>>>>
>>>>... omongan kayak gini cuman buang waktu aja tem,..
>>>>
>>>>.. lu ngaku ato tidak, kgak ada pengaruh apa2 buat gw.. kgak untung, kgak
>>>> rugi..
>>>>
>>>>yg jelas, lu orang yg mau ngelibas islam dan orang islam di milis
>>>>ini.. dan dimana-mana lu ngumbar fitnah dan caci maki islam..
>>>>
>>>>sehingga nato dan un yg dikendalikan amrik bisa melegitimate
>>>>pembantaian orang islam, wanita dan anak2..
>>>>
>>>>itu aja udah cukup menunjukkan kebejatan lu..
>>>>
>>>>singkat saja:
>>>>
>>>>b e j a t ......! ! ! bejat!!!
>>>>
>>>>
>>>>
>>>>On 2/8/12, item abu <item...@yahoo.com> wrote:
>>>>> Hehehe ... udah jelas lu ini tadinya mikir gua sama dgn Bukan Pedanda,
>>>>> sekarang ngakunya sengaja ngomong gitu, ga mau ngaku ketololan lu. Terus
>>>>> lu
>>>>> nambah kegoblokan lu dgn ga percaya atas omongan gua, bertentangan dgn
>>>>> ocehan lu sendiri.
>>>>>
>>>>> Emang orang Islam itu ga ada yg pintar, semuanya dungu, tanpa kecuali.
>>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>> From: safin _blanc <pandan.wangi...@gmail.com>
>>>>>>To: proletar@yahoogroups.com
>>>>>>Sent: Tuesday, February 7, 2012 8:36 AM
>>>>>>Subject: Re: [proletar] Re: Women Expose (safin _blanc yang berotak
>>>>>> babi...)
>>>>>>
>>>>>>.. lu yg goblog.. gw memang sengaja supaya lu berdua ngomong jujur..
>>>>>>
>>>>>>klo lu memang orang berbeda, coba lu kasih biodata lu disini..
>>>>>>nama: (kgak perlu asli)
>>>>>>umur: (72 taon, kt orang)
>>>>>>pkerjaan:
>>>>>>alamat: (yg ini cukup negara mana, gw kgak mau lu dibunuh terorist,
>>>>>>keenakan lu nanti).
>>>>>>
>>>>>>itu aja..
>>>>>>
>>>>>>On Tue, Feb 7, 2012 at 5:13 AM, item abu <item...@yahoo.com> wrote:
>>>>>>
>>>>>>> **
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>> Goblok, gua bukan Bukan Pedanda.
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>> From: safin _blanc <pandan.wangi...@gmail.com>
>>>>>>> >To: proletar@yahoogroups.com
>>>>>>> >Sent: Tuesday, February 7, 2012 12:12 AM
>>>>>>> >Subject: Re: [proletar] Re: Women Expose (safin _blanc yang berotak
>>>>>>> babi...)
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>> >
>>>>>>> >..wah gw telat balas tulisan item yg belepotan taik salman rusdi
>>>>>>> > ini...
>>>>>>> >.. bukan kgak mau balas, soalnya gw lagi melancong ... capeknya masih
>>>>>>> >terasa..
>>>>>>> >
>>>>>>> >gini tem..
>>>>>>> >
>>>>>>> >gw kgak silau oleh tulisan pakar organisasi dunia yg didominasi amrik
>>>>>>> > sama
>>>>>>> >konco2nya yg  ngejelekin islam supaya mrk punya legitimasi ngebantai
>>>>>>> > orang
>>>>>>> >islam ...... apalagi tulisan yg ngaco seperti yg lu percaya itu.....
>>>>>>> > apa
>>>>>>> >perempuan disunat lalu kgak bisa beranak? bahkan bisa mati segala?...
>>>>>>> >tulisan pakar organisasi dunia yg ngawur, sama sekali kgak
>>>>>>> > kredibel.....
>>>>>>> >kgak perlu ada studi ilmiah utk bilang tulisan mereka ngawur..
>>>>>>> > kenyataan
>>>>>>> di
>>>>>>> >dunia nyata sdh jelas bhw statement mereka ngawur..
>>>>>>> >
>>>>>>> >dan lu percaya sama tulisan mereka? tentu saja lu percaya karena lu
>>>>>>> > memang
>>>>>>> >bagian dari orang yg mau melibas islam dan orang islam.. dimilis ini
>>>>>>> > ..
>>>>>>> and
>>>>>>> >beyond..
>>>>>>> >
>>>>>>> >setiap ada tulisan yg seperti ini lu telen bulat seperti lu telen taik
>>>>>>> >salman rusdi.... dan lu kgak punya malu sebarin tulisan konyol penuh
>>>>>>> >fitnah.. sama artinya dengan lu tukang fitnah juga...... jelas?
>>>>>>> >
>>>>>>> >.. ihh...
>>>>>>> >
>>>>>>> >
>>>>>>> >
>>>>>>> >
>>>>>>> >
>>>>>>> >
>>>>>>> >
>>>>>>> >
>>>>>>> >On Sat, Feb 4, 2012 at 10:41 AM, Bukan Pedanda
>>>>>>> > <bukan.peda...@yahoo.com
>>>>>>> >wrote:
>>>>>>> >
>>>>>>> >> **
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>> >>
>>>>>>> >>
>>>>>>> >>
>>>>>>> >>
>>>>>>> >> safin _blanc ini jelas berotak babi..
>>>>>>> >>
>>>>>>> >> Tanpa argumen ilmiah dia bilang kesimpulan pakar organisasi dunia
>>>>>>> >> itu
>>>>>>> >> "fitnah yg dilakukan orang2 yg mau ngelibas islam "
>>>>>>> >>
>>>>>>> >> Edan.
>>>>>>> >>
>>>>>>> >>
>>>>>>> >>
>>>>>>> >> --- In proletar@yahoogroups.com, safin _blanc <pandan.wangi558@...>
>>>>>>> wrote:
>>>>>>> >> >
>>>>>>> >> > .. apa gw bilang? titit lo memang sontoloyo..
>>>>>>> >> > .. bantah tuh kalo lu bisa bantah...
>>>>>>> >> > .. disertai bukti..
>>>>>>> >> >
>>>>>>> >> > .. kalo kgak, orang di milis ini akan ketawain lu..
>>>>>>> >> > ..
>>>>>>> >> >
>>>>>>> >> > Female genital mutilation or cutting (FGM/C) is the partial or
>>>>>>> >> > total
>>>>>>> >> > removal of the external genitalia – undertaken for cultural or
>>>>>>> >> > other
>>>>>>> >> > non-medical reasons – often causing severe pain and sometimes
>>>>>>> resulting
>>>>>>> >> in
>>>>>>> >> > prolonged bleeding, infection, infertility and even death.
>>>>>>> >> > .. ini fitnah yg dilakukan orang2 yg mau ngelibas islam, sehingga
>>>>>>> orang
>>>>>>> >> yg
>>>>>>> >> > bayar ongkos perang percaya bhw islam memang perlu dibasmi....
>>>>>>> >> > .. gw kgak pernah dengar ada cw yg mengalami seperti yg lu jadikan
>>>>>>> >> > referensi ini.. kecuali tentu saja rasa sakit. infeksi bisa
>>>>>>> >> > terjadi
>>>>>>> kalo
>>>>>>> >> > caranya kgak hygenis, tapi infertility? kematian?.. hah.. kgak
>>>>>>> >> > tahu
>>>>>>> malu
>>>>>>> >> > nyebar pitnah....
>>>>>>> >> >
>>>>>>> >> > .. sunat juga sakit, apa lu kgak sunat?
>>>>>>> >> > ..
>>>>>>> >> >
>>>>>>> >> >
>>>>>>> >> >
>>>>>>> >> > On Sat, Feb 4, 2012 at 4:22 AM, Bukan Pedanda <bukan.pedanda@
>>>>>>> ...>wrote:
>>>>>>> >> >
>>>>>>> >> > > **
>>>>>>> >>
>>>>>>> >> > >
>>>>>>> >> > >
>>>>>>> >> > >
>>>>>>> >> > > safin _blanc yang berotak babi dan berpengetahuan dangkal...
>>>>>>> >> > >
>>>>>>> >> > >
>>>>>>> http://www.un.org/apps/news/story.asp?Cr1=health&NewsID=37478&Cr=women
>>>>>>> >> > >
>>>>>>> >> > > --- In proletar@yahoogroups.com, safin _blanc <pandan.wangi558@>
>>>>>>> >> wrote:
>>>>>>> >> > > >
>>>>>>> >> > > > ..ngapain ngurus yg ginian, apa kgak ada kerjaan lain? gw kgak
>>>>>>> pernah
>>>>>>> >> > > > denger cw sekeliling gw yg complain soal ini.. termasuk bini
>>>>>>> >> > > > gw,..
>>>>>>> >> > > > ..cw juga kgak usil ngurusin laki2 yg sunat...
>>>>>>> >> > > >
>>>>>>> >> > > >
>>>>>>> >> > > > tp buat lu yg memang mau melibas islam dan orang islam di
>>>>>>> >> > > > milis
>>>>>>> ini,
>>>>>>> >> > > urusan
>>>>>>> >> > > > begini aja jadi besar..
>>>>>>> >> > > > ato barangkali bini lu kgak puas? klo dia kgak puas berarti
>>>>>>> >> > > > titit
>>>>>>> lu
>>>>>>> >> yg
>>>>>>> >> > > > sontoloyo....
>>>>>>> >> > > >
>>>>>>> >> > > >
>>>>>>> >> > > >
>>>>>>> >> > > >
>>>>>>> >> > > >
>>>>>>> >> > > > On Thu, Feb 2, 2012 at 9:03 AM, item abu <itemabu@> wrote:
>>>>>>> >> > > >
>>>>>>> >> > > > > **
>>>>>>> >> > > > >
>>>>>>> >> > > > >
>>>>>>> >> > > > > Hehehe... jadi lu sama sekali ga peduli dgn cewek2 yg
>>>>>>> >> > > > > dipotong
>>>>>>> >> itilnya
>>>>>>> >> > > > > itu, nurut lu, itu urusan mereka, bukan urusan lu.
>>>>>>> >> > > > >
>>>>>>> >> > > > >
>>>>>>> >> > > > >
>>>>>>> >> > > > >
>>>>>>> >> > > > > From: safin _blanc <pandan.wangi558@>
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >To: proletar@yahoogroups.com
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >Sent: Wednesday, February 1, 2012 7:24 AM
>>>>>>> >> > > > >
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >Subject: Re: [proletar] Women Expose Secret Genital Cutting
>>>>>>> Rite
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >lu usil kgak ada kerjaan ngurus itil cw.
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >itu urusan sesama perempuan..
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >lu memang tukang fitnah.
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >gw bilang kenyataan bhw banyak, banyak sekali muslimah yg
>>>>>>> >> bahagia..
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >lu yg penuh fitnah dalam ngelibas islam dan orang islam di
>>>>>>> milis
>>>>>>> >> > > ini,...
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >yang..gw yakin kgak bahagia..
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >kasihaaaannn...
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >On Wed, Feb 1, 2012 at 5:29 AM, item abu <itemabu@> wrote:
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> **
>>>>>>> >> > > > >
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >>
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >>
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> Jadi lu suka ngeliat dan ngedenger cewek tetangga lu
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> ketawa2,
>>>>>>> >> > > berarti lu
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> ga ngikutin ajaran Islam yg nindas cewek. Tetangga lu itu
>>>>>>> udah
>>>>>>> >> > > disunat
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> belum itilnya?
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >>
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> Hehehe.... spt yg gua bilang sebelumnya, orang Islam plus
>>>>>>> plus
>>>>>>> >> itu
>>>>>>> >> > > ga
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> peduli sama sekali dgn nasib cewek yg ditindas di negara
>>>>>>> syariat
>>>>>>> >> > > iblis,
>>>>>>> >> > > > > spt
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> cewek yg diperkosa di waktu msh anak2, cewek yg disunat
>>>>>>> itilnya,
>>>>>>> >> > > cewek
>>>>>>> >> > > > > yg
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> disiksa di rumahnya oleh lakinya dsb.
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >>
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >>
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >>
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> From: safin _blanc <pandan.wangi558@>
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >To: proletar@yahoogroups.com
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >Sent: Tuesday, January 31, 2012 9:19 AM
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >Subject: Re: [proletar] Women Expose Secret Genital
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> > Cutting
>>>>>>> >> Rite
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >>
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >tetangga gw 8 bersaudara, perempuan semua... udah pada
>>>>>>> kawin,
>>>>>>> >> dan
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >berbahagia.. kalo ngumpul ketawa mereka lepas sampai
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> > kita
>>>>>>> >> > > tetangganya
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >merasakan kegembiraan mrk.
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >gw pernah ikut latihan chen-qi di china... suhu kita
>>>>>>> bilang,..
>>>>>>> >> > > ngesek
>>>>>>> >> > > > > itu
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >perlu, tp orgasm merupakan pemborosan energi yg besar..
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >supaya ingat, si item sinting ini adalah orang yg mau
>>>>>>> melibas
>>>>>>> >> > > islam dan
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >orang islam di milis ini...
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >
>>>>>>> >>  > > > > >> >On Tue, Jan 31, 2012 at 6:11 AM, item abu <itemabu@>
>>>>>>> wrote:
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> **
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >>
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >>
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >>
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> Islam itu emang laknatan lil alamin
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >>
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >>
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> PAKISTAN-INDIA
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> Women Expose Secret Genital Cutting Rite
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> By Zofeen Ebrahim
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >>
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> KARACHI, Jan 30, 2012 (IPS) - "It was a dark and dingy
>>>>>>> room,
>>>>>>> >> > > where an
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> elderly woman asked me to take off my panties, made me
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> sit
>>>>>>> >> on a
>>>>>>> >> > > low
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> wooden
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> stool with my legs parted and then did something…I
>>>>>>> screamed
>>>>>>> >> out
>>>>>>> >> > > in
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> pain,"
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> recalls Alefia Mustansir, 40, of her childhood
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> experience.
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >>
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> Her friend, Sakina Haider, remembers "putting up a
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> good
>>>>>>> >> fight"
>>>>>>> >> > > before
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> she
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> succumbed. "I was told by my grandmother that I was
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> being
>>>>>>> >> taken
>>>>>>> >> > > to
>>>>>>> >> > > > > the
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> doctor to address burning in the genital area when
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> soap
>>>>>>> went
>>>>>>> >> > > there
>>>>>>> >> > > > > while
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> bathing!"
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >>
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> Both Haider and Mustansir have refused to have their
>>>>>>> >> daughters
>>>>>>> >> > > > > undergo
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> circumcision or female genital mutilation/cutting
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> (FGM/C),
>>>>>>> >> the
>>>>>>> >> > > > > Dawoodi
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> Bohras' best-kept secret until young women from the
>>>>>>> community
>>>>>>> >> > > first
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> began
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> to speak up against it a few years ago.
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >>
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> Bohras, a sub-sect of Ismaili Shia Muslims, are a
>>>>>>> tight-knit
>>>>>>> >> > > > > community,
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> with a majority residing in India and Pakistan, and
>>>>>>> >> estimated to
>>>>>>> >> > > > > number
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> two
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> million the world over.
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >>
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> An article in the Dec. 12 issue of the popular Indian
>>>>>>> weekly
>>>>>>> >> > > > > `Outlook'
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> says: "Khatna (circumcision) is a tradition the Bohras
>>>>>>> trace
>>>>>>> >> > > back to
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> their
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> origins in (north) Africa, one they continue with
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> because
>>>>>>> >> they
>>>>>>> >> > > see
>>>>>>> >> > > > > this
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> as
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> an attempt to stay true to their faith."
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >>
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> The Outlook article goes on to say that "most Bohra
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> women
>>>>>>> >> and men
>>>>>>> >> > > > > even
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> today would rather keep this practice a secret rather
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> than
>>>>>>> >> > > question a
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> custom that is now universally seen as a gross
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> violation
>>>>>>> of a
>>>>>>> >> > > woman's
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> body."
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >>
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> The World Health Organisation defines FGM/C as a
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> procedure
>>>>>>> >> that
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> "intentionally alters or injures female genital organs
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> for
>>>>>>> >> > > > > non-medical
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> reasons." FGM/C, as practiced in some African
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> countries,
>>>>>>> may
>>>>>>> >> > > involve
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> removal of the entire clitoris and labia.
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >>
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> The practice persists in 28 African countries, as well
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> as
>>>>>>> in
>>>>>>> >> some
>>>>>>> >> > > > > Middle
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> Eastern countries with varying degrees of cutting or
>>>>>>> >> mutilation.
>>>>>>> >> > > > > African
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> countries that have banned it include Burkina Faso,
>>>>>>> Central
>>>>>>> >> > > African
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> Republic, Djibouti, Eritrea, Ethiopia, Togo, Uganda,
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> Kenya
>>>>>>> >> and
>>>>>>> >> > > Egypt.
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >>
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> Bohras insist that their practice is not harmful since
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> it
>>>>>>> is
>>>>>>> >> done
>>>>>>> >> > > > > with
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> care and moderation. Many justify it as a means to
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> curb
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> a
>>>>>>> >> woman's
>>>>>>> >> > > > > sexual
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> drive and keep her chaste.
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >>
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> Haider finds that argument "highly problematic" and
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> sees
>>>>>>> it
>>>>>>> >> as a
>>>>>>> >> > > way
>>>>>>> >> > > > > of
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> controlling women.
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >>
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> Dr. Nighat Shah, former president of the Society of
>>>>>>> >> > > Obstetricians and
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> Gynaecologists in Pakistan, finds it hard to believe
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> that
>>>>>>> a
>>>>>>> >> > > > > community as
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> "progressive and educated" as the Bohras carries out
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> this
>>>>>>> >> > > practice.
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >>
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> "Medically speaking," she explained, "a little snip or
>>>>>>> clip
>>>>>>> >> (of
>>>>>>> >> > > the
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> clitoris) may not affect childbirth, but it may rob
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> the
>>>>>>> >> woman of
>>>>>>> >> > > > > sexual
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> pleasure. It is a very sensitive tissue."
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >>
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> Another gynaecologist and obstetrician, Dr. Shershah
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> Syed,
>>>>>>> >> finds
>>>>>>> >> > > no
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> medical benefit to support female circumcision. "I am
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> no
>>>>>>> >> > > religious
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> scholar,
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> so if a community believes it is an Islamic
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> injunction,
>>>>>>> I'd
>>>>>>> >> > > suggest
>>>>>>> >> > > > > the
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> girls should at least be old enough to understand the
>>>>>>> reason
>>>>>>> >> so
>>>>>>> >> > > that
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> they
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> can make an informed decision."
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >>
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> "Why do women's sexual drives have to be curbed?"
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> Haider
>>>>>>> >> asks.
>>>>>>> >> > > "Women
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> who
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> are not circumcised are not necessarily promiscuous!"
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> she
>>>>>>> >> says.
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >>
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> A young Indian girl belonging to this Muslim sect, who
>>>>>>> goes
>>>>>>> >> by
>>>>>>> >> > > the
>>>>>>> >> > > > > name
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> of
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> Tasleem, has now found the courage to initiate an
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> online
>>>>>>> >> petition
>>>>>>> >> > > > > asking
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> the community's high priest, Dr. Syedna Mohammad
>>>>>>> >> Burhanuddin, to
>>>>>>> >> > > have
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> this
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> "cruel, inhuman and undemocratic ritual" stopped.
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >>
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> The petition addressed to the 96-year-old prelate, who
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> is
>>>>>>> >> based
>>>>>>> >> > > in
>>>>>>> >> > > > > the
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> western Indian city of Mumbai, states: "Such a
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> barbaric
>>>>>>> >> ritual
>>>>>>> >> > > has no
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> place
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> in a progressive community like the Bohras. So we pray
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> to
>>>>>>> His
>>>>>>> >> > > > > Holiness
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> to
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> stop this misogynist ritual." Mustansir and Haider are
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> in
>>>>>>> a
>>>>>>> >> > > minority
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> among
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> Bohra women who refuse to accept the practice. Most
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> still
>>>>>>> get
>>>>>>> >> > > their
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> daughters circumcised because it is an order from the
>>>>>>> >> community's
>>>>>>> >> > > > > high
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> priest.
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >>
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> "I have blind faith in my leader. I believe there must
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> be
>>>>>>> >> some
>>>>>>> >> > > > > goodness
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> in
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> this that there is so much insistence," said Zahabia
>>>>>>> >> Mohammad,
>>>>>>> >> > > 38,
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> mother
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> of three circumcised daughters.
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >>
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> Mohammad conceded that her own experience was "gross"
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> and
>>>>>>> >> > > "barbaric",
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> but
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> justifies its continuation because "it is done in a
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> very
>>>>>>> safe
>>>>>>> >> > > manner
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> today
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> by doctors."
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >>
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> She was present for all of her daughters'
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> circumcisions.
>>>>>>> "It
>>>>>>> >> > > takes
>>>>>>> >> > > > > less
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> than five minutes and the procedure is done under
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> local
>>>>>>> >> > > anaesthesia.
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> Just a
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> very minute bit of the clitoris is clipped off," she
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> said.
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >>
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> She acknowledged she had little information on the
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> rite
>>>>>>> >> except
>>>>>>> >> > > what
>>>>>>> >> > > > > was
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> told her by an aunt "that the foreskin of the clitoris
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> is
>>>>>>> >> > > unclean and
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> circumcision is for the benefit of the women."
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >>
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> She also concedes that today, with a deluge of
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> information
>>>>>>> >> > > > > circulating
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> against this practice, it is imperative to equip the
>>>>>>> >> community
>>>>>>> >> > > with
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> information to enable them to make informed decisions.
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >>
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> "Not everyone will accept this blindly, not the next
>>>>>>> >> generation.
>>>>>>> >> > > They
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> will
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> question and prod, so it is important to prepare
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> them,"
>>>>>>> she
>>>>>>> >> says
>>>>>>> >> > > of a
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> rite
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> that is kept secret from male members of the sect.
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >>
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> Tasleem told Outlook that genital cutting happens in
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> all
>>>>>>> >> strata
>>>>>>> >> > > of
>>>>>>> >> > > > > Bohra
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> society. "I'd say 90 percent practise it."
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >>
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> Arwa Mohammad, who is in her 20s, signed the petition
>>>>>>> because
>>>>>>> >> > > "it's
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> archaic and nonsensical." She was circumcised when she
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> was
>>>>>>> >> seven
>>>>>>> >> > > by
>>>>>>> >> > > > > her
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> grandmother's doctor friend. "Just goes to show how
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> this
>>>>>>> >> ritual
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> perpetuates
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> without anyone questioning!"
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >>
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> Married a year back, Mohammad was "not traumatised"
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> for
>>>>>>> life
>>>>>>> >> for
>>>>>>> >> > > > > getting
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> circumcised, but cannot comprehend the reason still.
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> "I
>>>>>>> have
>>>>>>> >> > > friends
>>>>>>> >> > > > > who
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> have been circumcised like me but have a high sex
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> drive.
>>>>>>> On
>>>>>>> >> the
>>>>>>> >> > > other
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> hand,
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> she admits to "frigidity" in bed.
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >>
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> "The thought of snipping off a bit of a young child's
>>>>>>> >> clitoris
>>>>>>> >> > > gives
>>>>>>> >> > > > > me
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> the goosebumps," said 37-year-old uncircumcised Amena
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> Ali.
>>>>>>> >> She
>>>>>>> >> > > > > refuses
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> to
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> put her two daughters, aged six and eight - considered
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> the
>>>>>>> >> right
>>>>>>> >> > > age
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> band
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> for circumcision - under the blade.
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >>
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> The petition, put up last October, has opened an
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> animated
>>>>>>> >> forum
>>>>>>> >> > > for
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> discussion on both sides of the border, perhaps for
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> the
>>>>>>> very
>>>>>>> >> > > first
>>>>>>> >> > > > > time,
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> within the community on a subject that was taboo.
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >>
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> "Initially, only the non-Bohras were signing, but once
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> the
>>>>>>> >> media
>>>>>>> >> > > got
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> into
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> the act, many women from the community openly began
>>>>>>> talking
>>>>>>> >> about
>>>>>>> >> > > > > their
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> painful experience," Tasleem told IPS in an email
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> exchange
>>>>>>> >> from
>>>>>>> >> > > > > India.
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >>
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> So far, Tasleem has been able to collect 1,059
>>>>>>> signatures. "I
>>>>>>> >> > > will
>>>>>>> >> > > > > keep
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> this going till Dr. Syedna bans it. Raising awareness
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> is
>>>>>>> the
>>>>>>> >> > > first
>>>>>>> >> > > > > step
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> towards solving the problem."
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >>
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> "Whether the ritual will be abolished by this
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> petition,
>>>>>>> only
>>>>>>> >> time
>>>>>>> >> > > > > will
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> tell," says Zainab Hussain, 49, but she feels the
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> petition
>>>>>>> >> will
>>>>>>> >> > > make
>>>>>>> >> > > > > a
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> difference. "They (community leaders) may eventually
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> break
>>>>>>> >> their
>>>>>>> >> > > > > silence
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> and give a plausible answer."
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >>
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> (END)
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >>
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >> [Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >>
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >>
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >>
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >------------------------------------
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >>
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >Post message: prole...@egroups.com
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >Subscribe : proletar-subscr...@egroups.com
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >Unsubscribe : proletar-unsubscr...@egroups.com
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >List owner : proletar-ow...@egroups.com
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >Homepage : http://proletar.8m.com/Yahoo! Groups Links
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >>
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> >
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >>
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >> [Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >>
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >>
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >>
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >------------------------------------
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >Post message: prole...@egroups.com
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >Subscribe : proletar-subscr...@egroups.com
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >Unsubscribe : proletar-unsubscr...@egroups.com
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >List owner : proletar-ow...@egroups.com
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >Homepage : http://proletar.8m.com/Yahoo! Groups Links
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >
>>>>>>> >> > > > > >
>>>>>>> >> > > > >
>>>>>>> >> > > > > [Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
>>>>>>> >> > > > >
>>>>>>> >> > > > >
>>>>>>> >> > > > >
>>>>>>> >> > > >
>>>>>>> >> > > >
>>>>>>> >> > > > [Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
>>>>>>> >> > > >
>>>>>>> >> > >
>>>>>>> >> > >
>>>>>>> >> > >
>>>>>>> >> >
>>>>>>> >> >
>>>>>>> >> > [Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
>>>>>>> >> >
>>>>>>> >>
>>>>>>> >>
>>>>>>> >>
>>>>>>> >
>>>>>>> >
>>>>>>> >[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
>>>>>>> >
>>>>>>> >
>>>>>>> >
>>>>>>> >------------------------------------
>>>>>>> >
>>>>>>> >Post message: prole...@egroups.com
>>>>>>> >Subscribe  :  proletar-subscr...@egroups.com
>>>>>>> >Unsubscribe :  proletar-unsubscr...@egroups.com
>>>>>>> >List owner  :  proletar-ow...@egroups.com
>>>>>>> >Homepage    :  http://proletar.8m.com/Yahoo! Groups Links
>>>>>>> >
>>>>>>> >
>>>>>>> >
>>>>>>> >
>>>>>>> >
>>>>>>> >
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>> [Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>
>>>>>>
>>>>>>[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
>>>>>>
>>>>>>
>>>>>>
>>>>>>------------------------------------
>>>>>>
>>>>>>Post message: prole...@egroups.com
>>>>>>Subscribe  :  proletar-subscr...@egroups.com
>>>>>>Unsubscribe :  proletar-unsubscr...@egroups.com
>>>>>>List owner  :  proletar-ow...@egroups.com
>>>>>>Homepage    :  http://proletar.8m.com/Yahoo! Groups Links
>>>>>>
>>>>>>
>>>>>>
>>>>>>
>>>>>>
>>>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>> [Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
>>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>
>>>>
>>>>------------------------------------
>>>>
>>>>Post message: prole...@egroups.com
>>>>Subscribe  :  proletar-subscr...@egroups.com
>>>>Unsubscribe :  proletar-unsubscr...@egroups.com
>>>>List owner  :  proletar-ow...@egroups.com
>>>>Homepage    :  http://proletar.8m.com/Yahoo! Groups Links
>>>>
>>>>
>>>>
>>>>
>>>>
>>>>
>>>
>>> [Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
>>>
>>>
>>
>>
>>------------------------------------
>>
>>Post message: prole...@egroups.com
>>Subscribe  :  proletar-subscr...@egroups.com
>>Unsubscribe :  proletar-unsubscr...@egroups.com
>>List owner  :  proletar-ow...@egroups.com
>>Homepage    :  http://proletar.8m.com/Yahoo! Groups Links
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>
>[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
>
>[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
>
>
>
>
>

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



------------------------------------

Post message: prole...@egroups.com
Subscribe   :  proletar-subscr...@egroups.com
Unsubscribe :  proletar-unsubscr...@egroups.com
List owner  :  proletar-ow...@egroups.com
Homepage    :  http://proletar.8m.com/Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/proletar/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/proletar/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    proletar-dig...@yahoogroups.com 
    proletar-fullfeatu...@yahoogroups.com

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    proletar-unsubscr...@yahoogroups.com

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/

Kirim email ke