Not so good news

1994-03-14 Thread Michael Perelman
After I sent my message I discovered the duplicate mailings. I have received a number of complaints that pen-l is not identified. I will see what I can do to rectify the problems. Even so, it is sure a lot easier this time. -- Michael Perelman Economics Department California State University

Not so good news

1994-03-14 Thread Michael Perelman
After I sent my message I discovered the duplicate mailings. I have received a number of complaints that pen-l is not identified. I will see what I can do to rectify the problems. Even so, it is sure a lot easier this time. -- Michael Perelman Economics Department California State University

Temporary Lectureship (fwd)

1994-03-14 Thread Michael Perelman
Forwarded message: Date: Mon, 14 Mar 1994 09:37:09 EST Sender: Teaching and Research in Economic History <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> From: Sam Williamson <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Organization: Miami University School of Business Subject: Temporary Lectureship Preliminary Announcement The Univers

Temporary Lectureship (fwd)

1994-03-14 Thread Michael Perelman
Forwarded message: Date: Mon, 14 Mar 1994 09:37:09 EST Sender: Teaching and Research in Economic History <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> From: Sam Williamson <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Organization: Miami University School of Business Subject: Temporary Lectureship Preliminary Announcement The Univers

FROM THE DEVELOPMENT GAP (fwd)

1994-03-14 Thread Michael Perelman
Forwarded message: Date: Mon, 14 Mar 1994 18:46:21 GMT Sender: Activists Mailing List <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> From: The Development GAP <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Organization: ? Subject: FROM THE DEVELOPMENT GAP ~Date: Fri, 4 Mar 1994 12:25:19 -0800 ~From: The Development GAP /* Written 6:3

FROM THE DEVELOPMENT GAP (fwd)

1994-03-14 Thread Michael Perelman
Forwarded message: Date: Mon, 14 Mar 1994 18:46:21 GMT Sender: Activists Mailing List <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> From: The Development GAP <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Organization: ? Subject: FROM THE DEVELOPMENT GAP ~Date: Fri, 4 Mar 1994 12:25:19 -0800 ~From: The Development GAP /* Written 6:3

Xrates, AS-AD, & comparative advantage

1994-03-14 Thread Peter.Dorman
I guess this is one of those nostalgic periods on PEN-L when old debates come back for a second run. Tom W. wonders how it can be that, in one context, I claim that absolute advantage does not rule because exchange rates need not adjust to balance the current account, and in another I claim that

Xrates, AS-AD, & comparative advantage

1994-03-14 Thread Peter.Dorman
I guess this is one of those nostalgic periods on PEN-L when old debates come back for a second run. Tom W. wonders how it can be that, in one context, I claim that absolute advantage does not rule because exchange rates need not adjust to balance the current account, and in another I claim that

Re: LTV

1994-03-14 Thread GSKILLMAN
Barkley Rosser (hi, Barkley) takes exception with the way I pose the point that labor values are at best superfluous: > I profoundly hesitate to get involved in the Cottrell- > Skillman-et-al controversies over Marx and the labor theory of > values. But, one point: From someone who does n

Re: LTV

1994-03-14 Thread GSKILLMAN
Barkley Rosser (hi, Barkley) takes exception with the way I pose the point that labor values are at best superfluous: > I profoundly hesitate to get involved in the Cottrell- > Skillman-et-al controversies over Marx and the labor theory of > values. But, one point: From someone who does n

RE; inflation and real wages

1994-03-14 Thread MMEEROPO%WNEC . BITNET
There is one other complication in the question about inflation and real wages: Many of the people in the working class are NET DEBTORS. This is particularly true of the section that owns their own homes -- as well as those who are struggling to get out of the working class with heavy student lo

RE; inflation and real wages

1994-03-14 Thread MMEEROPO%WNEC . BITNET
There is one other complication in the question about inflation and real wages: Many of the people in the working class are NET DEBTORS. This is particularly true of the section that owns their own homes -- as well as those who are struggling to get out of the working class with heavy student lo

Re: use-value

1994-03-14 Thread Jim Devine
On the question of whether use-value is quantitative or not, I won't say anything. Hugo Radice said what I wanted to say. But I don't think use-value is irrelevant to Marx's political economy. He abstracts from it at the beginning of CAPITAL. All that's necessary is that a commodity have a use-v

Re: use-value

1994-03-14 Thread Jim Devine
On the question of whether use-value is quantitative or not, I won't say anything. Hugo Radice said what I wanted to say. But I don't think use-value is irrelevant to Marx's political economy. He abstracts from it at the beginning of CAPITAL. All that's necessary is that a commodity have a use-v

LTV defense, part 3

1994-03-14 Thread Allin Cottrell
1. At this point I shall digress briefly to cover a flank, i.e. to address a concern that I suspect many students of Marxism may have. 2. I appear to be treating the LTV and the Sraffian system as alternative theories of (the "systematic component" of) relative prices. But isn't this to

LTV defense, part 3

1994-03-14 Thread Allin Cottrell
1. At this point I shall digress briefly to cover a flank, i.e. to address a concern that I suspect many students of Marxism may have. 2. I appear to be treating the LTV and the Sraffian system as alternative theories of (the "systematic component" of) relative prices. But isn't this to

Re: Turing Test

1994-03-14 Thread Jim Devine
On Fri, 11 Mar 1994 15:07:39 -0500 (EST) Gil said: > >For example, if a law were passed mandating that all firms be labor- >owned, Marx's argument of Vol I, Ch. 5 and Vol III, Chs 21-23 would >lead to the conclusion that the elimination of labor's subsumption >under capital would lead to the elimi

Re: Turing Test

1994-03-14 Thread Jim Devine
On Fri, 11 Mar 1994 15:07:39 -0500 (EST) Gil said: > >For example, if a law were passed mandating that all firms be labor- >owned, Marx's argument of Vol I, Ch. 5 and Vol III, Chs 21-23 would >lead to the conclusion that the elimination of labor's subsumption >under capital would lead to the elimi

AD-AS, response to Peter Dorman

1994-03-14 Thread FAC_BROSSER
Peter: 1) I am glad to hear that you are free of sin, my brother, in your (past) teaching of micro. However in your remarks about "microland is faster than macroland" I would say it ain't necessarily so, especially when prices are a signaling device. We have seen plenty sudden speculative fren

AD-AS, response to Peter Dorman

1994-03-14 Thread FAC_BROSSER
Peter: 1) I am glad to hear that you are free of sin, my brother, in your (past) teaching of micro. However in your remarks about "microland is faster than macroland" I would say it ain't necessarily so, especially when prices are a signaling device. We have seen plenty sudden speculative fren

RE: marx on money

1994-03-14 Thread Jim Devine
In response to Doug Henwood's point that the use of surplus-value is important to the issue, Gil Skillman agrees: >, and of course he's right. And Marx would have agreed, up to the >point of insisting that in a *capitalist* society, the realization of >surplus value via interest presupposes the

RE: marx on money

1994-03-14 Thread Jim Devine
In response to Doug Henwood's point that the use of surplus-value is important to the issue, Gil Skillman agrees: >, and of course he's right. And Marx would have agreed, up to the >point of insisting that in a *capitalist* society, the realization of >surplus value via interest presupposes the

Re: the aggregate demand curve

1994-03-14 Thread Jim Devine
On Mon, 14 Mar 1994 13:55:15 -0500 (EST) Rudy F. said: >... I guess that >I don't understand how a change in investment can be large >enough to cause a recession or a period of expansion, in the >short run, but not have any impact on the production function. The idea is that the flow of investm

Re: the aggregate demand curve

1994-03-14 Thread Jim Devine
On Mon, 14 Mar 1994 13:55:15 -0500 (EST) Rudy F. said: >... I guess that >I don't understand how a change in investment can be large >enough to cause a recession or a period of expansion, in the >short run, but not have any impact on the production function. The idea is that the flow of investm

Guaranteed Basic Income

1994-03-14 Thread Sally Lerner
I would appreciate comments on: 1) the idea of a basic guaranteed income for individuals, linked to distribution of available paid work via a much shorter work week, incentives for education, community service, environmental restoration, etc., other ideas, and 2) realistically, how such an income

Guaranteed Basic Income

1994-03-14 Thread Sally Lerner
I would appreciate comments on: 1) the idea of a basic guaranteed income for individuals, linked to distribution of available paid work via a much shorter work week, incentives for education, community service, environmental restoration, etc., other ideas, and 2) realistically, how such an income

LTV

1994-03-14 Thread FAC_BROSSER
I profoundly hesitate to get involved in the Cottrell- Skillman-et-al controversies over Marx and the labor theory of values. But, one point: From someone who does not "believe" in the LTV to Gil, the argument that prices are on the surface and therefore are the supreme driving force does

LTV

1994-03-14 Thread FAC_BROSSER
I profoundly hesitate to get involved in the Cottrell- Skillman-et-al controversies over Marx and the labor theory of values. But, one point: From someone who does not "believe" in the LTV to Gil, the argument that prices are on the surface and therefore are the supreme driving force does

Re: the aggregate demand curve

1994-03-14 Thread FICHTENBAUM
Jim D. writes: >but can't you say that the AS curve is drawn in the "Keynesian >short run" in which the stocks of means of production are >assumed to be given? Then capital investment leads to >shifts in the long-run AS curve over time... The problem I see with this argument is that we tell stu

Re: the aggregate demand curve

1994-03-14 Thread FICHTENBAUM
Jim D. writes: >but can't you say that the AS curve is drawn in the "Keynesian >short run" in which the stocks of means of production are >assumed to be given? Then capital investment leads to >shifts in the long-run AS curve over time... The problem I see with this argument is that we tell stu

Re: the aggregate demand curve

1994-03-14 Thread MMEEROPO%WNEC . BITNET
Rudy F. responded to me -- >I think you made a good point about the fact that the >aggregate demand and supply curves are not independent. >This has always bothered me and no one seems to have >solved the problem to my satisfaction. > >The problem is that investment is a component of aggrega

Re: the aggregate demand curve

1994-03-14 Thread MMEEROPO%WNEC . BITNET
Rudy F. responded to me -- >I think you made a good point about the fact that the >aggregate demand and supply curves are not independent. >This has always bothered me and no one seems to have >solved the problem to my satisfaction. > >The problem is that investment is a component of aggrega

Inflation is a good way to...

1994-03-14 Thread Sam Lanfranco
While making a list of the ?good things? that inflation can do, don't overlook its wonderful effect on municipal debt loads. At nominal tax dollars increase from income and upward pressure on property prices, the real burden of the last spending round's accumulated debt falls away from the city -

Inflation is a good way to...

1994-03-14 Thread Sam Lanfranco
While making a list of the ?good things? that inflation can do, don't overlook its wonderful effect on municipal debt loads. At nominal tax dollars increase from income and upward pressure on property prices, the real burden of the last spending round's accumulated debt falls away from the city -

Re: inflation and real wages

1994-03-14 Thread FICHTENBAUM
Peter D. writes: > >I disagree with Rudy F about inflation being a mechanism that lowers real >wages, either logically or historically. Logically, of course, the circular >flow indicates that aggregate purchasing power remains unaffected, and the >main distributional effect of greater-than-expect

Re: inflation and real wages

1994-03-14 Thread FICHTENBAUM
Peter D. writes: > >I disagree with Rudy F about inflation being a mechanism that lowers real >wages, either logically or historically. Logically, of course, the circular >flow indicates that aggregate purchasing power remains unaffected, and the >main distributional effect of greater-than-expect

results

1994-03-14 Thread cns
Preliminary results of Jim O'Connor's request for books to use in Political Economy for Sociologists class Percentage of pen-l respondents recommending books they have authored themselves -- 50% Percentage of respondents who think I'm too young to retire -- 16% Percentage of respondents I than

results

1994-03-14 Thread cns
Preliminary results of Jim O'Connor's request for books to use in Political Economy for Sociologists class Percentage of pen-l respondents recommending books they have authored themselves -- 50% Percentage of respondents who think I'm too young to retire -- 16% Percentage of respondents I than

Re: the aggregate demand curve

1994-03-14 Thread Alan G. Isaac
On Mon, 14 Mar 1994 06:50:38 -0800 Rudy Fichtenbaum said: >aggregate demand and supply curves are not independent. >This has always bothered me and no one seems to have >solved the problem to my satisfaction. > >The problem is that investment is a component of aggregate >demand but it also affects

Re: the aggregate demand curve

1994-03-14 Thread Alan G. Isaac
On Mon, 14 Mar 1994 06:50:38 -0800 Rudy Fichtenbaum said: >aggregate demand and supply curves are not independent. >This has always bothered me and no one seems to have >solved the problem to my satisfaction. > >The problem is that investment is a component of aggregate >demand but it also affects

RE: marx on money

1994-03-14 Thread Jim Devine
On Sun, 13 Mar 1994 23:52:00 -0800 Gil said: >This is to continue my dialogue with Allin C. concerning the results >he and a coauthor recently obtained, which are consistent with >earlier work by Shaikh and others, to the effect that values diverge >very little from prices of production in fact.

RE: marx on money

1994-03-14 Thread Jim Devine
On Sun, 13 Mar 1994 23:52:00 -0800 Gil said: >This is to continue my dialogue with Allin C. concerning the results >he and a coauthor recently obtained, which are consistent with >earlier work by Shaikh and others, to the effect that values diverge >very little from prices of production in fact.

AD-AS again

1994-03-14 Thread Tom . Weisskopf
I have found the latest flurry of exchanges on the AD-AS question very interesting, and would have jumped in sooner if I only had more time. Now that my name has been mentioned, I can no longer restrain myself -- though time constraints still limit me to one small point. Peter Dorman referred ba

AD-AS again

1994-03-14 Thread Tom . Weisskopf
I have found the latest flurry of exchanges on the AD-AS question very interesting, and would have jumped in sooner if I only had more time. Now that my name has been mentioned, I can no longer restrain myself -- though time constraints still limit me to one small point. Peter Dorman referred ba

Re: Employment policy

1994-03-14 Thread Jim Devine
On Sun, 13 Mar 1994 23:34:45 -0800 JKC said: > . . . I get the feeling that >the general view from the left, center and the right seems to indicate that >monetary policy is not all that effective as an employment policy. > >I have not done a lot of review on the efficacy of monetary policy and wou

Re: Employment policy

1994-03-14 Thread Jim Devine
On Sun, 13 Mar 1994 23:34:45 -0800 JKC said: > . . . I get the feeling that >the general view from the left, center and the right seems to indicate that >monetary policy is not all that effective as an employment policy. > >I have not done a lot of review on the efficacy of monetary policy and wou

Re: the aggregate demand curve

1994-03-14 Thread Jim Devine
On Mon, 14 Mar 1994 07:41:02 -0800 Doug H. said: >I thought Keynes liked the idea of inflation subtly lowering real wages. >Is this a Marxist slander against him? No it isn't. In the GT, Keynes saw inflation exactly in this way. Tarshis and Dunlop criticized his assumption that real wages fall as

Re: the aggregate demand curve

1994-03-14 Thread Jim Devine
On Mon, 14 Mar 1994 07:41:02 -0800 Doug H. said: >I thought Keynes liked the idea of inflation subtly lowering real wages. >Is this a Marxist slander against him? No it isn't. In the GT, Keynes saw inflation exactly in this way. Tarshis and Dunlop criticized his assumption that real wages fall as

Re: the aggregate demand curve

1994-03-14 Thread Jim Devine
On Mon, 14 Mar 1994 06:51:12 -0800 Rudy F. said: >The problem is that investment is a component of aggregate >demand but it also affects aggregate supply since >investment is the change in the capital stock. but can't you say that the AS curve is drawn in the "Keynesian short run" in which the st

Re: the aggregate demand curve

1994-03-14 Thread Jim Devine
On Mon, 14 Mar 1994 06:51:12 -0800 Rudy F. said: >The problem is that investment is a component of aggregate >demand but it also affects aggregate supply since >investment is the change in the capital stock. but can't you say that the AS curve is drawn in the "Keynesian short run" in which the st

Re: micro S & D

1994-03-14 Thread Jim Devine
On Sun, 13 Mar 1994 21:41:57 -0800 Barkley Rosser said: > As near >as I can tell the only alternatives to supply and demand are either >Marx or (Gil Skillman and Jim Devine, are you reading?) Of course I'm reading (though I'm dismayed at the large amount of mail after leaving town for the weekend

Re: micro S & D

1994-03-14 Thread Jim Devine
On Sun, 13 Mar 1994 21:41:57 -0800 Barkley Rosser said: > As near >as I can tell the only alternatives to supply and demand are either >Marx or (Gil Skillman and Jim Devine, are you reading?) Of course I'm reading (though I'm dismayed at the large amount of mail after leaving town for the weekend

Re: the aggregate demand curve

1994-03-14 Thread FICHTENBAUM
Doug H. writes: > >I thought Keynes liked the idea of inflation subtly lowering real wages. >Is this a Marxist slander against him? > Keynes may have liked the idea and was honest enough to admit it. But I was referring to standard textbook treatment of the issue. Are there standard textbooks

Re: the aggregate demand curve

1994-03-14 Thread FICHTENBAUM
Doug H. writes: > >I thought Keynes liked the idea of inflation subtly lowering real wages. >Is this a Marxist slander against him? > Keynes may have liked the idea and was honest enough to admit it. But I was referring to standard textbook treatment of the issue. Are there standard textbooks

inflation and real wages

1994-03-14 Thread Peter.Dorman
I disagree with Rudy F about inflation being a mechanism that lowers real wages, either logically or historically. Logically, of course, the circular flow indicates that aggregate purchasing power remains unaffected, and the main distributional effect of greater-than-expected inflation will be fr

inflation and real wages

1994-03-14 Thread Peter.Dorman
I disagree with Rudy F about inflation being a mechanism that lowers real wages, either logically or historically. Logically, of course, the circular flow indicates that aggregate purchasing power remains unaffected, and the main distributional effect of greater-than-expected inflation will be fr

LTV defense, part 2

1994-03-14 Thread Allin Cottrell
First substantive remarks: On Sraffa-Steedman == 1. There is no doubt a nice Latin name for the fallacy of seeking to defend one's own position by attacking one's opponent's. Nonetheless I will open by doing exactly that. Why? Because there is

LTV defense, part 2

1994-03-14 Thread Allin Cottrell
First substantive remarks: On Sraffa-Steedman == 1. There is no doubt a nice Latin name for the fallacy of seeking to defend one's own position by attacking one's opponent's. Nonetheless I will open by doing exactly that. Why? Because there is

New system

1994-03-14 Thread Doug Henwood
It's confusing not to have PEN-L listed as the source of a message; the new software makes everything look like pseudo-personalized direct mail. And, at least on this system (PINE 3.05, on a Sun UNIX), you can't reply to PEN-L; a reply goes to the author. Can this be fixed? Or is this the price o

New system

1994-03-14 Thread Doug Henwood
It's confusing not to have PEN-L listed as the source of a message; the new software makes everything look like pseudo-personalized direct mail. And, at least on this system (PINE 3.05, on a Sun UNIX), you can't reply to PEN-L; a reply goes to the author. Can this be fixed? Or is this the price o

Re: the aggregate demand curve

1994-03-14 Thread Doug Henwood
I thought Keynes liked the idea of inflation subtly lowering real wages. Is this a Marxist slander against him? Doug Doug Henwood [[EMAIL PROTECTED]] Left Business Observer 212-874-4020 (voice) 212-874-3137 (fax) On Mon, 14 Mar 1994 [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: > Mike, > > I think you made a goo

Re: the aggregate demand curve

1994-03-14 Thread Doug Henwood
I thought Keynes liked the idea of inflation subtly lowering real wages. Is this a Marxist slander against him? Doug Doug Henwood [[EMAIL PROTECTED]] Left Business Observer 212-874-4020 (voice) 212-874-3137 (fax) On Mon, 14 Mar 1994 [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: > Mike, > > I think you made a goo

more AS-AD

1994-03-14 Thread Peter.Dorman
Now that I have been pulled back into this discussion of AS-AD I can't seem to get out. So here is my reply to Barkley Rosser (hi Bark!): 1. Why do I get so agitated about the assumption that nominal MS remains constant as AS shifts? Why isn't this just like the pleasant fiction about demand cu

more AS-AD

1994-03-14 Thread Peter.Dorman
Now that I have been pulled back into this discussion of AS-AD I can't seem to get out. So here is my reply to Barkley Rosser (hi Bark!): 1. Why do I get so agitated about the assumption that nominal MS remains constant as AS shifts? Why isn't this just like the pleasant fiction about demand cu

CSE 1994 Conference

1994-03-14 Thread HKR
We are currently putting together the programme for this year's Conference of Socialist Economists annual conference. CSE'94: SOCIALISMAND BEYOND? University of Leeds, July 8th-10th 1994 Programme so far includes: plenaries: on globalisation and on racism. streams/workshops: capital, repro

CSE 1994 Conference

1994-03-14 Thread HKR
We are currently putting together the programme for this year's Conference of Socialist Economists annual conference. CSE'94: SOCIALISMAND BEYOND? University of Leeds, July 8th-10th 1994 Programme so far includes: plenaries: on globalisation and on racism. streams/workshops: capital, repro

quantifiability of use-value in Marx

1994-03-14 Thread HKR
The use-value of labour-power is not that it IS a quantity exceeding its own (exchange)-value, but that it is a SOURCE of a quantity of value exceeding its own EV, as one of Steve Keen's Marx quotes makes clear. In addition, LP is only a POTENTIAL source of value (and thus to an unquantifiable ex

quantifiability of use-value in Marx

1994-03-14 Thread HKR
The use-value of labour-power is not that it IS a quantity exceeding its own (exchange)-value, but that it is a SOURCE of a quantity of value exceeding its own EV, as one of Steve Keen's Marx quotes makes clear. In addition, LP is only a POTENTIAL source of value (and thus to an unquantifiable ex

Central America and World Bank/IMF Adjustment Programs

1994-03-14 Thread mcclintockbrent%faculty%Carthage
One of my students is researching the impact of World Bank/IMF structural adjustment programs in Central America for a course he is taking in political science. While he and I are familar with World Bank/IMF activities in Africa (he is Nigerian) and the recent World Bank report on East Asia, we

Central America and World Bank/IMF Adjustment Programs

1994-03-14 Thread mcclintockbrent%faculty%Carthage
One of my students is researching the impact of World Bank/IMF structural adjustment programs in Central America for a course he is taking in political science. While he and I are familar with World Bank/IMF activities in Africa (he is Nigerian) and the recent World Bank report on East Asia, we

RE: marx on money

1994-03-14 Thread GSKILLMAN
Something else that just occurred to me with respect to Allin's post. Under conditions such as those discovered by Allin and co-author, to the effect that labor values correlate very closely with prices of production, the prices of production which emerge from Sraffa's "standard system" would

RE: marx on money

1994-03-14 Thread GSKILLMAN
Something else that just occurred to me with respect to Allin's post. Under conditions such as those discovered by Allin and co-author, to the effect that labor values correlate very closely with prices of production, the prices of production which emerge from Sraffa's "standard system" would