>I guess I simply wish SbS had an option to turn off "guessing"
>regarding compilations for any of us that don't want the guessing based
>on tags.
>
It isn't guessing.  It's sensible logic.  Differing song artists = compilation 
with album artist = Various Artists.

After all, it has to do *something* if there is no other information to go on.  
What is the alternative?

If it had not made your album a compilation, with album artist "Various 
Artists", then what would it have done?  It would have ended up with multiple 
albums with the same name, one for each track artist.  The songs would not be 
joined together onto one album.

The logic has been implemented this way for this exact reason.  It can't 
automatically join all songs on an album tag that matches otherwise you have 
the "Greatest Hits" issue.  e.g. Where two albums called "Greatest Hits" by 
different artists are merged into one album containing all songs on both albums.
_______________________________________________
ripping mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.slimdevices.com/mailman/listinfo/ripping

Reply via email to