On Mon, Feb 18, 2008 at 6:09 AM, Frederic Da Vitoria
<[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
>
> I don't have much against allowing it, but I certainly wouldn't want anybody
> to make me do it! If a CD I have is already in MB as part of a box set and I
> have a single CD release, I don't want to have to enter m
On Feb 15, 2008 12:09 AM, Aaron Cooper <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
> On 13-Feb-08, at 7:36 AM, Chris B wrote:
> > back to the proposal: i would say that we should allow all box sets to
> > be added even if they are a subset of a larger box, UNLESS that box is
> > just a box containing other, existi
> > How will they know which of the CDs in the box have been released in
> > the
> > past? How will they know how to group the CDs? What text on the
> > box or in
> > the insert do they look for?
>
> Excellent questions! Easy solution: Let's allow people to add
> separate releases for bo
On 14/02/2008, Aaron Cooper <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
> On 13-Feb-08, at 7:36 AM, Chris B wrote:
> > back to the proposal: i would say that we should allow all box sets to
> > be added even if they are a subset of a larger box, UNLESS that box is
> > just a box containing other, existing, boxes
On 14-Feb-08, at 3:36 PM, Jim DeLaHunt wrote:
What really want to understand, and don't, is what steps a contributor
should take, who has a box set in their hand, and no clue about other
releases or box sets.
How will they know what existing MB entries to look for? What
should they
do with t
On 13-Feb-08, at 7:36 AM, Chris B wrote:
back to the proposal: i would say that we should allow all box sets to
be added even if they are a subset of a larger box, UNLESS that box is
just a box containing other, existing, boxes (bear with me) - in which
case that's basically the same logic we app
Brian:
Brian Schweitzer wrote:
>
>
> I'm not disagreeing with you - if it's released separately, add just the
> standalone release. If it's added in a box, add the box.
>
> The problem I'm describing is the cases like the Brilliant Classics
> Master Composers series, or the Philips and B
On Feb 13, 2008 1:54 AM, Brian Schweitzer
<[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
> 1 Label A releases a classical CD.
> 2 Label B licenses that classical CD and includes it as disc 6 of a box set.
> 3 Label A releases a box set, also including that CD.
> 4 Label C licenses that CD and includes it as disc 9 of
On 13/02/2008, Brian Schweitzer <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
>
> > why treat classical box sets any different to normal box sets?
> >
> > if released separately: don't add the box set
> > if only released in boxset: add the box set
> > http://wiki.musicbrainz.org/BoxSetNameStyle
> >
> > if part rele
> why treat classical box sets any different to normal box sets?
>
> if released separately: don't add the box set
> if only released in boxset: add the box set
> http://wiki.musicbrainz.org/BoxSetNameStyle
>
> if part released only in the box set, and part not, add the whole box
> set for context
Brian Schweitzer wrote:
Box Sets, aka: what defines a unique classical release?
This one is a pain, but not just in classical.
I don't agree, I find BoxSetNameStyle sensible and good.
(This is not to say that there aren't problematic cases. Here is an
AddReleaseEdit for the second disc of a
On 13/02/2008, Brian Schweitzer <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
> Box Sets, aka: what defines a unique classical release?
>
> This one is a pain, but not just in classical. In classical, though,
> we tend to run into it a LOT more - Led Zep may put out one or two box
> sets, whereas the same classical
Just a clarification: When I talked about a "single CD", I'm talking
about a non-box set release. A release of, say, Don Giovani that
spans 2 or 3 CDs I would, under this suggestion, still consider a
"single" release as opposed to a Box Set release. (Box Set style
combines the two as a single con
Box Sets, aka: what defines a unique classical release?
This one is a pain, but not just in classical. In classical, though,
we tend to run into it a LOT more - Led Zep may put out one or two box
sets, whereas the same classical CD may be re-re-re-re-released in
many many box sets.
1 Label A rel
14 matches
Mail list logo
