On 13/02/2012 11:47, Emmanuel Lécharny wrote: > Le 2/13/12 11:40 AM, Francesco Chicchiriccò a écrit : >> On 13/02/2012 11:34, Emmanuel Lécharny wrote: >>> Le 2/13/12 10:15 AM, Francesco Chicchiriccò a écrit : >>>> Ok, so here's the proposed plan: >>>> >>>> Today: I'll send an e-mail to [email protected] and >>>> [email protected] inviting people to subscribe to syncope >>>> incubator mailing lists, warning that in one week time these two >>>> Google >>>> groups will be put in archive mode; >>>> >>>> Next Mon 20th: I'll put the two Google groups in archive mode. >>>> >>>> Next Mon 20th: I'll change the address at the two Nabble forum >>>> archives. >>> Keep in mind that we don't have fora at The ASF. We only have a >>> mailing list, which may not be the best thing for users. For >>> developpers, a forum is not teh right place to discuss about the >>> project, that's for sur, but for user, it would be a good idea to >>> discuss if you guys want you keep them. >>> >>> Otherwise, I'm fine with the proposal. >> I proposed Nabble because it could act as an archive (very well indexed >> by Google, indeed) of all discussions about Syncope, either for dev and >> users: since I can easily change the ML address, Nabble can become the >> place where you can find what discussed so far - as Google groups >> archive, and what we'll discuss from now onwards - as Apache modbox or >> Markmail. >> >> Anyway, Nabble can be configured to allow posting only from people >> subscribed to the correspondent Apache ML: I guess this should be the >> way how other Apache projects - like as OpenJPA, for example - manage >> things. >> >> Does it look better? > > What is important is that discussions about the development happen on > the ASF mailing lists. That it is duplicated on any other archives is > a no brainer. Sooner or later, people will subscribe on The ASF > mailing list, and nabble will just become history. If I can't get all > the mails when checking the syncope-dev ML, because some other > discussions happened only on nabble, then this is clearly a no go.
Ok, I understand the principle here: so, both Nabble forums will be used as: * archive for any mail sent to syncope-dev and syncope-user ASF MLs * e-mail form submission to syncope-dev and syncope-user ASF MLs, and this will be allowed only for people subscribed to MLs I guess this should comply with rules: right? Thanks. -- Francesco Chicchiriccò Apache Cocoon PMC and Apache Syncope PPMC Member http://people.apache.org/~ilgrosso/
