On 07/12/16 12:44, Brian Smith wrote: > Notice in the BRs that the KeyUsage extension (not to be confused with the > ExtendedKeyUsage extension we're talking about here) is optional. Why is it > OK to be optional? Because the default implementation allows all usages, > including in particular the usages that browsers need.
The fact that some defaults are suitable doesn't mean that all defaults are suitable. You are assuming what you seek to prove. > My proposal requires as close to zero effort as any proposal to change the > BRs. Changing the BRs in this way would (arguably, as the scope of the BRs is a matter of ongoing debate, something we hope this line of work will eventually clarify) bring a whole load of certs which are not currently issued under the BRs and which aren't supposed to be under the BRs, under the BRs. This is really quite obviously a bad idea. Gerv _______________________________________________ dev-security-policy mailing list [email protected] https://lists.mozilla.org/listinfo/dev-security-policy

