Hi ael, Unfortunately the presence of an OSM object in the comparison tool does not necessarily mean it will be in the FHRS database. B&Bs are a good example as I don’t think they’re all registered with FHRS. Some are though, hence my choice to include tourism=guest_houses in the comparison tool.
The tool imports all OSM data for GB with an fhrs:id tag set and all OSM data for GB with certain tags (see <https://github.com/gregrs-uk/python-fhrs-osm/blob/master/filter-osm.sh#L5-L13> for the current list). My choice of tags was based on an analysis of OSM objects with an fhrs:id set. You can see PDFs of the graphs here <https://github.com/gregrs-uk/python-fhrs-osm/commit/e9fb7e5bb41796e9e463ec8f49497c33c2eb91df#commitcomment-19305241> and I’m happy to make changes if this would be useful. As there’s no guarantee that all of the OSM objects in the comparison tool will have an FHRS record, the statistics only give a % of FHRS establishments matched and a % of the OSM objects with relevant tags which have an addr:postcode. The osm-unmatched-* GPX files include a centroid for each OSM node/way that has one or more of the relevant tags (see link above) but doesn’t yet have an fhrs:id set in OSM. Hopefully you shouldn’t need to search the FHRS site too much as the comparison tool's overview map for each district displays all the FHRS establishments. (Unmatched ones are shown as blue dots, usually reverse geocoded by postcode so not always very accurately positioned!) Hope that helps. Thanks, Greg P.S. Unfortunately the tool isn’t accessible right now as the dev server is down (see <http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Platform_Status>). > On 6 Nov 2016, at 16:58, ael <law_ence....@ntlworld.com> wrote: > > I not at all sure that this is related but I have found that I can't > match certain establishments with the fhrs search tool or find them in > their xml file, yet your comparison tools is finding them. > > An example is > > <wpt lat="50.4584278" lon="-4.4657903"> > <name>Hyvue House</name> > </wpt> > > which is a Bed & breafast in Liskeard Cornwall. The address is Coldstyle > Road, but searching the fhrs data for the name with or without the > street name returns no results. Perhaps I misunderstand > osm-unmatched-no-postcode-379.gpx ? Am I wrong in assuming this only > includes places with an FHRS rating? > > ael _______________________________________________ Talk-GB mailing list Talk-GB@openstreetmap.org https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-gb
