Re: [Freevo-users] S-Presso and Freevo

2006-10-15 Thread Evan Hisey
Karl- 1. The GPL is _viral_. This was a major reason behind it's creation and why an LGPL was also written. If you use, modify, distribute GPL code you are under the requirements of the GPL. The LGPL allows for linking of libraries and such with out triggering the viral effect. It most definitely

Re: [Freevo-users] S-Presso and Freevo

2006-10-14 Thread Karl Lattimer
On Sun, 2006-10-15 at 10:46 +1000, Elizabeth Dodd wrote: > On Sunday 15 October 2006 10:38, Karl Lattimer wrote: > > All they are required to do is respect the copyright > > holders, distribute the GPL or tell interested parties what license it > > is and where they can get a copy of it, and where

Re: [Freevo-users] S-Presso and Freevo

2006-10-14 Thread Elizabeth Dodd
On Sunday 15 October 2006 10:38, Karl Lattimer wrote: > All they are required to do is respect the copyright > holders, distribute the GPL or tell interested parties what license it > is and where they can get a copy of it, and where the code they used can > be obtained. not quite, you can no long

Re: [Freevo-users] S-Presso and Freevo

2006-10-14 Thread Karl Lattimer
On Sun, 2006-10-15 at 09:56 +1000, Elizabeth Dodd wrote: > On Sunday 15 October 2006 09:33, Karl Lattimer wrote: > > After reading a little of this thread I'm wondering what it is exactly > > you're expecting Asus to give you? If you're looking at getting the code > > for their front panel stuff th

Re: [Freevo-users] S-Presso and Freevo

2006-10-14 Thread Karl Lattimer
On Sat, 2006-10-14 at 19:10 -0500, Evan Hisey wrote: > Karl- > They do have to make the GPLed code available. If they have made any > mod's to the code to get it to work on their hardware then those have > to be released. Sorry this is a very primitive understanding of the GPL and its implicati

Re: [Freevo-users] S-Presso and Freevo

2006-10-14 Thread Evan Hisey
Karl- They do have to make the GPLed code available. If they have made any mod's to the code to get it to work on their hardware then those have to be released. If they have written all new code under a different lic. they can keep that. I just want to be able to get what I am legally entitled to

Re: [Freevo-users] S-Presso and Freevo

2006-10-14 Thread Elizabeth Dodd
On Sunday 15 October 2006 09:33, Karl Lattimer wrote: > After reading a little of this thread I'm wondering what it is exactly > you're expecting Asus to give you? If you're looking at getting the code > for their front panel stuff then I'd think again. It is within the GPL > to produce custom code

Re: [Freevo-users] S-Presso and Freevo

2006-10-14 Thread Karl Lattimer
On Sun, 2006-10-15 at 08:23 +1000, Elizabeth Dodd wrote: > On Sunday 15 October 2006 02:46, Evan Hisey wrote: > > Elizabeth- > >Any Idea wha the mini distro is? They should have a good shot at > > enforcing the source code redistrobution clause. Asus's lawyers are > > already familiar with the

Re: [Freevo-users] S-Presso and Freevo

2006-10-14 Thread Elizabeth Dodd
On Sunday 15 October 2006 02:46, Evan Hisey wrote: > Elizabeth- >    Any Idea wha the mini distro is? They should have a good shot at > enforcing the source code redistrobution clause. Asus's lawyers are > already familiar with the GPL issues they are going to run into. > > Evan It wouldn't boot on

Re: [Freevo-users] S-Presso and Freevo

2006-10-14 Thread Evan Hisey
Elizabeth- Any Idea wha the mini distro is? They should have a good shot at enforcing the source code redistrobution clause. Asus's lawyers are already familiar with the GPL issues they are going to run into. Evan On 10/14/06, Elizabeth Dodd <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > I'm building my Freevo

[Freevo-users] S-Presso and Freevo

2006-10-14 Thread Elizabeth Dodd
I'm building my Freevo on an S-Presso barebones box. This comes with a mini distro, which is probably in violation of the GPL. Asus, who make this do not offer source code to the distro - which would be a great thing indeed. I joined the Asus forum, mentioned gpl-violations.org and within hours m