I noticed my misinterpretation myself indeed - after the facts. My bad. I wasn't claiming that oneway=yes doesn't apply to cyclists, I was saying that the 'wegcode' actually allows bicycles to use the cycleway in the opposite direction. <- and that was totally wrong after deeper researching.
So I was trying to point out the difference between the way OSM goes about this and the real life situation. I came to the following conclusion: By default, cycleways as tagged in OSM do allow cycletraffic both ways, since they do not implicitly put oneway=yes on it. But that’s not what the .be law says... What you're claiming is correct, I was trying to point out that the keys put on the junction=roundabout do not have influence when the cycleway was drawn separately which is true in the case of this separation. Now, I only checked the situation after Jakka worked on it but didn't realise this before sending my replies, so I failed to see the initial situation where the routing problem claims applied upon. The conclusion I'm drawing from all this is that in Belgium, most seperate cycleways should probably be tagged oneway=yes. It's got everything to do with the placement of the D7/D9 signs being to the right or to the left of the sign. And then there are some exceptions as well to this rule depending on the sitation. So I checked with google streetview, and I believe that the oneway tags are now all correct on the cycleways that are located around the roundabout. And I learned something today, you can't use the cycleway in both directions by default! I always figured you could. Glenn On 11-11-14 16:46, Ben Laenen wrote: > On Tuesday 11 November 2014 14:51:07 Glenn Plas wrote: >> Sorry but oneway=yes just means you can only drive in the direction of >> the way. It has nothing to do with going opposite. > > Yeah, sorry, used a wrong word there after I rewrote that sentence. Should > have been: > > "No, it's the opposite: oneway=yes prohibits all drivers to go in the opposite > direction, whether you're driving a car, a bicycle, a horse or herding a > cow or whatever your mode of transport (except on foot, you're not a > driver then)." > > since you were claiming oneway=yes doesn't apply to cyclists. > > Ben > > > _______________________________________________ > Talk-be mailing list > Talk-be@openstreetmap.org > https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-be > -- "Everything is going to be 200 OK." _______________________________________________ Talk-be mailing list Talk-be@openstreetmap.org https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-be
