Às 10:15 de 14/04/2020, Paul Allen escreveu:
On Tue, 14 Apr 2020 at 04:33, António Madeira via Tagging
<[email protected] <mailto:[email protected]>> wrote:

    - is ref:xxx=* a good solution to add the official reference
    code/number?


No.  But that's what we have.  With hindsight we'd have done it
differently.  But
it's now been used so often it would be very difficult to fix all the
existing uses.

More importantly, heritage/historic tagging was started by the
Historic Place
project and they're the only ones (that I know of) that make use of
those tags.
They're the ones you'd have to convince to alter their code to handle your
proposed change.

You mean this?
https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Open_Historical_Map


    - we've adopted the tag protection_title=* to define the
    protection category of the heritage, although the German wiki
    clearly states this is used for natural areas only. Would it be
    better to create another tag or is OK to adapt this one, since
    this is also a protected feature?

It's a protected feature but not a protected natural area.  The wiki page
for it says it requires boundary=national_park or
boundary=protected_area so
it shouldn't be used this way.  That said, other people have used it
that way.
Would xxx:criteria fit your usage?

The "problem" with criteria is that it seems to be used with numbers or
abbreviations, like a list that corresponds to some longer definitions.
For example: we could create a criteria list with 1, 2, 3, 4 which would
correspond to the 4 levels of heritage existing in Portugal, but how
would data consumers know what those numbers mean? Or if you use
abbreviations, like MN, IIP, etc. we would have the same problem.
The protection_title=* seemed to solve that, but it's not 100% accurate.
I don't want to use it if it's not correct, so maybe we could create
something like heritage:designation=* which would go in line with the
heritage scheme.



_______________________________________________
Tagging mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging

Reply via email to