RE: mesmerization

2005-04-02 Thread Stuart LeBlanc
To the extent that guitarists only compare themselves to other guitarists, they will have no bona fides as musicians. -Original Message- From: Michael Thames [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Friday, April 01, 2005 8:53 PM To: lute net; Stuart LeBlanc Subject: Re: mesmerization I had

Re: memorization/Re: Gallot speaks...

2005-04-02 Thread Jon Murphy
Wow, motion and motor - and time and space - and memory. How basic can you get. Both of you spend a lot of words and speculation on the forms of memory and analysis. But the process is not one or another, it is a combination. Do I memorize which finger goes to which fret, or do I memorize the

Re: sketches of spain lute

2005-04-02 Thread gary digman
Dear Jim; I do. I need jazz. I don't need the Who. That's just me. However, I don't need every expression of jazz that's put out. I'm not going to try to tell you that you should need jazz or that you should need the jazz I like. There's something for everybody. I don't know why we seem

Re: sketches of spain lute

2005-04-02 Thread Roman Turovsky
Dear Jim; I do. I need jazz. I don't need the Who. That's just me. However, I don't need every expression of jazz that's put out. I'm not going to try to tell you that you should need jazz or that you should need the jazz I like. There's something for everybody. I don't know why we seem to

Re: Poisoning the Lute List...

2005-04-02 Thread Roman Turovsky
during the, let us say, couple of years we have had amongst us an actor, a writer, who knows everything, who is able to tell who is good or bad player, who is good or bad composer, which music is good, which is bad, how to play the baroque lute, why not to play Kapsperger, why to worship as

Re: Poisoning the Lute List...

2005-04-02 Thread Roman Turovsky
As I said before, no jar of honey is complete without its blob of tar. Love to all, Marion Or a drowned fly. RT __ Roman M. Turovsky http://polyhymnion.org/swv Dear lutenists, during the, let us say, couple of years we have had amongst us an actor, a writer, who knows

Re: mesmerization

2005-04-02 Thread AJN (boston)
If I recall correctly, the Berlin Philharmonic played Beethoven's Fifth from memory when they appeared here in Boston a few years ago. They used a small chamber orchestra for that work. Doesn't Renato Fasano and his Virtuosi di Wherever also play from memory? As for Andre, I think his musicians

Historical Dance at Amherst EMF

2005-04-02 Thread AJN (boston)
Dorothy Olsson has asked me to forward this message to the lute list. AJN -- Forwarded Message -- From: Dorothy Olsson, INTERNET:[EMAIL PROTECTED] TO: AJN (boston), 71162,751 DATE: 3/29/05 5:49 PM Please join us for the … HISTORICAL DANCE PROGRAM AT THE AMHERST EARLY

Rock Lute

2005-04-02 Thread Thomas Schall
Dear list, for those interested (apart from Michael) I have put the music on my webpage as far as it is up to now. The final piece isn't ready yet and wll need a 10-course lute. I'll keep you informed. http://www.lautenist.de/rockpop1.pdf Best wishes Thomas -- Thomas Schall Niederhofheimer

Re: sketches of spain lute

2005-04-02 Thread chriswilke
Dear all, Everyone obviously has their own taste in music. However, let's not confuse like/dislike with good/bad. There is plenty of music (and art in general) that I can objectively recognize as good. That does not automatically translate into personal pleasure, though. So if you like

Re: Rock Lute

2005-04-02 Thread Christopher Schaub
Yes, this is really great. I love the Scorpions addition too! I used to skip school as a kid to go see rock concerts, especially the Scorpions. If we skipped school we then earned the right to be right up to the stage, get our chests pressed into a metal fence and occassionally beat up by a random

RE: mesmerization

2005-04-02 Thread Mayes, Joseph
Gosh! Stuart That's hard to argue with - unless one were to point out that the same would hold true for any other (splinter)group of musicians - say lute players Joseph Mayes From: Stuart LeBlanc [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Sat 4/2/2005 5:39 AM To: lute

Re: mesmerization

2005-04-02 Thread Roman Turovsky
There are a number of lutenists that compare with other instrumental virtuosi, and there are/were a few guitarists of that caliber too. RT __ Roman M. Turovsky http://polyhymnion.org/swv From: Mayes, Joseph [EMAIL PROTECTED] Gosh! Stuart That's hard to argue with - unless one were

Re: sketches of spain lute

2005-04-02 Thread Michael Thames
I am not a big jazz fan, but Strayhorn's Daydream is as great a piece of music as anything classical. And having The Who??? in the same paragraph is preposterous. The only RR entity that ever could stand up to classical and be judjed (favorably) on classical terms was KingCrimson's LIZARD. RT

Re: mesmerization

2005-04-02 Thread Michael Thames
To the extent that guitarists only compare themselves to other guitarists, they will have no bona fides as musicians. Is there such a thing as a Bona fide musician? This also has it's drawbacks, guitarist's who compare themselves to bona fides, do silly things like start transcribing,

Re: memorization/Re: Gallot speaks...

2005-04-02 Thread Dr. Marion Ceruti
-Original Message- From: Jon Murphy [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Apr 2, 2005 3:59 AM To: Dr. Marion Ceruti [EMAIL PROTECTED], Ed Durbrow [EMAIL PROTECTED], lute list lute@cs.dartmouth.edu Subject: Re: memorization/Re: Gallot speaks... Wow, motion and motor - and time and

Re: Rock Lute

2005-04-02 Thread Phalese
Hi, Nice idea, but Stairway to Heaven does contain quite a few mistakes for example in bar 8 the bass is B A A and not G A A . best wishes Mark -- To get on or off this list see list information at http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/~wbc/lute-admin/index.html

Re: Rock Lute

2005-04-02 Thread Thomas Schall
Hi Mark, yes - I finally found some more mistakes and will correct them. I'll tell when I corrected them. Thanks for helping! Best wishes Thomas Am Samstag, 2. April 2005 21:02 schrieb [EMAIL PROTECTED]: Hi, Nice idea, but Stairway to Heaven does contain quite a few mistakes for example in

Re: Il Sig Napolitano

2005-04-02 Thread Donatella Galletti
Well, it says we don't know much, in fact. I'll try to write more as soon as I have time Donatella - Original Message - From: sterling price [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: BAROQUE-LUTE@cs.dartmouth.edu Sent: Tuesday, March 15, 2005 1:22 AM Subject: Re: Il Sig Napolitano Hi- I have been playing

Re: Rock Lute

2005-04-02 Thread Greg Silverman
Thomas Schall wrote: Dear list, for those interested (apart from Michael) I have put the music on my webpage as far as it is up to now. The final piece isn't ready yet and wll need a 10-course lute. I'll keep you informed. http://www.lautenist.de/rockpop1.pdf Thomas, Thanks for this. My

Re: mesmerization

2005-04-02 Thread Roman Turovsky
Telemann wrote quartets for 4 violins, and Wagenseil wrote quartets for 4 cellos. Very fine music, especially the latter. RT __ Roman M. Turovsky http://polyhymnion.org/swv On a side note.. I never got this thing about 4 guitars, you don't go hear 4 pianos, 4 orchestras, ( as the

RE: mesmerization

2005-04-02 Thread Mayes, Joseph
Well, normally I would consider this as too far out to engender a reply...But... Let's see if understand the point: You'er saying that if the lute were to be included in every piece of music in which it could be included, that that would be an enormous repertoire. I'll have to agree. It

Re: sketches of spain lute

2005-04-02 Thread Roman Turovsky
I am not a big jazz fan, but Strayhorn's Daydream is as great a piece of music as anything classical. And having The Who??? in the same paragraph is preposterous. The only RR entity that ever could stand up to classical and be judjed (favorably) on classical terms was KingCrimson's LIZARD.

Re: mesmerization

2005-04-02 Thread Thomas Schall
Please excuse - what is the relevance of the sheer quantity of repertoire? I feel that lutenists have an vast amount of music to select from - much more than a single player could play in his lifetime. The 19th century guitar was very popular and there is also a lot of repertoire. So neither

Re: mesmerization

2005-04-02 Thread Roman Turovsky
The guitar does suffer from only being included in duos with the flute, violin, viola, 'cello, voice, piano, string quartet, and orchestra - to More often than not in a rather cheesy fashion. RT name but some - so I guess you're right on both counts. To get on or off this list see list

Re: mesmerization

2005-04-02 Thread Roman Turovsky
Please excuse - what is the relevance of the sheer quantity of repertoire? Exactly. No quantity of Carculliani will ever justify any perusal. RT To get on or off this list see list information at http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/~wbc/lute-admin/index.html

Re: sketches of spain lute

2005-04-02 Thread Michael Thames
Roman, I'm thinking of making my own ornament of Thick As A Brick, or Teacher, or Living in The Past All by Jerthro Tull .And dedicating it to you. Any ideas anyone? JT is fine. Just no The Huh, please. RT Now, WHO, are you speaking of? Michael Thames

Re: sketches of spain lute

2005-04-02 Thread Thomas Schall
Hey! Great you like JT, too! Much of their music works great on lute - on baroque lute I like to play Locomotive breath and other songs from Aqualung while Thick as a brick doesn't work properly on a B-Lute but well on a R-Lute - I'll add excerps of it to my rock-pop lute soon (as I hope).

Re: sketches of spain lute

2005-04-02 Thread Roman Turovsky
On the other hand, there's some music that I know is not of the highest artistic merit, but I enjoy anyway. Can I really justify Black Sabbath? Estonian medieval ensemble Rondellus did an entire CD of Black Sabbath covers translated into Latin. No musical problems whatsoever. RT To get on or

7-course - 6-course

2005-04-02 Thread Stephen Fryer
Already in the early 16th century there were some pieces being written for 7-course lute. Since at that time most lutes were 6-course this could have been a problem. Is there any eveidence of how players dealt with playing 7-course (or 8-course) music on a lute with only 6 courses? --

Re: sketches of spain lute

2005-04-02 Thread Thomas Schall
This album (Rondellus) is great! Highly recommended - we'll play spiral architect end of april in their version :-) (or what I was able to arrange from listening to their CD - their lutenist was willing to send me his sheets but they never arrived.) This one makes a great lute song - Steward

Re: sketches of spain lute

2005-04-02 Thread Michael Thames
Estonian medieval ensemble Rondellus did an entire CD of Black Sabbath covers translated into Latin. No musical problems whatsoever. RT No musical problems? The essential ingredient would be missing. massive amounts of distortion. Black Sabbath with out distortion! is equal to eating at

Re: sketches of spain lute

2005-04-02 Thread bill kilpatrick
there are some recent interviews with martin barre here: http://www.guitarnoise.com/ i liked juthro tull till i saw them play live - i think it was ian anderson's brand new blue jeans, carefully ripped at the knee that made me loose interest. nice guitar though ... - bill --- Thomas Schall

Re: 7-course - 6-course

2005-04-02 Thread Tim Beasley
If I may presume to respond: Adapt is one writer's counsel. Coelho, Victor Anand. Authority , autonomy, and interpretation in 17-century Italian lute music. Pp. 108-141. In: Coelho, Victor Anand. Performance on Lute, Guitar, and Vihela. CUP: Cambridge, 1997. Pp. 125-126 Garsi's famous

Re: sketches of spain lute

2005-04-02 Thread Thomas Schall
fantastic what you all take care of - I couldn't tell the clothes of those musicians Ian Anderson lost his voice - what's a pity but I still enjoy their live performances because they make the best out of it and have more to offer than to celebrate past success. Thomas Am Sonntag, 3.

RE: mesmerization

2005-04-02 Thread Stuart LeBlanc
No disrespect intended Joseph, but you might read my message again more carefully. If you want to know what my experience with guitar is you can take a look at http://www.stuartleblanc.org/music.htm -Original Message- From: Mayes, Joseph [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Saturday, April

Re: mesmerization

2005-04-02 Thread Roman Turovsky
No disrespect intended Joseph, but you might read my message again more carefully. If you want to know what my experience with guitar is you can take a look at http://www.stuartleblanc.org/music.htm Hey, Stuart, You have Ozu on your hero list. You just raised my hope in this country 200%! RT

Re: 7-course - 6-course

2005-04-02 Thread Dr. Marion Ceruti
Dear Stephen, It is always hard to get a dollar out of 99 cents. If you have fewer courses than the instrument for which the piece was written you can deal with it in a variety of ways. My approach has been either to play the bass note an octave higher, select a different inversion for the

RE: mesmerization

2005-04-02 Thread Stuart LeBlanc
I'm delighted we agree on that, but I would have expected you to be more excited about Andrei Tarkovsky! Nontheless I will sleep easily tonight, knowing that I have done my country a great service. -Original Message- From: Roman Turovsky [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Saturday, April

Re: mesmerization

2005-04-02 Thread Roman Turovsky
AT is too easy a choice RT I'm delighted we agree on that, but I would have expected you to be more excited about Andrei Tarkovsky! Nontheless I will sleep easily tonight, knowing that I have done my country a great service. -Original Message- From: Roman Turovsky

Re: mesmerization

2005-04-02 Thread Roman Turovsky
I'm delighted we agree on that, but I would have expected you to be more excited about Andrei Tarkovsky! How 'bout Ermanno Olmi? RT -- http://polyhymnion.org/torban Nontheless I will sleep easily tonight, knowing that I have done my country a great service. -Original

RE: mesmerization

2005-04-02 Thread chriswilke
Stuart, I for one am excited about Tarkovsky! - a great artist who's films are not films, but pieces of music. (I suppose he would've argued more for poetry.) Andrei Rublev changed my world and made me much more serious about my art. I'm also a fan of Bresson and Bergman. Chris ---

Newbie Question #2

2005-04-02 Thread Tim Beasley
Thanks all for a lot of great advice. It's greatly appreciated. I've (obviously) been doing a bit of reading. One luthier's webpage I ran across pointed out that 6-course Renaissance music doesn't suffer horribly on 7/8-course lutes, but that one should never even think of playing music

Re: sketches of spain lute

2005-04-02 Thread Michael Thames
I remember seeing Ian Anderson on a show a few years ago called Real Time with Bill Maher I was shocked to see how conservative he looked compared to the wild days of the 70's. I've heard he's one of the richest men in rock and roll. Michael Thames www.ThamesClassicalGuitars.com - Original

Re: Newbie Question #2

2005-04-02 Thread Dr. Marion Ceruti
-Original Message- From: Tim Beasley [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Apr 2, 2005 5:35 PM To: lute@cs.dartmouth.edu Subject: Newbie Question #2 Thanks all for a lot of great advice. It's greatly appreciated. I've (obviously) been doing a bit of reading. One luthier's webpage I ran across

cinematheque (was RE: mesmerization)

2005-04-02 Thread Stuart LeBlanc
Haven't seen any of his work yet, although Il Posto has been on my list for a while. In lieu of that, Umberto D. is the most heartbreaking story I have ever watched on film. -Original Message- From: Roman Turovsky [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Saturday, April 02, 2005 6:56 PM To:

cinematheque (was RE: mesmerization)

2005-04-02 Thread Stuart LeBlanc
Yes, I'm trying to think of what music matches Tarkovsky... Arvo Pärt? Bresson's work has that same spiritual quality, but far more concisely and narratively rendered. Ockeghem? When I watch the multilayered films of Altman and Renoir I think of fugues. Although Bergman's films are more

Re: 7-course - 6-course

2005-04-02 Thread LGS-Europe
I sometimes tune my 6th course down. It doesn't work for every piece, but on a small instrument I can play a lot of 7-course music. David - Original Message - From: Stephen Fryer [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: Lute List lute@cs.dartmouth.edu Sent: Saturday, April 02, 2005 11:46 PM Subject: