Suggestion wrt XML Archetypes Templates

2007-12-10 Thread Adam Flinton
-bounces at openehr.org [mailto:openehr-technical- bounces at openehr.org] On Behalf Of Thomas Beale Sent: Monday, 10 December 2007 7:34 AM To: adam.flinton at nhs.net; For openEHR technical discussions Subject: Re: Suggestion wrt XML Archetypes Templates Adam Flinton wrote: I reserve my

Suggestion wrt XML Archetypes Templates

2007-12-10 Thread Laura Sato (NHS CFH)
at openehr.org] On Behalf Of Heath Frankel Sent: 10 December 2007 11:17 To: 'For openEHR technical discussions'; adam.flinton at nhs.net Subject: RE: Suggestion wrt XML Archetypes Templates No XML Schema changes required, in fact the schema already indicates that the string data should have space

Suggestion wrt XML Archetypes Templates

2007-12-09 Thread Thomas Beale
Adam Flinton wrote: I reserve my views wrt attributes vs text() however that would do on the proviso of a bit of testing with many tools as it used to be patchily supported by different tools. I accept that was a few years back things may well have improved. So then next question then

Suggestion wrt XML Archetypes Templates

2007-12-07 Thread Adam Flinton
Lisa Thurston wrote: Hi Adam and all I think there might have been some misunderstanding regarding the problem you raised. Yes Oxygen and XmlSpy will add unpredictable whitespace characters into an element when pretty printed and resaved. The problem is that the XML tools don't know they

Suggestion wrt XML Archetypes Templates

2007-12-03 Thread Adam Flinton
Chunlan Ma wrote: Dear Adam, I totally understand the XML issues that you described in your previous email. However, this problem doesn't exist if you use oXygen xml editor. I just downloaded Altova XMLSpy 2008. I opened an archetype XML file using XMLSpy 2008 and did pretty-print and then

Suggestion wrt XML Archetypes Templates

2007-12-03 Thread Adam Flinton
Gerard Freriks wrote: My question: - What is your justification for your statement? a) Safety b) Efficiency c) Best practice /| Microsoft uses a lot of XML documents in its products and many of them use/ /elements to contain values. In fact if you go to W3Cschools you will see /

Suggestion wrt XML Archetypes Templates

2007-12-03 Thread Adam Flinton
Gerard Freriks wrote: Thanks. But I'm curious in: Why? Why is you solution more safe? A) You are definitively bookending the string. This is exactly the same as you do within the ADL e.g. [at0002] = description = * text = Procedure

Suggestion wrt XML Archetypes Templates

2007-12-03 Thread Adam Flinton
Ian McNicoll wrote: Just for info, I have the latest version of XMLSpy 2008 and cannot reproduce the problem with Pretty-printing adding whitespace to element values. Although XMLspy rather nicely word breaks long text lines and indents appropriately, none of this whitesapce appears to be

Suggestion wrt XML Archetypes Templates

2007-12-03 Thread Adam Flinton
Thomas Beale wrote: Adam Flinton wrote: To quote from the oxygen xml page above: Although writing documents with no indentation is a perfectly acceptable practice, it makes editing difficult and is error prone. It also makes the identification of exact error positions difficult.

Suggestion wrt XML Archetypes Templates

2007-12-01 Thread Andrew Patterson
Note that that means that you would almost certainly have to specify collapse that no values could ever start or end with a space or contain more than one contiguous space. This is what is specified in the openehr schema for most of the elements you are talking about. For instance, all types

Suggestion wrt XML Archetypes Templates

2007-11-30 Thread Adam Flinton
as: archetype_idvalueopenEHR-EHR-ACTION.procedure.v1draft/value/archetype_id So are templates wrong archetypes right or vice versa? The included and unbounded attributes exist for both lower and upper with default values of false. Due to the openEHR assertions, you will never need more than 1 attribute on each

Suggestion wrt XML Archetypes Templates

2007-11-29 Thread Adam Flinton
archetypes templates which is that the values are contained as a text() child of an element sometimes as the text() child of a value child of the element. This is dangerous (IMHO) wrong. The reasons being that : A) a single value of that sort should be contained in an attribute. B) It leads

Archetypes

2007-11-20 Thread Greg Caulton
gomez adrian.gomez at hospitalitaliano.org.ar wrote: Where is the best information site o documentation to understand the archetypes technology. thanks Adrian Gomez Hospital Italiano de Buenos Aires ARGENTINA ___ openEHR-technical mailing list

Archetypes

2007-11-20 Thread Tim Cook
The Resources section is the place to start and the openEHR Primer and the openEHR Health Computing Platform are the first key documents to read. Then it depends on what you want to do; build archetypes, develop an application ... http://www.openehr.org/shared-resources/getting_started.html

New paper on archetypes

2007-11-15 Thread Thomas Beale
An authors' link to this paper is at: http://healthinformatics.cqu.edu.au/downloads/Garde_BDSArchetypes_2007.pdf - thomas beale Thomas Beale wrote: The following paper on archetypes and clinical data sets was recently published. * /*Expressing Clinical Data Sets with /open/EHR

New paper on archetypes

2007-11-14 Thread Thomas Beale
An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.openehr.org/mailman/private/openehr-technical_lists.openehr.org/attachments/20071114/15a1c295/attachment.html

Further value constraints: in Archetypes or Templates?

2007-10-30 Thread Koray Atalag
(wonderfully) in a previous thread about archetypes and templates, one can simply come to a conclusion that (almost) universal and non-volatile domain knowledge go into former while local/volatile knowledge go into latter. In any concept such constraints are an integral part of that domain

identifying and organizing of archetypes

2007-10-25 Thread Sebastian Garde
. For instance the NHS templates refer to an the ID but how do I know where to go to get that? You could simulate it quite easily for the archetypes: Base URL (e.g. http://svn.openehr.org/knowledge/archetypes/dev/adl/openehr/ehr/) + a folder as per the various Archetype classes (e.g. section/ or entry

identifying and organizing of archetypes

2007-10-24 Thread Greg Caulton
What is the unique identifier for each archetype? I assume it is the id e.g. openEHR-EHR-OBSERVATION.blood_pressure.v1 but is there no URI that I could always resolve to get the definition. For instance the NHS templates refer to an the ID but how do I know where to go to get that? The

Multiple parents and max number of nested specialized archetypes?

2007-10-22 Thread Lisa Thurston
An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.openehr.org/mailman/private/openehr-technical_lists.openehr.org/attachments/20071022/fb05b0eb/attachment.html

Multiple parents and max number of nested specialized archetypes?

2007-10-22 Thread Heath Frankel
I haven't followed this whole thread, in particular I haven't seen Rong's emails about templates and aggregation archetypes but I thought I would provide a little input about the future of the template specifications. If you have a look at the Template Object Model as published as a draft

Multiple parents and max number of nested specialized archetypes?

2007-10-22 Thread Rong Chen
Thanks all for the excellent explanations on the differences between archetypes and templates both from functional and technical point of view. I agree with Sebastian, these rather educational comments should be included in our FAQ page. On the technical side, I will be glad to review the early

Multiple parents and max number of nested specialized archetypes?

2007-10-21 Thread Hugh Leslie
An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.openehr.org/mailman/private/openehr-technical_lists.openehr.org/attachments/20071021/680fc2cd/attachment.html

Multiple parents and max number of nested specialized archetypes?

2007-10-19 Thread Sam Heard
An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.openehr.org/mailman/private/openehr-technical_lists.openehr.org/attachments/20071019/86ceb3ed/attachment.html -- next part -- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: OceanC_small.png Type: image/png Size: 4972 bytes

Multiple parents and max number of nested specialized archetypes?

2007-10-19 Thread Heather Leslie
. At the simplest and most obvious level, an archetype is a data specification for a single clinical concept. A specialisation is a type of archetype. A template is an aggregation of archetypes, some of which may be specialised, that are combined to carry out a particular clinical purpose eg a discharge summary

Multiple parents and max number of nested specialized archetypes?

2007-10-19 Thread Sam Heard
An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.openehr.org/mailman/private/openehr-technical_lists.openehr.org/attachments/20071019/5ef1c143/attachment.html -- next part -- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: OceanC_small.png Type: image/png Size: 4972 bytes

Multiple parents and max number of nested specialized archetypes?

2007-10-18 Thread Andrew Patterson
I should note that in the next generation of archetypes and tooling, archetype 'source' files for specialised archetypes will be 'differential' in nature - i.e. valid ADL, but containing only added and changed items from the parent, just as for subclasses in an object-oriented programming

Multiple parents and max number of nested specialized archetypes?

2007-10-18 Thread Erik Sundvall
archetypes, one designed for NHS by Ocean which is already a specialization of general histology archetype and the other archetype I am currently modeling, Bethesda System 2001. I have not experimented yet if my archetype can be redesigned as a specialization of NHS archetype (PAP

Multiple parents and max number of nested specialized archetypes?

2007-10-18 Thread Sam Heard
An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.openehr.org/mailman/private/openehr-technical_lists.openehr.org/attachments/20071018/3535f029/attachment.html -- next part -- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: OceanC_small.png Type: image/png Size: 4972 bytes

Multiple parents and max number of nested specialized archetypes?

2007-10-18 Thread Sebastian Garde
Hi, I also think we should avoid multiple inheritance - it is complex enough the way it is - from a tooling as well as from an archetype design point of view. We don't need to make it complicated in addition to complex. Like Erik, I don't know the details of these two archetypes, but I think

Multiple parents and max number of nested specialized archetypes?

2007-10-18 Thread Thomas Beale
Koray Atalag wrote: In my former message, with the question of writing down B and A for spelicalization section of C, I was proposing to write down the names of all archetypes till the top level in specialization archetype- like an absolute specialization path. This I think is not true

Multiple parents and max number of nested specialized archetypes?

2007-10-18 Thread Thomas Beale
Erik Sundvall wrote: Hi! Can one share important sub-parts without sharing view on process and structure. If so, will the information entered using the two different archetypes be computable in a similar way for e.g. decision support systems. this is why we have Cluster Structure

Multiple parents and max number of nested specialized archetypes?

2007-10-18 Thread Heather Leslie
: Thursday, 18 October 2007 8:46 AM To: For openEHR technical discussions Subject: RE: Multiple parents and max number of nested specialized archetypes? Hi, I also think we should avoid multiple inheritance - it is complex enough the way it is - from a tooling as well as from an archetype design point

Multiple parents and max number of nested specialized archetypes?

2007-10-18 Thread Stef Verlinden
ah - 'data quality' in other words - i.e. markers / meta-data relating to the data capture from the source, not the integrity of the data as represented on the openEHR system? I would like to expand that to data quality assurance. How can one objectively and according to locally accepted

Multiple parents and max number of nested specialized archetypes?

2007-10-18 Thread Heather Leslie
to constrain it for specific purpose. Clusters are in use all through the NHS archetypes/templates. I have found them especially useful in examination-related archetypes for very simple and universal concepts eg dimension, inspection, etc. These clusters will pop up amongst a large range

Multiple parents and max number of nested specialized archetypes?

2007-10-18 Thread Gerard Freriks
be to aim for a maximal Pap report archetype and use the template to constrain it for specific purpose. I agree. Clusters are in use all through the NHS archetypes/templates. I have found them especially useful in examination-related archetypes for very simple and universal

Multiple parents and max number of nested specialized archetypes?

2007-10-17 Thread Gerard Freriks
Dear Graham, Is multiple inheritance in the use case you presented, the only solution? I expect it is not. So why use it. When 'data integrity' is a recurring issue in several archetypes, re- use by inclusion of a 'data integrity' archetype in an other archetypes is a better other solution

Multiple parents and max number of nested specialized archetypes?

2007-10-17 Thread Thomas Beale
Grahame Grieve wrote: At the moment we have not seen any need for multiple inheritance in archetypes. I see this as very similar to multiple inheritance in objects. There is no *need*, but there is useful things that can be done. The question is whether the price is justified

Multiple parents and max number of nested specialized archetypes?

2007-10-17 Thread Heather Leslie
complex and time-consuming, reconciling back up to the parent once the lowest level of child requirements has been captured - I have experimented initially with mindmapping for these problems. To date they have been mainly related to principles of inspection and palpation in cluster archetypes

Multiple parents and max number of nested specialized archetypes?

2007-10-17 Thread Thomas Beale
Andrew Patterson wrote: I should note that in the next generation of archetypes and tooling, archetype 'source' files for specialised archetypes will be 'differential' in nature - i.e. valid ADL, but containing only added and changed items from the parent, just as for subclasses in an object

Multiple parents and max number of nested specialized archetypes?

2007-10-16 Thread Thomas Beale
Hi Koray, At the moment we have not seen any need for multiple inheritance in archetypes. Do you have a particular use case? Note that C specialising B means that C conforms to B and to A. Nothing special needed to do that. - thomas beale Koray Atalag wrote: Hi, I have a question about

Multiple parents and max number of nested specialized archetypes?

2007-10-16 Thread Koray Atalag
Hi, I have a question about the referencing of archetypes in specialization. And also want to know if there is a limit on the number of specializations of archetypes. For example: A is top level archetype B is specialization of A C has to further specialize B and there is possibility that D

[archetypes.com.au] Functionality to compare two archetypes

2007-09-18 Thread Sebastian Garde
' Subject: RE: [archetypes.com.au] Functionality to compare two archetypes Hi Sam, Of course it improves the risk for the user to unconsciously hide the changes the user is looking for, but in general I believe that it is a good thing to implement useful functionality even if it improves

[archetypes.com.au] Functionality to compare two archetypes

2007-09-13 Thread Sam Heard
An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.openehr.org/mailman/private/openehr-technical_lists.openehr.org/attachments/20070913/b263a212/attachment.html -- next part -- A non-text attachment was scrubbed... Name: OceanC_small.png Type: image/png Size: 4972 bytes

[archetypes.com.au] Functionality to compare two archetypes

2007-09-12 Thread Mikael Nyström
in the archetype. Otherwise it can be quite annoying to compare archetypes which contain many languages. Greetings, Mikael _ From: openehr-technical-boun...@openehr.org [mailto:openehr-technical-bounces at openehr.org] On Behalf Of Sebastian Garde Sent: den 10 september

[archetypes.com.au] Functionality to compare two archetypes

2007-09-12 Thread Mikael Nyström
Of Sam Heard Sent: den 12 september 2007 22:05 To: For openEHR technical discussions Subject: Re: [archetypes.com.au] Functionality to compare two archetypes Hi everyone We need to be careful here as this will show the changes and if there have (inadvertently) been changes in other languages then we

[archetypes.com.au] Functionality to compare two archetypes

2007-09-10 Thread Rong Chen
Hi Sebastian! It is a very nice piece of work you and Stefan have done! I fully agree that we need to make archetypes compatibility checking explicit and this is a very good start. It will be useful to publish the algorithm that you used for comparison so others could comment. And the same

[archetypes.com.au] Functionality to compare two archetypes

2007-09-10 Thread Thomas Beale
Rong Chen wrote: Hi Sebastian! It is a very nice piece of work you and Stefan have done! I fully agree that we need to make archetypes compatibility checking explicit and this is a very good start. It will be useful to publish the algorithm that you used for comparison so others could

[Archetypefinder] Archetypes as mindmaps, German archetypes

2007-08-08 Thread Sebastian Garde
Dear all, There is a new version of the Archetypefinder available at http://www.archetypes.com.au where you can easily find the latest openEHR archetypes. Most noticable changes: * we have included a browsable mindmap for each of the archetypes now (see e.g. http

[Archetypefinder] Archetypes as mindmaps, German archetypes

2007-08-08 Thread Russell Banks
Subject: [Archetypefinder] Archetypes as mindmaps, German archetypes Dear all, There is a new version of the Archetypefinder available at http://www.archetypes.com.au ( http://www.archetypes.com.au/ ) where you can easily find the latest openEHR archetypes. Most noticable changes: we have

Language tags within archetypes

2007-07-09 Thread Mikael Nyström
To: For openEHR technical discussions Subject: Language tags within archetypes Ocean has been recently doing some work in translating archetypes into Chilean Spanish which is proceeding well. We have come across a minor issue with standards for language tags and wanted to get the groups opinion

Instruction action archetypes?

2007-05-29 Thread Erik Sundvall
to an activity (since there are no state-related fields in the class named ACTIVITY except a pattern pointing out allowed action archetypes)? Maybe I am misunderstanding something here. Remember, many actions will be entered without an instruction - so no activity id is required Since the allowed

Runtime references to other archetypes?

2007-05-28 Thread Erik Sundvall
Hi! Do I understand correctly that (at least) the following two archetypes refer to specific parts (selected by paths) of other archetypes, and that these references will be created/selected by clinicians at runtime? http://svn.openehr.org/knowledge/archetypes/dev/html/en/openEHR-EHR

Instruction action archetypes?

2007-05-25 Thread Mattias Forss
: - Are there any examples of instruction archetypes with more than one activity anywhere? - If different activities (of the same instruction) point to different action archetypes how should then the resulting usage of the ISM be interpreted? Can they be considered part of the same process with some

ECG archetypes

2007-03-12 Thread mfj...@miba.auc.dk
Greetings All, Thank you for all the interesting replies on the request on ECG-archetypes. To clarify what our efforts in making an ECG-archetype are; We have, as part of our thesis, examined the standards; SCP-ECG, aECG (FDA-XML) and DICOM for storing and exchanging raw ECG and metadata

ECG archetypes

2007-03-11 Thread Sam Heard
An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.openehr.org/mailman/private/openehr-technical_lists.openehr.org/attachments/20070311/a0adcd71/attachment.html -- next part -- ___ openEHR-technical mailing list

ECG archetypes

2007-03-11 Thread Heath Frankel
Of Sam Heard Sent: Sunday, 11 March 2007 7:49 PM To: dclunie at dclunie.com; For openEHR technical discussions Subject: Re: ECG archetypes Hi David Absolutely not - what we need are readers that can make sense of data as a blob and get these specified as suitable for use in an EHR. Do you

ECG archetypes

2007-03-10 Thread Grahame Grieve
of the clinical implications - differential diagnosis etc and will include more archetypes than the straight physiology and decision support data. Cheers, Sam Gerard Freriks wrote: Yes. Have a look at what is available at the machine interface and decide wether you really want this, need

ECG archetypes

2007-03-09 Thread Gerard Freriks
Engineering and Informatics. In this semester ? our finale, we are working with complex data interoperability to an Electronic Health Record (EHR). We are following the openEHR?s EHR architecture standard, and therefore also working with archetypes. We have a few questions we would like you

ECG archetypes

2007-03-09 Thread Ian McNicoll
Freriks [mailto:gf...@luna.nl] Sent: 09 March 2007 09:24 To: For openEHR clinical discussions Cc: Melvin I Reynolds; 06gr956d at miba.auc.dk; For openEHR technical discussions Subject: Re: ECG archetypes Dear Colleague, -1- I assume that you want to store all ECG measurements and not only

ECG archetypes

2007-03-09 Thread Karsten Hilbert
it as a blob and handing it out to the original application on demand. Now, of course, *any* data can be made sense of given appropriate specs. Also, that's the whole purpose of archetypes - to make data self-descriptive and self-consistent. And in an ideal world one would want to map the original

ECG archetypes

2007-03-09 Thread Gerard Freriks
Yes. Have a look at what is available at the machine interface and decide wether you really want this, need this in the EHR. Or only a limited subset. Gerard -- private -- Gerard Freriks, MD Huigsloterdijk 378 2158 LR Buitenkaag The Netherlands T: +31 252544896 M: +31 620347088 E:

ECG archetypes

2007-03-08 Thread Mie Faerch Jensen
architecture standard, and therefore also working with archetypes. We have a few questions we would like you to help us deal with. - What we are trying to investigate is how to represent a recorded ECG-signal in an archetype, and therefore we are wondering what the status is on dealing with ECG

CEN published En13606-1 EHRcom. Tutorial about Archetypes

2007-03-07 Thread ognian.pis...@oceaninformatics.biz
It's not a nasty word. But the revolution is over. Now it's implementation time. This is a typical case of an innovation that is mature enough to be implemented by many not only by the original inventors. Venture capitalists don't like revolutionary, it's true. O. Pishev Quoting Gerard Freriks

CEN published En13606-1 EHRcom. Tutorial about Archetypes

2007-03-07 Thread Gerard Freriks
Okay Ognian. Let us settle for your point of view and agree. In the mean time you all know that it is, has to be true. The railway and locomotive, the steam engine in ships, the telephone, the fax, the PC, Internet, the printed book or newspaper, and many more things were paradigm shifts, were

CEN published En13606-1 EHRcom. Tutorial about Archetypes

2007-03-07 Thread ognian.pis...@oceaninformatics.biz
Quoting Gerard Freriks gfrer at luna.nl: Okay Ognian. Let us settle for your point of view and agree. In the mean time you all know that it is, has to be true. The railway and locomotive, the steam engine in ships, the telephone, the fax, the PC, Internet, the printed book or

CEN published En13606-1 EHRcom. Tutorial about Archetypes

2007-03-07 Thread Karsten Hilbert
On Wed, Mar 07, 2007 at 12:43:51AM +0100, Gerard Freriks wrote: ... ... revolutions, that changed society ... Past Tense ... And EN13606 and openEHR will be the same. Future Tense Revolutionary can only be applied after the fact. Karsten -- GPG key ID E4071346 @ wwwkeys.pgp.net E167

CEN published En13606-1 EHRcom. Tutorial about Archetypes

2007-03-06 Thread Gerard Freriks
. And is exactly what healthcare of the future needs In the attachment a draft presentation with more information about the CEN standards. March 29 and 30 a tutorial about the new revolutionary European EHR standard and Archetypes will be held in Leiden. More information can be found at: http

CEN published En13606-1 EHRcom. Tutorial about Archetypes

2007-03-06 Thread Karsten Hilbert
Anything dubbed revolutionary raises cautionary red flags. As Adrian Midgley once aptly put it: Ars longa, IT brevis. Karsten On Tue, Mar 06, 2007 at 12:10:09PM +0100, Gerard Freriks wrote: Subject: CEN published En13606-1 EHRcom. Tutorial about Archetypes X-Mailer: Apple Mail

CEN published En13606-1 EHRcom. Tutorial about Archetypes

2007-03-06 Thread Gerard Freriks
Dear Karsten, For several reasons I was using that special nasty word revolutionary. -1- To be able to get 'plug-and-play' interoperability as opposed to the very big problem of implementing many messages across vendors in a uniform way, is REVOLUTIONARY. -2- To have a standard with

Archetype lists and possible archetypes

2007-02-22 Thread Chunlan Ma
Dear Sam, Excludes and Includes, open/closed might serve most requirements. We do need certain rules as well, e.g. can we set a slot which excludes all. Like Gerard and Koray had mentioned, I agree to have a way to categorise the archetypes. That would make the includes and excludes lots

Archetype lists and possible archetypes

2007-02-21 Thread Sam Heard
An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.openehr.org/mailman/private/openehr-technical_lists.openehr.org/attachments/20070221/3ad85e5e/attachment.html -- next part -- ___ openEHR-technical mailing list

Archetype lists and possible archetypes

2007-02-21 Thread Gerard Freriks
Sam, About restricting slots. It must not be an on/off type of restriction. Is it possible to have 'types of archetypes'? And then. What 'types' are needed? Isn't there a need for an 'Archetype ontology' that helps provide 'types of archetypes'? Gerard -- private -- Gerard Freriks, MD

Problem in some sample archetypes and questions

2007-01-09 Thread Sam Heard
An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.openehr.org/mailman/private/openehr-technical_lists.openehr.org/attachments/20070109/087aad98/attachment.html -- next part -- ___ openEHR-technical mailing list

Problem in some sample archetypes and questions

2007-01-08 Thread Sam Heard
An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: http://lists.openehr.org/mailman/private/openehr-technical_lists.openehr.org/attachments/20070108/b36218e3/attachment.html -- next part -- ___ openEHR-technical mailing list

Problem in some sample archetypes and questions

2007-01-08 Thread Mattias Forss
2007/1/8, Koray Atalag atalagk at yahoo.com: Currently both the Editor and the Workbench allow these type of errors. Hi Koray, The latest code of the Java Archetype Editor now validates cardinalities. It also has support for all but the demographics archetypes now. Lots of new improvements

Problem in some sample archetypes and questions

2007-01-08 Thread Koray Atalag
Sam Heard wrote: Thanks Koray Your expression of cardinality and occurrences is exactly correct - there are clearly some errors in the archetypes. The only reason to limit cardinality in the archetype is to force a choice when there are more than one child e.g. container x

Problem in some sample archetypes and questions

2007-01-08 Thread Koray Atalag
of archetype design - ones that most probably will never encounter while designing their archetypes. Best regards and Bedankt! -koray ___ openEHR-technical mailing list openEHR-technical at openehr.org http://www.chime.ucl.ac.uk/mailman/listinfo/openehr

Problem in some sample archetypes and questions

2007-01-08 Thread Rong Chen
. * another one would be to make a number of ITEM_TREE or ITEM_LIST archetype of the relevant piece of content as separate archetypes, and use slots to include particular subsets. * a third possibility is to use invariants to prevent certain paths from existing that would otherwise be allowed

Problem in some sample archetypes and questions

2007-01-08 Thread Mattias Forss
of reference, you create a CLUSTER node, and then individually reference the subset of paths of items from the target CLUSTER that you want, but not others. * another one would be to make a number of ITEM_TREE or ITEM_LIST archetype of the relevant piece of content as separate archetypes, and use

Problem in some sample archetypes and questions

2007-01-08 Thread Jose Alberto Maldonado
. * another one would be to make a number of ITEM_TREE or ITEM_LIST archetype of the relevant piece of content as separate archetypes, and use slots to include particular subsets. * a third possibility is to use invariants to prevent certain paths from existing

[Norton AntiSpam] Re: Problem in some sample archetypes and questions

2007-01-08 Thread Mattias Forss
want, but not others. * another one would be to make a number of ITEM_TREE or ITEM_LIST archetype of the relevant piece of content as separate archetypes, and use slots to include particular subsets. * a third possibility is to use invariants to prevent certain paths from existing

Problem in some sample archetypes and questions

2007-01-07 Thread Koray Atalag
Hi to all, While revising my MST archetypes, I came across some confusion on the use of cardinality and occurences. And when I reread ADL 1.4 and ADL2, inspected the sample archetypes and then created new ones with Archetype Editor and also tested with the Workbench my confusion got even more

XML archetypes

2006-11-13 Thread Mattias Forss
Hi, I am doing some experiments on a XML serializer for the Java archetype editor. I wonder if there are any example XML archetypes that I can look at to verify that I follow the XML-schema documentation correctly? Regards, Mattias -- next part -- An HTML attachment

Antw: Re: Antw: Re: AW: HL7 templates/archetypes

2006-10-19 Thread Amnon Shabo
Subject Antw: Re: Antw: Re: AW: HL7 16/10/06 21:19templates/archetypes

Antw: Re: Antw: Re: AW: HL7 templates/archetypes

2006-10-17 Thread Bert Verhees
Williamtfgoossen at cs.com schreef: Good Point Ed, Until now the list of actual OpenEHR implementation I have actually seen working is 0 William, I told before on this list, English is not even my second language, but I do what I can to be understandable. --- Now to your Good Point, Ed

Antw: Re: Antw: Re: Antw: Re: AW: HL7 templates/archetypes

2006-10-17 Thread williamtfgoos...@cs.com
to the dinosaur systems for GPs, stemming from the 80 ies, I agree, these have difficulties with HL7 v3, and they would have similar troubles with OpenEHR archetypes. My point is that you need to change to new desigs to make it work. Thanks for the feedback -- next part

Antw: Re: Antw: Re: Antw: Re: AW: HL7 templates/archetypes

2006-10-17 Thread Stap, R.E. (Roel)
: Re: Antw: Re: AW: HL7 templates/archetypes Yes Bert, I agree with many of the problems. My point was: today I cannot go to a live implementation of a OpenEHR system. You support this. Today I can point you at least to 3 working systems that have HL7 v3 Care Provision as the founding

Antw: Re: Antw: Re: AW: HL7 templates/archetypes

2006-10-17 Thread Thomas Beale
William E Hammond wrote: You assume the worst of me. It seems that looking at actual implementations of both 13606 and V3 will provide excellent experience data for both groups. I know V3 implementations, and did not know many 13606 implementations, altho I do know one system that has

Antw: Re: Antw: Re: Antw: Re: AW: HL7 templates/archetypes

2006-10-17 Thread Thomas Beale
Williamtfgoossen at cs.com wrote: Yes Bert, I agree with many of the problems. My point was: today I cannot go to a live implementation of a OpenEHR system. You support this. actually, you can. We'll give you the URL of the webservice interface whenever you want it;-) - thomas beale

AW: HL7 templates/archetypes

2006-10-16 Thread Gerard Freriks
. For instance the HL7v3 Mood attribute in the HL7v3 RIM will map onto a specific type of Archetype. Types of Archetypes are based on a model of clinical treatment: Observation, Evaluation, Instruction and Action. And types of Archetypes are not attributes of the Reference Model

AW: HL7 templates/archetypes

2006-10-16 Thread Ognian Pishev
:19 AM Subject: Re: AW: HL7 templates/archetypes On Oct 15, 2006, at 2:34 PM, Gerard Freriks wrote: Dear Dana, Why would you like to do that? Theoretically it might be possible to map computationally constraints imposed on one model to others imposed on an other, where both

Antw: Re: HL7 templates/archetypes

2006-10-16 Thread williamtfgoos...@cs.com
I believe it is very hard to accept the dogmatic approach of Gerard Freriks once again :-( I thought we would have stopped, working on the implementable harmonization artifacts. It has been proven to work with HL7 v3 messages. For clinical content it does not matter at all in which technical

Antw: Re: AW: HL7 templates/archetypes

2006-10-16 Thread williamtfgoos...@cs.com
In een bericht met de datum 15-10-2006 23:54:28 West-Europa (zomertijd), schrijft gfrer at luna.nl: What might be possible in a way, is to transform from CEN to HL7 and back again when a R-MIM is used that is an agreed mapping of the CEN/tc251 EN13606 part 1 Reference Model using the RIM.

Antw: HL7 templates/archetypes

2006-10-16 Thread Stap, R.E. (Roel)
Dear William, I am currently working on the creation of Diabetes related archetypes based on common archetypes. These archetypes are used to be specialised in templates for use in diabetes protocol support systems. Please, can you provide me with one example where you have an HL7 compliant

AW: HL7 templates/archetypes

2006-10-16 Thread Thomas Beale
Gregory Woodhouse wrote: On Oct 15, 2006, at 2:34 PM, Gerard Freriks wrote: Dear Dana, Why would you like to do that? Theoretically it might be possible to map computationally constraints imposed on one model to others imposed on an other, where both ways express the same clinical

Antw: Re: HL7 templates/archetypes

2006-10-16 Thread Thomas Beale
not matter at all in which technical formalism or spec it is operationalised. A clinical concept sorting out takes 2 weeks, transforming from HL7 to Open EHR takes 15 minutes. Hi William, I think one needs to be careful with such claims. Properly designing archetypes can take quite a lot

Antw: Re: AW: HL7 templates/archetypes

2006-10-16 Thread Thomas Beale
Williamtfgoossen at cs.com wrote: In een bericht met de datum 15-10-2006 23:54:28 West-Europa (zomertijd), schrijft gfrer at luna.nl: What might be possible in a way, is to transform from CEN to HL7 and back again when a R-MIM is used that is an agreed mapping of the CEN/tc251 EN13606

CEN and HL7 methods and archetypes

2006-10-16 Thread Gerard Freriks
or presented or discussed several times at various occasions, are: Harmonisation: CEN and HL7 Harmonisation between CEN EN13606 EHRcom and HL7v2 is not taking place. Harmonisation between CEN EN13606 plus its Archetypes and HL7v3 message artefacts is not possible. Harmonisation between CEN and HL7

Antw: Re: AW: HL7 templates/archetypes

2006-10-16 Thread Gerard Freriks
William, Since when is it a lie when one states his opinion? Read my other e-mail where I state more opinions and provide some arguments. Read in that e-mail also the fact that CEN/tc251 EN13606 and OpenEHR are based on many years of RD and real implementations. EN13606 EHRcom is factual NOT

<    1   2   3   4   5   6   >