Je comprends parfaitement les désirs de transparence sur les affaires en cours, mais croyez-vous vraiment utile d'envoyer ici la copie de tous les messages en anglais qui passent concernant la France !???
J'avais essayé de dire que la transparence avait ses limites, que si on les dépassait ça détruisait la transparence, je le re-dis ! Les purs chevaliers de l'open source convivial peuvent-ils se créer un salon dans lequel ils recopieront tous les messages qui les tienne au courant de ce qui se passe dans le monde entier par transparence !? MERCI ! 2012/10/18 THEVENON Julien <julien_theve...@yahoo.fr> > *> De :* Frederik Ramm <frede...@remote.org> > > *> *See, the same applies to DWG as well. It is utterly trivial for > someone to create a separate account for Cadastre work - a matter of five > minutes, or less. So we wonder: > > Why is this such a big deal for people? > > I just try to do it. The problem is that I cannot use the same email > address than for my main OSM account. > Honestly I think this is really painfull to create a dedicated mail > account just for that and that I will also have to manage. > If a can create a dedicated account with the same mail address it would be > fine for me. > > *> *A Cadastre import is not something you do on a whim - it is something > that you plan ahead, you prepare the files, do a lot of work (hopefully), > so switching to your separate account for uploading a batch of Cadastre > import is not a big deal either. > *> *Now if someone is unwilling to do even this little bit of work in > order to make it easier for the rest of the community - and that includes > DWG - do clearly separate Cadastre from non-Cadastre work - what does that > tell us about the diligence of that person otherwise? > > But this is not a problem that a lot of information comes from Bing aerial > and our local knowledge when we perform cadastre import ? > > > *> *A Cadastre import is something that should only be done by people who > take this seriously, who are diligent, who know the rules and follow them - > in tagging as well as elsewhere. > > For sure, that's why there will certainly be a restricted access to the > raw data for people that perform bulk import. > > *> *For someone who possesses all these skills, creating an extra import > account should be easy. > > If it doesn`t imply to create a new email account I agree with you > > *> *There has been some discussion around the question of whether > Cadastre work counts as an import or not. I am willing to accept that > someone who uploads 100 houses is not importing something; it is > conceivable that he has actually looked at every single one of these > houses. But someone who uploads 10000 houses in one day is clearly making > an import; there's no way these houses have really been individually (!) > reviewed. > > I agree with you > > Best regards > Julien > > > _______________________________________________ > Talk-fr mailing list > Talk-fr@openstreetmap.org > http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-fr > >
_______________________________________________ Talk-fr mailing list Talk-fr@openstreetmap.org http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-fr
