Only as another opinion http://martinfowler.com/bliki/FeatureBranch.html
On Fri, Nov 5, 2010 at 2:03 PM, Fabio Maulo <[email protected]> wrote: > I did ;) > I have a full history updated, the fork in bitbukect came from my files > uploaded in sky-drive. > We are ready to make the move at any moment but that is not the real > matter... as you said the matter is what will happen after make the move and > I'm scared by big pull requests instead little patches, pull requests > without follow some rules (related issue ticket, and not only superficial > tests). > I'm scared about the management and the future quality... > The core is not a compendium of "plug-ins" and even if we have already 2700 > tests (utest and mostly integration tests) we know that we have a lot of > situations without a test. A very little change may end in a disaster and I > don't like to run behind disasters... (don't ask me an example because I > have more than one and I would avoid the relation between "disaster" and > person). There are time where I made a code review without apply the > patch... > > I have already some OSS projects under Mercurial but they are not > NHibernate. > NHibernate is neither a pleasure nor a way of being known in .NET's > ecosystem; > NHibernate is a very BIG responsibility and it was and it is a very > troublesome PITA (I felt anchored to NH many many times). > > btw I'm pretty sure we will move to a DVCS soon... > because I don't like dictatorial environments (I don't like a personal fork > as the main line) we can interpreter the "move" as: the anarchy is closer. > > bah?!?!? perhaps today is a special day.... definitively I have to take a > walk with my personal and best advisor (my shnauzer Fiamma). > > > On Fri, Nov 5, 2010 at 1:13 PM, Frans Bouma <[email protected]> wrote: > >> On Nov 5, 11:29 am, Ken Egozi <[email protected]> wrote: >> > @Frans - what the hell is wrong with you? did I offend you in any way? I >> am >> > sorry if I did, that was not my intention, even though you probably >> deserve >> > this. >> >> I was, and still am just so f*cking tired about the bickering towards >> me about svn. The constant whining about why svn is not great etc. and >> I apparently didn't have a clue. That was totally NOT the point I was >> trying to make, and I am explaining that for a dozen posts already. My >> point was about code reviews. I simply tried to help Torkel, which was >> a reason for you to again show me how wrong I am about svn. So 1) I >> tried to help someone, I invested time in that, why is it a reason for >> you to reply to that the way you did? and 2) no, I am not here to >> defend SVN, like I said: I don't give a f*ck what you think about svn, >> I was trying to make a point about _code reviews_. >> >> It's all just insanely annoying. Here I am, trying to participate in a >> serious discussion, using serious arguments, and it didn't go that >> route, instead, it seems even absurd how I can use svn in normal daily >> use. >> >> I never had any slowdowns on svn update, but perhaps it's because we >> use a lot of different repositories. I.e. it's not 1 repository and >> one .sln file, but at least 8. Like I said, svn supports folder based >> checkouts, use them. It's the same with 'oh my vs.net is so slow >> because the 40+project solution loads so slow'. No, this isn't a >> remark to defend SVN, but to help out. >> >> Anyway, like I said, enough is enough, I don't need constant >> bickering, my time is too valuable for me. On github AND bitbucket, >> the NH source code is forked, the one on bitbucket seems to be >> actively kept up to date even. I think you all should simply bite the >> bullet and take a decision and act accordingly. If all of you want to >> move, move. YES that takes tremendous effort in stuff around the >> codebase, but after that you get what you want. >> >> Just crying in this thread how great <insert scm of choice> is, is >> easy. You all seem to think that by claiming some tool as the best, >> everything else simply falls into place. But someone has to make the >> move, people. Not just all look at Fabio and wait what he decides, as >> I can understand he's reluctant to make this move: no-one seems to be >> willing to offer help in making this move so he'll have to do a lot of >> work himself. >> >> You call yourself a team? Then act like one! Offer help for the move, >> if you want it so badly. Make a task list of what's to be done and >> assign yourself to some tasks, ask others to step in as well and make >> this happen. _IF_ you want it so badly because the world will suck >> otherwise. By just whining in this thread about how sucky SVN is, is >> lazy and of course nothing will change, because 'it works today' and >> Fabio otherwise has to do a tremendous amount of work alone. Ever >> thought about that, 'team' ? Instead of all the energy of trying to >> show to the world how wrong I am about SVN, you also could have >> invested that in a migration plan to github. Did anyone do that? >> Wouldn't that have been a lot more productive? >> >> @Torkel: I tried to help you as you asked a question. Apparently you >> didn't want my answer, as you already knew what was better. You asked >> why I didn't have a problem, and I honestly replied with what we do. >> If that apparently seems a lie to you, what else can I do? Do you >> really think we can create / ship software with sucky sourcecontrol >> which doesn't work? No. If you didn't want my answer, it would have >> been great if you would have said that in the first place, so I would >> have saved myself the time replying to you. Think about that next time >> you ask someone a question, ok? >> >> I've decided to leave this list because after this thread it occurred >> to me it's not really valuable to invest time on this mailinglist. So >> after this post I'll. >> >> FB >> >> > Get your act together please. >> > >> > On Fri, Nov 5, 2010 at 11:43 AM, Richard Brown (gmail) < >> > >> > [email protected]> wrote: >> > > No abuse please. >> > >> > -- >> > Ken Egozi. >> http://www.kenegozi.com/bloghttp://www.delver.comhttp://www.musicglue.comhttp://www.castleproject.orghttp://www.idcc.co.il-הכנס >> הקהילתי הראשון למפתחי דוטנט - בואו בהמוניכם > > > > > -- > Fabio Maulo > > -- Fabio Maulo
