WG,
we have reviewed the different comments posted on the list in response
to our initial proposal.
After thinking further about that, we'd like to propose the following as
a way forward:
At the same time we issue a Working Group Last Call we would ask for
knowledge of existing implementations, and the more details provided at
that time, the better.
In the situation where an implementation would exist we would proceed
with submission to IESG.
In the opposite situation (no implementation exists), we would
systematically ask the WG for reasoned opinions regarding whether we
should nevertheless proceed with submission to IESG.
We will gauge consensus on that aspect. In case consensus is in favour
of proceeding with submission to IESG we will do so. In the opposite
case, we will put the document in a "Waiting for implementation" state
until information on an existing implementation is brought to our
knowledge or of the WG.
Please share your views on that.
Thank you
M&T
Le 24/11/2015 10:03, Thomas Morin a écrit :
Hello everyone,
Following the positive feedback received during BESS meeting in Yokohama
about introducing a one-implementation requirement in BESS, we propose
to do the following for future WG last calls:
As a prerequisite before doing a working group last call on a document,
the chairs will ask the working group for known implementations of the
specifications; a relatively detailed level of information will be
required (e.g. "release x.y of solution z shipping date d", "all
features implemented", "partial implementation only", etc.) and everyone
will be invited to reply (not only co-authors of the specifications);
the chairs will then do the working group last call if satisfying
information was provided on at least one implementation.
We are open for comments on this proposal until December 7th.
Martin & Thomas
_______________________________________________
BESS mailing list
BESS@ietf.org
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/bess
_______________________________________________
BESS mailing list
BESS@ietf.org
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/bess
