Re: [talk-au] Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import?

2009-12-16 Thread John Smith
Travelling about northern NSW in the lead up to xmas I noticed this location: http://www.openstreetmap.org/browse/node/585129264 Is no longer a BP, but has Liberty signs up... BP states they update their dataset monthly but it seems they're a bit slack...

Re: [talk-au] Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import?

2009-12-16 Thread Steve Bennett
On Tue, Dec 15, 2009 at 10:57 PM, Steve Bennett stevag...@gmail.com wrote: To be a complete hypocrit, I could check it out on my way to work tomorrow. If driving, I drive straight past it, if riding, I pass within a few blocks. Then again, had a quick look with streetview, looks like BPs on

Re: [talk-au] Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import?

2009-12-16 Thread John Smith
2009/12/16 Steve Bennett stevag...@gmail.com: Yes, it's definitely been razed. The big BP sign is still there, so it's unclear whether they're just rebuilding it from below ground level or what. Ahh ok, I couldn't make out signs from NearMap, then again I wasn't looking that much after seeing

Re: [talk-au] Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import?

2009-12-15 Thread John Smith
BP have this location on their site: http://www.openstreetmap.org/browse/node/585128133 Except when you view it with NearMap the site has been leveled, not sure if BP is rebuilding it or what ___ Talk-au mailing list Talk-au@openstreetmap.org

Re: [talk-au] Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import?

2009-12-15 Thread Steve Bennett
On Tue, Dec 15, 2009 at 7:19 PM, John Smith deltafoxtrot...@gmail.com wrote: BP have this location on their site: http://www.openstreetmap.org/browse/node/585128133 Except when you view it with NearMap the site has been leveled, not sure if BP is rebuilding it or what To be a complete

Re: [talk-au] Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import?

2009-12-15 Thread John Smith
2009/12/15 Steve Bennett stevag...@gmail.com: Then again, had a quick look with streetview, looks like BPs on both sides. Both look pretty established, so I'm guessing it's demolished rather than new. The NearMap imagery is very recent, the same can't be said for sat imagery or streetview,

Re: [talk-au] Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import?

2009-12-14 Thread John Smith
Here's a current list of nodes with 'fixme' tags: http://map-data.bigtincan.com/data/BPfixmes.osm.bz2 Also some people have editted locations without removing the fixme tags... ___ Talk-au mailing list Talk-au@openstreetmap.org

Re: [talk-au] Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import?

2009-12-14 Thread John Smith
2009/12/15 John Smith deltafoxtrot...@gmail.com: Here's a current list of nodes with 'fixme' tags: http://map-data.bigtincan.com/data/BPfixmes.osm.bz2 Also some people have editted locations without removing the fixme tags... I just noticed since that contains version numbers etc, you can

Re: [talk-au] Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import?

2009-12-14 Thread John Smith
Here's an example of OSM beating even BP to the punch... This location doesn't exist in the BP dataset: http://osm.org/go/uN9xpckXA-- You can make out BP signs with NearMap and according to OSM data, it was tagged on the 3rd of November...

Re: [talk-au] Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import?

2009-12-14 Thread Liz
On Tue, 15 Dec 2009, John Smith wrote: 2009/12/15 John Smith deltafoxtrot...@gmail.com: Here's a current list of nodes with 'fixme' tags: http://map-data.bigtincan.com/data/BPfixmes.osm.bz2 Also some people have editted locations without removing the fixme tags... I just noticed

Re: [talk-au] Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import?

2009-12-13 Thread Liz
On Sun, 13 Dec 2009, John Smith wrote: H BP has 2 locations listed for the same address, one is express one isn't, and I'm not sure which is correct, maybe BP has lost more service stations? :) I joined two together in Grenfell same address same phone number same stuff for sale i think

Re: [talk-au] Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import?

2009-12-13 Thread John Smith
2009/12/13 Liz ed...@billiau.net: On Sun, 13 Dec 2009, John Smith wrote: H BP has 2 locations listed for the same address, one is express one isn't, and I'm not sure which is correct, maybe BP has lost more service stations? :) I joined two together in Grenfell same address same

Re: [talk-au] Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import?

2009-12-13 Thread John Henderson
John Smith wrote: H BP has 2 locations listed for the same address, one is express one isn't, and I'm not sure which is correct, maybe BP has lost more service stations? :) http://www.openstreetmap.org/browse/changeset/3360844 I notice that both are tagged with:

Re: [talk-au] Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import?

2009-12-13 Thread John Smith
2009/12/13 John Henderson snow...@gmx.com: John Smith wrote: H BP has 2 locations listed for the same address, one is express one isn't, and I'm not sure which is correct, maybe BP has lost more service stations? :) http://www.openstreetmap.org/browse/changeset/3360844 I notice that

Re: [talk-au] Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import?

2009-12-13 Thread Ross Scanlon
I notice that both are tagged with:        fuel:octane_91 = no implying that neither sell ordinary unleaded petrol.  That's the normal high-volume seller, or have you banned it in Qld? fuel:e10 = yes Replaces 91 octane at lots of BP servos. At least they have 95, 98 and lpg which

Re: [talk-au] Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import?

2009-12-13 Thread John Henderson
Ross Scanlon wrote: fuel:e10 = yes Replaces 91 octane at lots of BP servos. At least they have 95, 98 and lpg which suits me as the truck really does not like e10. Interesting. Personally, I use e10 in my '97 Pulsar almost always, even though Nissan say not to. I've never had a

Re: [talk-au] Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import?

2009-12-13 Thread John Smith
2009/12/14 John Henderson snow...@gmx.com: Ross Scanlon wrote: fuel:e10 = yes Replaces 91 octane at lots of BP servos. At least they have 95, 98 and lpg which suits me as the truck really does not like e10. Interesting.  Personally, I use e10 in my '97 Pulsar almost always, even though

Re: [talk-au] Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import?

2009-12-13 Thread Ross Scanlon
Interesting. Personally, I use e10 in my '97 Pulsar almost always, even though Nissan say not to. I've never had a problem with drivability or with the fuel or intake system. On the contrary, e10 is actually about 93 or 94 octane, as the ethanol raises the octane number of the 91 base

Re: [talk-au] Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import?

2009-12-13 Thread Chris Barham
On Thu, Dec 10, 2009 at 12:39 PM, John Smith deltafoxtrot...@gmail.com wrote: The 2 BP's along the Bruce Highway north of Brisbane aren't located properly either, it looks like they've simply used address to geo lookups and when the addresses are specific they co-ords go wonky, wonder if they

Re: [talk-au] Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import?

2009-12-13 Thread John Smith
2009/12/14 Chris Barham cbar...@pobox.com: I've found one that is almost 20km out - and wondered whether this is the worst one found so far?: http://www.bp.com/iframe.do?categoryId=9012436contentId=7017653 The one at Moree was plotted 20km out of Moree to the North, but the servo is on the

Re: [talk-au] Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import?

2009-12-13 Thread Steve Bennett
On Mon, Dec 14, 2009 at 12:09 PM, Chris Barham cbar...@pobox.com wrote: I drove out there to check and be certain on the weekend so have removed the FIXME tag. Wow, someone cares about their servos :) Steve ___ Talk-au mailing list

Re: [talk-au] Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import?

2009-12-13 Thread John Smith
2009/12/14 Steve Bennett stevag...@gmail.com: On Mon, Dec 14, 2009 at 12:09 PM, Chris Barham cbar...@pobox.com wrote: I drove out there to check and be certain on the weekend so have removed the FIXME tag. Wow, someone cares about their servos :) Why haven't you? :P

Re: [talk-au] Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import?

2009-12-12 Thread Brendan Morley
I'll bet internally they're associated with lots-on-plan land records... And if the public dataset is simply used address to geo lookups, then which geocoder did they use? And is BP allowed to publish the derived dataset? Brendan On Thu, 10 Dec 2009 19:43:08 +1100, Liz wrote: On Thu, 10 Dec

Re: [talk-au] Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import?

2009-12-12 Thread Elizabeth Dodd
On Sun, 13 Dec 2009, Brendan Morley wrote: I'll bet internally they're associated with lots-on-plan land records... The Beckom one was so far up the road it had moved to a rest area Others like Young, address on an intersection, were on the intersection literally And if the public dataset is

Re: [talk-au] Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import?

2009-12-12 Thread John Smith
2009/12/12 Brendan Morley morb@beagle.com.au: I'll bet internally they're associated with lots-on-plan land records... They probably don't need to know/care about the geo data. And if the public dataset is simply used address to geo lookups, then which geocoder did they use? And is BP

Re: [talk-au] Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import?

2009-12-12 Thread John Smith
2009/12/11 James Livingston doc...@mac.com: On Wednesday, December 09, 2009, at 03:25PM, Chris Barham cbar...@pobox.com wrote: BP allows free download of GPS data for their Australian service stations. Has anyone asked any of the other companies yet? If not, I'll send some emails about:

Re: [talk-au] Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import?

2009-12-12 Thread David Dean
Maybe the fuel station node labelled 'BP' just a few 10s of metres away on the link you posted? http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=-27.445482lon=153.029376zoom=18layers=B000FTF - David John Smith-131 wrote: Anyone familiar with the BP at this location? 44 Bowen Bridge Rd, Herston QLD

Re: [talk-au] Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import?

2009-12-12 Thread David Dean
Maybe the fuel station node labelled 'BP' just a few 10s of metres away on the link you posted? http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=-27.445482lon=153.029376zoom=18layers=B000FTF - David John Smith-131 wrote: Anyone familiar with the BP at this location? 44 Bowen Bridge Rd, Herston QLD

Re: [talk-au] Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import?

2009-12-12 Thread John Smith
2009/12/13 David Dean dd...@ieee.org: Maybe the fuel station node labelled 'BP' just a few 10s of metres away on the link you posted? http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=-27.445482lon=153.029376zoom=18layers=B000FTF Mmmm that was a tad obvious, dunno how I missed it

Re: [talk-au] Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import?

2009-12-11 Thread Liz
On Fri, 11 Dec 2009, Arie Paap wrote: How should duplicates which are already in OSM (but weren't close enough to be picked up when processed) be dealt with? For example BP Bellevue: http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=-31.8941lon=116.0263zoom=17layers=B000 FTF (both appear on southern side of

Re: [talk-au] Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import?

2009-12-11 Thread John Smith
2009/12/11 Arie Paap wildmy...@gmail.com: How should duplicates which are already in OSM (but weren't close enough to be picked up when processed) be dealt with? For example BP Bellevue: http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=-31.8941lon=116.0263zoom=17layers=B000FTF (both appear on southern side

Re: [talk-au] Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import?

2009-12-11 Thread John Smith
2009/12/11 James Livingston doc...@mac.com: http://apps.nowwhere.com.au/caltex/austlocator/search.aspx I wouldn't bother with nowwhere, it's a mapds website and they are most likely hosting the data on behalf of caltex, and so they probably wouldn't be able or willing to release the data.

Re: [talk-au] Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import?

2009-12-11 Thread John Smith
2009/12/11 Liz ed...@billiau.net: i then looked for one at blanchetown, and there was no new bp at blanchetown, so either its not bp any more, or because the node was close the new data has not been imported I think you found it, unless you mean there is 2 BPs at Blanchetown?

Re: [talk-au] Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import?

2009-12-11 Thread Elizabeth Dodd
On Fri, 11 Dec 2009, you wrote: 2009/12/11 Elizabeth Dodd ed...@billiau.net: On Fri, 11 Dec 2009, you wrote: i then looked for one at blanchetown, and there was no new bp at blanchetown, so either its not bp any more, or because the node was close the new data has not been imported

Re: [talk-au] Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import?

2009-12-10 Thread Emilie Laffray
2009/12/10 John Smith deltafoxtrot...@gmail.com 2009/12/10 Steve Bennett stevag...@gmail.com: [26] = ATM You could add a separate (or same?) amenity=atm (or whatever it is) point? I added tag k='amenity:atm' v='no' / tag k='amenity:eftpos' v='yes' / tag k='rent:trailers'

Re: [talk-au] Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import?

2009-12-10 Thread Steve Bennett
On Fri, Dec 11, 2009 at 4:10 AM, Emilie Laffray emilie.laff...@gmail.com wrote: Also do we need to include tags when there is nothing present. I think the basic case is that those services are not present. Including them only when they are present would make more sense in my view and would not

Re: [talk-au] Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import?

2009-12-10 Thread Arie Paap
On Thu, Dec 10, 2009 at 8:42 PM, John Smith deltafoxtrot...@gmail.com wrote: All 1,381 locations have been uploaded, there was a few more duplicates I missed before but these have been removed as well. http://www.openstreetmap.org/browse/changeset/3340910 Bound to be some duplicates that

Re: [talk-au] Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import?

2009-12-10 Thread James Livingston
On Wednesday, December 09, 2009, at 03:25PM, Chris Barham cbar...@pobox.com wrote: BP allows free download of GPS data for their Australian service stations. Has anyone asked any of the other companies yet? If not, I'll send some emails about:

Re: [talk-au] Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import?

2009-12-09 Thread Sam Couter
Ross Scanlon i...@4x4falcon.com wrote: Make sure if you are going to enter fuel information then you include all types, (lpg, 91, 95, 98 octane, diesel, etc) More: Automotive LPG is different tax-wise from barbecue LPG and therefore sold and dispensed differently, sometimes you can refill your

Re: [talk-au] Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import?

2009-12-09 Thread John Smith
2009/12/9 Sam Couter s...@couter.id.au: and usually only sold during the winter months in alpine areas. Ethanol is for drinking and swindling motorists and governments out of some cash so As if the govt doesn't get enough tax already, and they get tax on top of tax when the GST kicks in.

Re: [talk-au] Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import?

2009-12-09 Thread John Smith
2009/12/9 Liz ed...@billiau.net: On Wed, 9 Dec 2009, Sam Couter wrote: Ethanol is for drinking and swindling motorists and governments out of some cash so it should be noted for those of us who'd rather push the car than put E10 in it. I thought E10 was so I didn't have to pay a 30c per

Re: [talk-au] Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import?

2009-12-09 Thread Liz
On Wed, 9 Dec 2009, John Smith wrote: Anyway, this is getting off topic, the fields from the BP are as following, most are binary fields (Y or N), no idea what the other field is for. NAME,X,Y, LocationNo, Street, Town, State, Postcode, Phone, Unlead, PremiumUnlead, BPUltimate, E10, Diesel,

Re: [talk-au] Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import?

2009-12-09 Thread Steve Bennett
On Wed, Dec 9, 2009 at 8:52 PM, John Smith deltafoxtrot...@gmail.comwrote: NAME,X,Y, LocationNo, Street, Town, State, Postcode, Phone, Unlead, PremiumUnlead, BPUltimate, E10, Diesel, Any_Autogas, Hours_24, Trailers, LPGBottle, Toilets, CarWash, CleanGo, SuperWash, Other, Pay, EFTPOS,

Re: [talk-au] Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import?

2009-12-09 Thread John Smith
2009/12/9 Liz ed...@billiau.net: give us some practical examples and we can go and visit our local BP servos and try to work out what Other is AA Oakleigh 145.09 -37.88 5362162 - 168 Warrigal Rd Oakleigh VIC 3166 AA Reservoir145.02 -37.72 372235 - 37 Gisborne

Re: [talk-au] Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import?

2009-12-09 Thread John Smith
2009/12/9 Steve Bennett stevag...@gmail.com: Can we really maintain this? These services come and go fairly frequently. Just keep a list of nodes/ways and the location ID and it should be trivial to keep up to date. Also, if you're doing a bulk import, how do you avoid double tagging existing

Re: [talk-au] Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import?

2009-12-09 Thread James Livingston
On 09/12/2009, at 8:26 PM, Steve Bennett wrote: Can we really maintain this? These services come and go fairly frequently. Individual things like whether they have LPG filling for bbqs maybe, but servos don't move that often (usually taken over by another one). In any case, it's probably not

Re: [talk-au] Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import?

2009-12-09 Thread John Smith
2009/12/9 James Livingston doc...@mac.com: I'd suggest doing something like import if there is not an existing amenity=fuel within X distance, flag it for manual checking if there is. The only problem with that is where you get 2 or 3 service stations close/next to each other.

Re: [talk-au] Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import?

2009-12-09 Thread James Livingston
On 09/12/2009, at 8:41 PM, Steve Bennett wrote: On Wed, Dec 9, 2009 at 9:37 PM, James Livingston doc...@mac.com wrote: I'd suggest doing something like import if there is not an existing amenity=fuel within X distance, flag it for manual checking if there is. Ah, didn't know that kind of

Re: [talk-au] Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import?

2009-12-09 Thread Ross Scanlon
On Wed, 9 Dec 2009 20:14:32 +1100 Sam Couter s...@couter.id.au wrote: Ross Scanlon i...@4x4falcon.com wrote: Make sure if you are going to enter fuel information then you include all types, (lpg, 91, 95, 98 octane, diesel, etc) More: Automotive LPG is different tax-wise from barbecue LPG

Re: [talk-au] Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import?

2009-12-09 Thread Sam Couter
John Smith deltafoxtrot...@gmail.com wrote: The problem with E10 for most cars is it doesn't recognise the extra oxygen atom Australian electronic fuel injection systems have O2 sensors, this isn't a problem. The reduced energy of E10 compared to the same volume of petrol is a problem, is basic

Re: [talk-au] Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import?

2009-12-09 Thread Sam Couter
John Smith deltafoxtrot...@gmail.com wrote: As if the govt doesn't get enough tax already, and they get tax on top of tax when the GST kicks in. The government gets *less* money from E10. Fuel excise is reduced and its production is subsidised. Anyway, this is getting off topic, Yes, but a

Re: [talk-au] Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import?

2009-12-09 Thread John Smith
Ok, getting back on topic, I spent a little time this morning generating an OSM file that can be opened in JOSM. For those curious/interested: http://map-data.bigtincan.com/data/BPtest.osm.bz2 I haven't included all fields, I left out the following: [16] = Trailers [17] = LPGBottle

Re: [talk-au] Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import?

2009-12-09 Thread Steve Bennett
[26] = ATM You could add a separate (or same?) amenity=atm (or whatever it is) point? Steve ___ Talk-au mailing list Talk-au@openstreetmap.org http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-au

Re: [talk-au] Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import?

2009-12-09 Thread John Smith
2009/12/10 Steve Bennett stevag...@gmail.com:    [26] =  ATM You could add a separate (or same?) amenity=atm (or whatever it is) point? I added tag k='amenity:atm' v='no' / tag k='amenity:eftpos' v='yes' / tag k='rent:trailers' v='no' / tag k='rent:lpg_bottles' v='no' / tag

Re: [talk-au] Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import?

2009-12-09 Thread John Smith
Also I think some of the co-ords are way off, there is 2 BP locations in Carnarvon for example and when you zoom in on them there doesn't look to be a service station anywhere within the vicinity. ___ Talk-au mailing list Talk-au@openstreetmap.org

Re: [talk-au] Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import?

2009-12-09 Thread Steve Bennett
On Thu, Dec 10, 2009 at 1:39 PM, John Smith deltafoxtrot...@gmail.comwrote: The 2 BP's along the Bruce Highway north of Brisbane aren't located properly either, it looks like they've simply used address to geo lookups and when the addresses are specific they co-ords go wonky, wonder if they

[talk-au] Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import?

2009-12-08 Thread Chris Barham
ref: Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import? BP allows free download of GPS data for their Australian service stations. They also offer another CSV dataset download with servo phone numbers, names and address. Could these two be useful to OpenStreetMap as a datasource?

Re: [talk-au] Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import?

2009-12-08 Thread John Smith
2009/12/9 Chris Barham cbar...@pobox.com: ref: Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import? BP allows free download of GPS data for their Australian service stations.  They also offer another CSV dataset download with servo phone numbers, names and address.  Could these two

Re: [talk-au] Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import?

2009-12-08 Thread John Smith
I just opened the all states csv files and pasted them into a spread sheet and ended up with 1,387 rows, there was 2 duplicate rows I removed and 1 row without co-ords. ___ Talk-au mailing list Talk-au@openstreetmap.org

Re: [talk-au] Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import?

2009-12-08 Thread Ross Scanlon
On Wed, 9 Dec 2009 14:37:59 +1000 John Smith deltafoxtrot...@gmail.com wrote: 2009/12/9 Chris Barham cbar...@pobox.com: ref: Australia BP service station dataset - suitable for bulk import? BP allows free download of GPS data for their Australian service stations.  They also offer another