> De : Frederik Ramm <frede...@remote.org>
> See, the same applies to DWG as well. It is utterly trivial for someone to create a separate account for Cadastre work - a matter of five minutes, or less. So we wonder: > Why is this such a big deal for people? I just try to do it. The problem is that I cannot use the same email address than for my main OSM account. Honestly I think this is really painfull to create a dedicated mail account just for that and that I will also have to manage. If a can create a dedicated account with the same mail address it would be fine for me. > A Cadastre import is not something you do on a whim - it is something that you plan ahead, you prepare the files, do a lot of work (hopefully), so switching to your separate account for uploading a batch of Cadastre import is not a big deal either. > Now if someone is unwilling to do even this little bit of work in order to make it easier for the rest of the community - and that includes DWG - do clearly separate Cadastre from non-Cadastre work - what does that tell us about the diligence of that person otherwise? But this is not a problem that a lot of information comes from Bing aerial and our local knowledge when we perform cadastre import ? > A Cadastre import is something that should only be done by people who take this seriously, who are diligent, who know the rules and follow them - in tagging as well as elsewhere. For sure, that's why there will certainly be a restricted access to the raw data for people that perform bulk import. > For someone who possesses all these skills, creating an extra import account > should be easy. If it doesn`t imply to create a new email account I agree with you > There has been some discussion around the question of whether Cadastre work counts as an import or not. I am willing to accept that someone who uploads 100 houses is not importing something; it is conceivable that he has actually looked at every single one of these houses. But someone who uploads 10000 houses in one day is clearly making an import; there's no way these houses have really been individually (!) reviewed. I agree with you Best regards Julien
_______________________________________________ Talk-fr mailing list Talk-fr@openstreetmap.org http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-fr
