Re: [Vo]: Re: Loop closed? (was Re: High efficiency electrolysis)

2007-03-06 Thread Stephen A. Lawrence
Michel Jullian wrote: OK thanks Jones, Ron et al. I could have gone on and on like this, describing encouraging experimental results maybe, raising millions perhaps, but I'll put an end to my little joke, which was in reality a challenge to the group's thermodynamics skills, nothing against

[Vo]: Re: Loop closed? (was Re: High efficiency electrolysis)

2007-03-06 Thread Jones Beene
Stephen If there are violations of the second law waiting to be employed, I think we can be reasonably sure they won't use either heat pumps or heat engines as their prime movers. Not to put words in anyone's mouth, but I think what you meant to say was: If there are violations of the

Re: [Vo]: Re: Loop closed? (was Re: High efficiency electrolysis)

2007-03-06 Thread Stephen A. Lawrence
Jones Beene wrote: Stephen If there are violations of the second law waiting to be employed, I think we can be reasonably sure they won't use either heat pumps or heat engines as their prime movers. Not to put words in anyone's mouth, but I think what you meant to say was: If there are

[Vo]: Re: Loop closed? (was Re: High efficiency electrolysis)

2007-03-06 Thread Michel Jullian
Oh I forgot again, could a Jones readable Vo reply to this so he gets it? Thanks. Michel - Original Message - From: Michel Jullian [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: vortex-l@eskimo.com Sent: Tuesday, March 06, 2007 12:52 AM Subject: [Vo]: Re: Loop closed? (was Re: High efficiency electrolysis

[Vo]: Re: Loop closed? (was Re: High efficiency electrolysis)

2007-03-05 Thread Michel Jullian
[EMAIL PROTECTED] To: vortex-l@eskimo.com Sent: Sunday, March 04, 2007 5:36 PM Subject: Re: [Vo]: Re: Loop closed? (was Re: High efficiency electrolysis) What happens when you begin to use the hot water? Harry Stiffler Scientific wrote: ... Enough of that, I hope some one will comment

[Vo]: Re: Loop closed? (was Re: High efficiency electrolysis)

2007-03-05 Thread Jones Beene
Michel Jullian wrote, Sterling draws 1000W heat from hot reservoir (not necessarily water BTW) and outputs 150W mechanical. Heat pump draws 150W*9=1350W from ambient air and outputs them to the hot tank. Net power into the hot tank: 350W The figure of COP=9 may have occurred in print, or in

RE: [Vo]: Re: Loop closed? (was Re: High efficiency electrolysis)

2007-03-05 Thread Stiffler Scientific
-Qc/Qh ) would apply. -Original Message- From: Jones Beene [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Monday, March 05, 2007 9:31 AM To: vortex Subject: [Vo]: Re: Loop closed? (was Re: High efficiency electrolysis) Michel Jullian wrote, Sterling draws 1000W heat from hot reservoir

Re: [Vo]: Re: Loop closed? (was Re: High efficiency electrolysis)

2007-03-05 Thread Jones Beene
Ron, For example the Jandy Model AE 2500 claims COP 5.4, while the Ice Breaker Model H100R is rated at 5.6 and its big brother at 6.1, or http://www.sortprice.com/search-CQ-Pool_and_Spa-Heat_Pump which all have claims of COP's that are higher. Wow, I had no idea that they were getting that

Re: [Vo]: Re: Loop closed? (was Re: High efficiency electrolysis)

2007-03-05 Thread Michel Jullian
Message - From: Jones Beene [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: vortex-l@eskimo.com Sent: Monday, March 05, 2007 6:02 PM Subject: Re: [Vo]: Re: Loop closed? (was Re: High efficiency electrolysis) Ron, For example the Jandy Model AE 2500 claims COP 5.4, while the Ice Breaker Model H100R is rated at 5.6

RE: [Vo]: Re: Loop closed? (was Re: High efficiency electrolysis)

2007-03-05 Thread Stiffler Scientific
: Re: [Vo]: Re: Loop closed? (was Re: High efficiency electrolysis) OK thanks Jones, Ron et al. I could have gone on and on like this, describing encouraging experimental results maybe, raising millions perhaps, but I'll put an end to my little joke, which was in reality a challenge to the group's

Re: [Vo]: Re: Loop closed? (was Re: High efficiency electrolysis)

2007-03-05 Thread Harry Veeder
Michel Jullian wrote: OK thanks Jones, Ron et al. I could have gone on and on like this, describing encouraging experimental results maybe, raising millions perhaps, but I'll put an end to my little joke, which was in reality a challenge to the group's thermodynamics skills, nothing against

[Vo]: Re: Loop closed? (was Re: High efficiency electrolysis)

2007-03-05 Thread Jones Beene
Michel Jullian wrote: My scheme simply can NOT work as I realized before I even posted it, because the absolute max efficiency of a heat pump, which depends only on the absolute temperatures of the hot and cold sources, is exactly equal to one over the absolute max efficiency of a heat engine

RE: [Vo]: Re: Loop closed? (was Re: High efficiency electrolysis)

2007-03-05 Thread Stiffler Scientific
Jones; Why play with him, he is only learning to spread his wings? -Original Message- From: Jones Beene [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Monday, March 05, 2007 2:08 PM To: vortex-l@eskimo.com Subject: [Vo]: Re: Loop closed? (was Re: High efficiency electrolysis) Michel Jullian wrote

[Vo]: Re: Loop closed? (was Re: High efficiency electrolysis)

2007-03-05 Thread Michel Jullian
all? Michel - Original Message - From: Jones Beene [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: vortex-l@eskimo.com Sent: Monday, March 05, 2007 9:07 PM Subject: [Vo]: Re: Loop closed? (was Re: High efficiency electrolysis) Michel Jullian wrote: My scheme simply can NOT work as I realized before I even

RE: [Vo]: Re: Loop closed? (was Re: High efficiency electrolysis)

2007-03-04 Thread Stiffler Scientific
Jullian [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Saturday, March 03, 2007 8:15 PM To: vortex-l@eskimo.com Subject: [Vo]: Re: Loop closed? (was Re: High efficiency electrolysis) OK, if the MIBs didn't intercept my posts which they probably didn't (no one has knocked at my door yet), it must be that my

Re: [Vo]: Re: Loop closed? (was Re: High efficiency electrolysis)

2007-03-04 Thread Harry Veeder
(most of it) a m2 of blackened copper collector can get you some real hot water. -Original Message- From: Michel Jullian [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Saturday, March 03, 2007 8:15 PM To: vortex-l@eskimo.com Subject: [Vo]: Re: Loop closed? (was Re: High efficiency electrolysis

Re: [Vo]: Re: Loop closed? (was Re: High efficiency electrolysis)

2007-03-04 Thread Michel Jullian
this post so he gets it, thanks) Michel - Original Message - From: Harry Veeder [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: vortex-l@eskimo.com Sent: Sunday, March 04, 2007 5:36 PM Subject: Re: [Vo]: Re: Loop closed? (was Re: High efficiency electrolysis) What happens when you begin to use the hot water

RE: [Vo]: Re: Loop closed? (was Re: High efficiency electrolysis)

2007-03-04 Thread StifflerScientific
PROTECTED] Sent: Sunday, March 04, 2007 4:48 PM To: vortex-l@eskimo.com Subject: Re: [Vo]: Re: Loop closed? (was Re: High efficiency electrolysis) When you begin to use the heat from the hot reservoir (launch the Sterling) it would tend to cool down from the thermal watts you draw from

Re: [Vo]: Re: Loop closed? (was Re: High efficiency electrolysis)

2007-03-04 Thread Harry Veeder
: Sunday, March 04, 2007 5:36 PM Subject: Re: [Vo]: Re: Loop closed? (was Re: High efficiency electrolysis) What happens when you begin to use the hot water? Harry Stiffler Scientific wrote: ... Enough of that, I hope some one will comment on your idea as I have seen Heat Pumps easily

[Vo]: Re: Loop closed? (was Re: High efficiency electrolysis)

2007-03-03 Thread Michel Jullian
? ;-) -- Michel - Original Message - From: Michel Jullian [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: vortex-l@eskimo.com Sent: Sunday, March 04, 2007 1:30 AM Subject: [Vo]: Re: Re: Loop closed? (was Re: [Vo]: High efficiency electrolysis) Oh I remember now, Jones doesn't get my posts for some reason. But surely