RE: (313) Re: hey ya?

2003-12-27 Thread alex.bates
apparently they sold 6 million copies of the outkast album this year ab -Original Message- From: john harvey [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Tuesday, December 23, 2003 12:49 AM To: 313 Subject: Re: (313) Re: hey ya? Then you expose one group to one set of stimuli, and expose

RE: (313) Re: hey ya?

2003-12-22 Thread Lester Kenyatta Spence
On Sun, 21 Dec 2003, Brendan Nelson wrote: -Original Message- From: Lester Kenyatta Spence [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: 21 December 2003 06:50 There's been some attempt to actually test this empiricallyto see whether exposure to rap music (or other aggressive art forms

RE: (313) Re: hey ya?

2003-12-22 Thread Brendan Nelson
-Original Message- From: Lester Kenyatta Spence [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: 22 December 2003 04:07 It's a bit of a chicken'n'egg question I suppose. Not in this casethe power of the experiment is that you're able to ferrett out the causal element... Take a population of

Re: (313) Re: hey ya?

2003-12-22 Thread john harvey
Then you expose one group to one set of stimuli, and expose the other group to some sort of placebo. comparing hip hop to a band like placebo is a silly idea. (stupid joke)

Re: (313) Re: hey ya?

2003-12-21 Thread Cyclone Louise Wehner
Let's be frank: the truth is that sexism is not deemed as offensive cuturally as racism, accuse a racist of racism and he will get defensive, accuse a male of sexism and it's laughed off. I always wondered about that. Let me get this straight---are you equating all males to sexists? That's

Re: (313) Re: hey ya?

2003-12-21 Thread Cyclone Louise Wehner
I think that may be part of the new urban feminism that arose with Lil' Kim and co building on Madonna's brand of feminism. Things are internalised and subverted. Trad feminists had real issues when Madonna first came out and there has always been disquiet surrounding Kim, who acknowledged Madonna

Re: (313) Re: hey ya?

2003-12-21 Thread Cyclone Louise Wehner
This is a great response. I think it's fair enough to discuss it, though, and the issue has arisen in specific media, as that essay by dream showed. Andrew's contribution was well intentioned. -- From: Kent williams [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: 313 list 313@hyperreal.org Subject: Re: (313) Re

Re: (313) Re: hey ya?

2003-12-21 Thread Kent williams
I didn't mean to dog anyone in the discussion for being white and daring to discuss the issue, if that's the impression I gave. I just think there's a discussion to be had, placing misogyny in hip hop lyrics in the context of the unique problems facing black americans -- too many men in jail, too

Re: (313) Re: hey ya?

2003-12-21 Thread Lester Kenyatta Spence
On Sat, 20 Dec 2003, Kent williams wrote: I didn't mean to dog anyone in the discussion for being white and daring to discuss the issue, if that's the impression I gave. I just think there's a discussion to be had, placing misogyny in hip hop lyrics in the context of the unique problems

Re: (313) Re: hey ya?

2003-12-21 Thread Phonopsia
- Original Message - From: Lester Kenyatta Spence [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: Kent williams [EMAIL PROTECTED] Cc: Cyclone Louise Wehner [EMAIL PROTECTED]; 313 Detroit 313@hyperreal.org; [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Sunday, December 21, 2003 6:21 AM Subject: Re: (313) Re: hey ya? Just trying

Re: (313) Re: hey ya?

2003-12-21 Thread Lester Kenyatta Spence
Subject: Re: (313) Re: hey ya? Just trying to keep these three ideas (blacks are american, blacks are the other, pop music is an economic product) in my head simultaneously is a difficult feat. but suffice it to say that because of these dynamics I'm willing to bet that the following assertions

RE: (313) Re: hey ya?

2003-12-21 Thread Brendan Nelson
-Original Message- From: Lester Kenyatta Spence [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: 21 December 2003 06:50 There's been some attempt to actually test this empiricallyto see whether exposure to rap music (or other aggressive art forms like heavy metal) has an impact on how people

RE: (313) Re: hey ya?

2003-12-20 Thread andrewduke
On Fri, 19 Dec 2003 11:15:43 -, FC2 Richards wrote: Sorry to bust you open on this thread, but last time I listened to the words of hey ya it was all about waiting for the right girl. My wife happens to think that is the sweetest song on the album just because of what it is about.

Re: (313) Re: hey ya?

2003-12-20 Thread Cyclone Louise Wehner
I think it was dream hampton who wrote about how women - especially women of colour - listen and appreciate gangsta rap styles and somehow listen 'beyond' what could be construed as misogynism. Let's be frank: the truth is that sexism is not deemed as offensive cuturally as racism, accuse a racist

Re: (313) Re: hey ya?

2003-12-20 Thread spacecrusher
lets also point out that for all the misogynism in hip hop, while to some degree it might be looked over from a female perspective of those who like that music... there is also an arguably reciprical aspect going on in hip hop and rb. i.e. to some degree there's a two way street, mutually

Re: (313) Re: hey ya?

2003-12-20 Thread Kent williams
On Sat, 20 Dec 2003, spacecrusher wrote: lets also point out that for all the misogynism in hip hop, It comes in many flavors -- straight up women-hating, parody of straight up women-hating, ironic, comic, critique of misogyny -- and it comes down to who's saying it, why they're saying it, and

RE: (313) Re: hey ya?

2003-12-19 Thread FC2 Richards
Sorry to bust you open on this thread, but last time I listened to the words of hey ya it was all about waiting for the right girl. My wife happens to think that is the sweetest song on the album just because of what it is about. She can look past the whole bitch thing, and I think most people