Edmund Storms wrote:
> The Mills situation is a bit more complex than you note, Stephen. 
> Hydrinos are not the only result of the Mills theory. He has created a
> new model for atomic interaction and a new model for calculating many
> fundamental constants including the ionization energy of most elements.
> His model is a major challenge to the view provided by QM.  Even if
> hydrinos are not created, something else provides the energy he detects
> in various ways.

Indeed, what you say is correct.  None the less, his theory predicts the
formation of hydrinos.  Conventional QM predicts that they will not
form.  Hence, the creation of hydrinos would seem to be the most obvious
make-or-break issue between the theories.

If they exist, conventional QM is largely wrong (even within its domain
of applicability), Mills' theory, which predicted their formation (as
well as a number of other things), is apparently correct within its
currently tested domain of applicability, and Mills is in line for a
Nobel and his theory will be taught to junior-level physics majors for
at least the next few decades.

If hydrinos don't exist, then Mills' theory is wrong, whether or not it
predicts other things:  one incorrect prediction is all it takes to show
a valid theory is false, and whether it's eventually proved right or
wrong, CQM is certainly a "valid theory".

Ptolemaic cosmology predicted many things correctly, after all.  But the
moons of Jupiter shot it down none the less.



>  His model is the only rational explanation that has
> been offered so far.  As is usual, rejection by conventional science is
> based largely on ignorance of what is being rejected.
> 
> Ed
> 
> 
> 
> On Jul 21, 2009, at 12:07 PM, Stephen A. Lawrence wrote:

>>
>> Either Mills hits a home run, and shakes the foundations of physics (and
>> maybe gets a Nobel, forget a few scraggly patents), or he strikes out
>> and is not even a footnote in the history of science.  There isn't any
>> middle ground, as far as I can see.  Because either hydrinos are for
>> real and totally revolutionary, and when the evidence is all in Mills
>> will be recognized as a giant on the landscape of physics, or they are
>> not real, and in the latter case there is nothing of value in Mills'
>> work; hydrinos can't be "a little bit real".
>>
>>

Reply via email to