Hi All, Sorry to jump in after an already long discussion since we are getting close to a conclusion, so I just don’t want my intervention to cause more fuzz than good. I am in accordance with most of what was said so far, but “Default” looks to me a less valuable naming than “Standard”, it is not a strong opinion, so I give my +1 to “Standard” and +0 to “Default”. I will use “Standard" in the following, just to be clearer, but you can substitute it with “Default” if you wish (you might notice further subtle differences, or not). So, what I am not sure about now is why all proposals end with “XWiki flavor” (and this is not really about the American spelling of flavour ! :D). All flavours we gonna have surely will be XWiki ones, won’t it ? So if we start with the “Standard XWiki Flavor”, I am afraid we are going to lead a movement where everyone will name their flavour with that same suffix. Is that our intention ? “XWiki Standard Flavor” would already carry a different meaning, since it would say more “Standard flavour made by the XWiki team”. However, if our intent was more to say this is a generic wiki flavour, using “Standard Wiki Flavor” looks more in line with our intended meaning. And if our meaning is more that this is just a generic flavour, ending with “Standard Flavor” is probably simpler, clearer and better. WDYT ? -- Denis Gervalle SOFTEC sa - CEO On Fri, Jun 9, 2017 at 16:48, Thomas Mortagne <[email protected]> wrote: So here is the current situation
= Proposition which don't annoy people enough to get a veto * "Default XWiki Flavor" (+3) * "Standard XWiki Flavor" (+2) = Someone gave a veto on those * "Base XWiki Flavor" * "Classic XWiki Flavor" (good success for this one until it hits Edy and Vincent) * "Raw XWiki Flavor" * "Starter XWiki Flavor" * "XWiki Flavor” * "Generic XWiki Flavor" Anyone want to change his votes ? I don't really have a preference between "Default" and "Standard". On Fri, Jun 9, 2017 at 4:18 PM, Vincent Massol <[email protected]> wrote: > So I’ve read this thread and here’s my POV: > > * "Base XWiki Flavor” -1 (same reason as Thomas) > * “Classic XWiki Flavor” -1 (same reason as Edy, it means there’s a non > classic and *better* one and we don’t have one so it doesn’t make sense) > * “Raw XWiki Flavor” -1 (not enough meaning IMO and a bit deprecatory) > * “Starter XWiki Flavor” -1 (would mean there’s another flavor which isn’t > the case) > * "Default XWiki Flavor” +1 > * "Generic XWiki Flavor” +1 > * “Standard XWiki Flavor” +1 (makes the most sense IMO) > * "XWiki Flavor”. Here it’s hard to understand that “XWiki” actually means > “developed by the XWiki project” and it would work only if other flavors > don’t have “XWiki” in the name. This is why I’m -1 ATM for it. IMO it’s not > easy enough to differentiate and understand what it means compared to other > listed flavors such “Procedure Flavor” from XWiki SAS or “Demo Flavor” from > contrib. > > Thanks > -Vincent > >> On 24 May 2017, at 11:51, Thomas Mortagne <[email protected]> wrote: >> >> Hi devs, >> >> I'm getting closer to finish with the hard work around new platform >> flavor which is going to replace XE. >> >> Need to decide what user will see in the Flavor picker when installed XWiki >> now. >> >> As a reminder we decided that this would be a generic flavor, not tied >> to any specific use case (so forget about "Knwonledge Base Flavor" >> :)). >> >> Here is a few ideas gathered in previous mails: >> * "XWiki Flavor" >> * "Default XWiki Flavor" >> * "Generic XWiki Flavor" >> * "Base XWiki Flavor" >> >> "Generic" is probably a way too technical term. >> >> "Base" would be misleading IMO since it's not really a base flavor. >> Its primary goal is not to be used as a dependency (of course it's >> fine to have it as dependency if you just want to add pre installed >> extensions to the default flavor). It's a -1 for me. >> >> Frankly I would simply go for "XWiki Flavor". I know, it's not going >> to be the only flavor for XWiki but it's obvious when you actually see >> severals of those in the picker anyway and I find it nicer than >> "Default XWiki Flavor" which basically means the same thing since the >> XWiki core project does not plan to provide any other flavor. I'm also >> fine with "Default XWiki Favor" if others think it's a better name. >> >> WDYT ? >> >> -- >> Thomas Mortagne > -- Thomas Mortagne
