[osol-discuss] Opensolaris - just a fake? (was: Re: [ksh93-integration-discuss] some questions about ksh93 integration)

2006-08-24 Thread Martin Schaffstall
On 8/24/06, Dan Price [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: On Thu 24 Aug 2006 at 12:35AM, Roland Mainz wrote: I have a couple of questions regarding the shape of the project: - What is the nature of the replacing of libcmd.so? If I'm not mistaken, I noticed that the existing

Re: [osol-discuss] Opensolaris - just a fake? (was: Re: [ksh93-integration-discuss] some questions about ksh93 integration)

2006-08-24 Thread James Carlson
Martin Schaffstall writes: It is interesting to observe that each time the project reaches another milestone a Sun employee steps in and demands a full change of the project. Very suspicious. Good grief! Would it be at all possible to comment on the technical issues with this project without

Re: [osol-discuss] Opensolaris - just a fake? (was: Re: [ksh93-integration-discuss] some questions about ksh93 integration)

2006-08-24 Thread Martin Schaffstall
On 8/24/06, James Carlson [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Martin Schaffstall writes: It is interesting to observe that each time the project reaches another milestone a Sun employee steps in and demands a full change of the project. Very suspicious. Good grief! Would it be at all possible to

Re: [osol-discuss] Opensolaris - just a fake? (was: Re: [ksh93-integration-discuss] some questions about ksh93 integration)

2006-08-24 Thread Stephen Lau
Martin Schaffstall wrote: It is interesting to observe that each time the project reaches another milestone a Sun employee steps in and demands a full change of the project. Very suspicious. It is interesting to observe that each time a Sun employee steps in and raises valid engineering

Re: [osol-discuss] Opensolaris - just a fake? (was: Re: [ksh93-integration-discuss] some questions about ksh93 integration)

2006-08-24 Thread Joshua Clulow
Martin Schaffstall wrote: If you want my opinion: Sun is SABOTAGING the project In as polite and respectful a manner as is possible under the circumstances: I feel it's probably safe to say that we don't want your opinion if it is as nonconstructive as that. You're not really helping

Re: [osol-discuss] Opensolaris - just a fake? (was: Re: [ksh93-integration-discuss] some questions about ksh93 integration)

2006-08-24 Thread Raquel Velasco and Bill Buck
Martin, if you really feel as if this is the case then please post some detailed support for your allegation. Observations are fine, but when they are as serious as this they need to be backed up with facts. Do it here. We bet you'll get a sincere, detailed response that leaves you

Re: [osol-discuss] Opensolaris - just a fake? (was: Re: [ksh93-integration-discuss] some questions about ksh93 integration)

2006-08-24 Thread Stephen Lau
Martin Schaffstall wrote: On 8/24/06, James Carlson [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Martin Schaffstall writes: It is interesting to observe that each time the project reaches another milestone a Sun employee steps in and demands a full change of the project. Very suspicious. Good grief! Would it

Re: [osol-discuss] Opensolaris - just a fake? (was: Re: [ksh93-integration-discuss] some questions about ksh93 integration)

2006-08-24 Thread Alan Coopersmith
Martin Schaffstall wrote: It is interesting to observe that each time the project reaches another milestone a Sun employee steps in and demands a full change of the project. Very suspicious. It is interesting to observe that your only contributions to this project are to flame people trying to

Re: [osol-discuss] Opensolaris - just a fake? (was: Re: [ksh93-integration-discuss] some questions about ksh93 integration)

2006-08-24 Thread Mike Kupfer
Martin == Martin Schaffstall [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Martin It is interesting to observe that each time the project reaches Martin another milestone a Sun employee steps in and demands a full Martin change of the project. Very suspicious. Unfortunately, these things happen sometimes with

Re: [osol-discuss] Opensolaris - just a fake? (was: Re: [ksh93-integration-discuss] some questions about ksh93 integration)

2006-08-24 Thread John Plocher
Martin Schaffstall wrote: It is interesting to observe that each time the project reaches another milestone a Sun employee steps in and demands a full change of the project. Interesting... As an observer who is keenly interested in ksh93 matters, but has not spent time working on the details

Re: [osol-discuss] Opensolaris - just a fake? (was: Re: [ksh93-integration-discuss] some questions about ksh93 integration)

2006-08-24 Thread Dennis Clarke
On 8/24/06, Dan Price [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: On Thu 24 Aug 2006 at 12:35AM, Roland Mainz wrote: I have a couple of questions regarding the shape of the project: hack slash burn snip Maybe IBM is right and Opensolaris is just a big FAKE project and contributions by external

Re: [osol-discuss] Opensolaris - just a fake? (was: Re: [ksh93-integration-discuss] some questions about ksh93 integration)

2006-08-24 Thread Joerg Schilling
Martin Schaffstall [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: It is interesting to observe that each time the project reaches another milestone a Sun employee steps in and demands a full change of the project. Very suspicious. Is Sun actually interested in a ksh93 migration or did Sun only allow the

Re: [osol-discuss] Opensolaris - just a fake? (was: Re: [ksh93-integration-discuss] some questions about ksh93 integration)

2006-08-24 Thread Rich Teer
On Thu, 24 Aug 2006, Martin Schaffstall wrote: This is not absurd. It is a observation. ... One that happens to be wrong. If you want my opinion: Sun is SABOTAGING the project Sun is not sabotaging the project. You seem to tbe confusing adhering to sound engineering principles as sabotage.

Re: [osol-discuss] Opensolaris - just a fake? (was: Re: [ksh93-integration-discuss] some questions about ksh93 integration)

2006-08-24 Thread ken mays
On 8/24/06, Dan Price [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: On Thu 24 Aug 2006 at 12:35AM, Roland Mainz wrote: I have a couple of questions regarding the shape of the project: hack slash burn snip Maybe IBM is right and Opensolaris is just a big FAKE project and contributions by external

Re: [osol-discuss] Opensolaris - just a fake? (was: Re: [ksh93-integration-discuss] some questions about ksh93 integration)

2006-08-24 Thread Alan DuBoff
On Thursday 24 August 2006 09:38 am, Martin Schaffstall wrote: This is not absurd. It is a observation. If you want my opinion: Sun is SABOTAGING the project I think there is clearly a misunderstanding between you and Sun, unfortunately. You sure seem bitter about it. -- Alan DuBoff -