Frank, Let me be quite clear here.
The reason I produce 'CS' that has a high ionic content is because I believe that to be the most effective in health outcomes. I can not think of any references that say otherwise, but am open to re-education. I do not claim that ionic solutions are colloids, and state that my product has a high ionic content on the label and name my product 'Silver Solution'. I do however, also include on the label the words 'colloidal silver' so that the general public know what the product is intended for. It is unfortunate that from an early stage the electro-generated liquid known as colloidal silver was mislabelled, but there it is... what everybody refers to as colloidal silver is in fact a mixture of colloid and ions, with higher percentage of the later than the former. But as it is the contents of the bottle that does the good work, I would rather the contents be mis-named than change the contents to fit the label. The fact that silver complexes with chloride is neither here nor there, if the silver still makes it into the blood stream and is able to react with the pathogens it encounters. If silver forms silver chloride, why should that be the end of the story? Chemical and biological reactions don't come to a halt because of this. The weight of evidence suggests that ionic silver is an effective health remedy, and proposing a theory why it shouldn't be does not change that fact. I am not tied to a particular camp for any reason other than I have not seen any evidence that compels me to change my views. I am more than happy to review such evidence, and upon being convinced that it is sound I will then alter my product to reflect this, so that I might present my customers with the best possible product. Ivan. > -----Original Message----- > From: Frank Key [mailto:[email protected]] > Sent: Friday, 3 August 2001 00:12 > To: *Silver-List* > Subject: Re: CS>Where to find 50 ppm...... > > > Ivan wrote: > > > > I think most of us have reached the conclusion that colloidal > > > silver is more effective than ionic silver for killing pathogens. > > > > I think not Marshall. Surely most think that ionic silver is > more effective > > in killing pathogens, or at least don't know which is more effective. > > > > Just who is the us you refer to... the same 'many' that Frank > referred to a > > while ago? > > > > Ivan. > > It would seem that those producing silver solutions (all ionic > silver) are the ones most inclined to: > > 1. claim ionic silver is more effective in killing pathogens. > 2. claim silver solutions are really colloids > 3. ignore that chloride combines with silver ions to form silver chloride. > > Maybe what is needed is a list devoted to silver solutions and > producers thereof. > > frank key -- The silver-list is a moderated forum for discussion of colloidal silver. To join or quit silver-list or silver-digest send an e-mail message to: [email protected] -or- [email protected] with the word subscribe or unsubscribe in the SUBJECT line. To post, address your message to: [email protected] Silver-list archive: http://escribe.com/health/thesilverlist/index.html List maintainer: Mike Devour <[email protected]>
