Re: [Finale] OT Contemporary music and anti-intellectualism

2006-01-30 Thread Darcy James Argue
Oh okay. If you mean fruitful, creative, musically omnivorous collaborations between classically-trained musicians and/or composers alongside musicians from other backgrounds, that's what the Downtown NY scene has been like for at least the past 30 years or so. The fully-notated music comin

[Finale] Netiquette [was: Happy 250th Birthday Mozart]

2006-01-30 Thread Ken Moore
"David W. Fenton" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Unfortunately, it seems that the reaction I've > provoked among some is to the wrong thing, the style rather than the > content. This may be a defect in my writing or it may be a defect in > the comprehension of the readers. Early users of the inter

Re: [Finale] OT Contemporary music and anti-intellectualism [was: Happy 250th Birthday Mozart]

2006-01-30 Thread dhbailey
Owain Sutton wrote: dhbailey wrote: Or to go to a football game (if you add in the cost of parking and the vastly overpriced souvenirs and refreshments). Another very good comparison. And in terms of sheer numbers and regularity of attendance, one that shows price is not necessarily an

Re: [Finale] Happy 250th Birthday Mozart

2006-01-30 Thread dhbailey
Darcy James Argue wrote: On 29 Jan 2006, at 7:41 PM, Carl Dershem wrote: Darcy James Argue wrote: Actually, the majority of indie rock fans roughly my age (let's say 21-40) are all in favor of timbrallly, structurally, lyrically sophisticated music that challenges them as listeners. Th

Re: [Finale] Happy 250th Birthday Mozart

2006-01-30 Thread dhbailey
John Howell wrote: dhbailey wrote: Writing music you detest to put bread on your table is selling out (think of those horrid German Dances and countless Minuets which Beethoven and Mozart wrote to put bread on their table) but writing music which you believe in but is tailored to someone's s

Re: [Finale] rulers

2006-01-30 Thread dhbailey
Cecil Rigby wrote: just wondering--- Why is it that when I view at 75% the rulers have inches that are correct, but at 100% view inches are one and five-eighths long? It's obvious the length is relative to view, but one would expect an inch to be the right length at 100% view, no? What resol

Re: [Finale] Happy 250th Birthday Mozart

2006-01-30 Thread dhbailey
Carl Dershem wrote: Dean M. Estabrook wrote: I can just hear Dick Clark's kids giving it a 10, because it has a beat and you can dance to it. (Probably dating myself) From discussions I've had mith my nieces and nephews and their contemporaries, most of the music fans now want the sam

Re: [Finale] Happy 250th Birthday Mozart

2006-01-30 Thread dhbailey
John Howell wrote: At 5:24 PM -0800 1/29/06, Brennon Bortz wrote: John, Would you point me in the direction of this "OrchestraList"? I'd really appreciate it! Thank you, Brennon Bortz [EMAIL PROTECTED] Not sure about the protocol for subscribing. A very nice bunch of very knowledgeabl

Re: [Finale] Happy 250th Birthday Mozart

2006-01-30 Thread Owain Sutton
John Howell wrote: At 10:53 AM + 1/29/06, Owain Sutton wrote: Some good points, perhaps, although I think you need a bit more evidence before making such claims about Dufay or Josquin with such certainty! In DuFay's lifetime the popularity of one's music can be measured by the number

Re: [Finale] Mozart's 250th Anniversary

2006-01-30 Thread Phil Daley
At 1/29/2006 08:35 PM, John Howell wrote: >At 12:43 PM -0500 1/29/06, Phil Daley wrote: >>In church this morning: >> >>Prelude: Gavotte >>Anthem: Praise God, Sing All Ye Heavens >>Offertory: Sonata in F Major >>Postlude: Ah Vous Dirais >> >>Worship Note: In celebration of Mozart's 250th birt

Re: [Finale] Happy 250th Birthday Mozart

2006-01-30 Thread David W. Fenton
On 29 Jan 2006 at 20:18, John Howell wrote: > At 10:53 AM + 1/29/06, Owain Sutton wrote: > > > >Some good points, perhaps, although I think you need a bit more > >evidence before making such claims about Dufay or Josquin with such > >certainty! > > In DuFay's lifetime the popularity of one's

Re: [Finale] Happy 250th Birthday Mozart

2006-01-30 Thread David W. Fenton
On 29 Jan 2006 at 18:59, Richard Yates wrote: [quoting me, unattributed:] > > I'm not sure why anyone > > thinks that public posts on that subject could be helpful under any > > circumstances. > > Because the posts are public, you know that everyone else knows that > the posts have been made and

Re: [Finale] rulers

2006-01-30 Thread Cecil Rigby
it's set to 96 DPI Cecil > What resolution is your monitor set to? That can make a difference as > to whether what a program thinkgs of as 100% really is 100%. > David H. Bailey ___ Finale mailing list Finale@shsu.edu http://lists.shsu.edu/mailman/l

Re: [Finale] OT Contemporary music and anti-intellectualism [was: Happy 250th Birthday Mozart]

2006-01-30 Thread David Froom
On 1/29/06 7:52 PM, Carl Dershem wrote: > To me, the price of tickets, plus the perception of snootiness are at > least as much what keep the audiences away as anything else. Carl, You are absolutely right. As a way of backing up what I say, we have a festival here in Maryland, in the rural part

Re: [Finale] OT Contemporary music and anti-intellectualism

2006-01-30 Thread John Howell
At 11:43 PM -0600 1/29/06, Noel Stoutenburg wrote: Andrew: When I read my comment There is in the U.S. a dogmatic divide between "contemporary" and "classical" music that just does not exist in Europe. and your reply I reiterate (for the third time now in this thread, so far w.o rejoinder)

Re: [Finale] OT Contemporary music and anti-intellectualism [was: Happy 250th Birthday Mozart]

2006-01-30 Thread Carolyn Bremer
Great story, David. Here in LA there is snootiness and some non-snootiness. The LA Phil makes its attempt at the bowl and does very well. Up front is snooty and fancy dinners, in back is less snooty and hot dogs (though still expensive for many). In comparison, there are ensembles like the Long B

Re: [Finale] OT Contemporary music and anti-intellectualism

2006-01-30 Thread Dean M. Estabrook
Question: Does this history extend back to the time when Shaw was Music Director of the ASO? Just curious, Dean On Jan 29, 2006, at 10:21 PM, Darcy James Argue wrote: There is a long history of this in Atlanta -- Randy Newman premiered the material from his (very, very good) album _Goo

Re: [Finale] verses

2006-01-30 Thread Andrew Stiller
On 28 Jan 2006 at 17:40, John Howell wrote: Personal opinion: Any song with 10 verses shows lack of craft on the part of the poet So much for most of the Child ballads... Andrew Stiller Kallisti Music Press http://home.netcom.com/~kallisti/ ___ Fin

[Finale] RE: classical concert prices (was: various)

2006-01-30 Thread Andrew Stiller
Prices here in Philadelphia are comparable to those cited for San Diego. Andrew Stiller Kallisti Music Press http://home.netcom.com/~kallisti/ ___ Finale mailing list Finale@shsu.edu http://lists.shsu.edu/mailman/listinfo/finale

Re: [Finale] OT Contemporary music and anti-intellectualism [was: Happy 250th Birthday Mozart]

2006-01-30 Thread Andrew Stiller
On Jan 30, 2006, at 12:43 AM, Noel Stoutenburg wrote: Andrew: When I read my comment There is in the U.S. a dogmatic divide between "contemporary" and "classical" music that just does not exist in Europe. and your reply I reiterate (for the third time now in this thread, so far w.o rejoi

Re: [Finale] Happy 250th Birthday Mozart

2006-01-30 Thread Andrew Stiller
On Jan 30, 2006, at 6:26 AM, Owain Sutton wrote: Petrucci was a shrewd (or very lucky) businessman. But, we do not know who he sold books to, or even how many he sold. Early printed music, right up through at least the 17th c., cost more--much more--than an MS because it looked better and wa

[Finale] Melody

2006-01-30 Thread Mike Greensill
Very nice piece John, I think you've nailed it except for a couple of points. > John Unfortunately the current reaction to even the modest effort that it takes to appreciate the American Songbook has now resulted in the masses giving up mel

Re: [Finale] Melody

2006-01-30 Thread Phil Daley
At 1/30/2006 01:19 PM, Mike Greensill wrote: >You seem to make the point that it's an "either or" situation. I >think it's much greyer than that. The reason kids have given up >melody is because they never get to sing it and never get to hear it. >The appreciation of any music does take effort an

Re: [Finale] Happy 250th Birthday Mozart

2006-01-30 Thread Darcy James Argue
On 30 Jan 2006, at 6:08 AM, dhbailey wrote: Darcy James Argue wrote: On 29 Jan 2006, at 7:41 PM, Carl Dershem wrote: Darcy James Argue wrote: Actually, the majority of indie rock fans roughly my age (let's say 21-40) are all in favor of timbrallly, structurally, lyrically sophisticat

Re: [Finale] Happy 250th Birthday Mozart

2006-01-30 Thread Owain Sutton
Andrew Stiller wrote: On Jan 30, 2006, at 6:26 AM, Owain Sutton wrote: Petrucci was a shrewd (or very lucky) businessman. But, we do not know who he sold books to, or even how many he sold. Early printed music, right up through at least the 17th c., cost more--much more--than an MS becaus

Re: [Finale] OT Contemporary music and anti-intellectualism

2006-01-30 Thread Darcy James Argue
Well, yes and no. I have no idea if Shaw was personally involved in any of the crossover stuff -- most of the time, the music director doesn't conduct the pops gigs. Anyway, the _Good Old Boys_ premiere happened back in 1974 and the orchestra was conducted by one of Randy's uncles, Emil New

Re: [Finale] Melody

2006-01-30 Thread Mike Greensill
<>Phil I only have local knowledge. And unfortunately here in the mostly wonderful city of San Francisco, except for the performing arts high school, music programs have disappeared and it's a continous fight to provde any music. I know this because I'm on the board of "Music In Schools T

[Finale] Clear Items - some things clearable gone?

2006-01-30 Thread Christopher Smith
Hi, A repost of an earlier question that went unanswered. Am I doing this right? C. On Jan 29, 2006, at 4:59 PM, Christopher Smith wrote: Hey! What happened to Mass Edit>Clear Items... lyrics or chords? In my FinMac2006c these items are greyed out! I worked around it by copying the me

Re: [Finale] Clear Items - some things clearable gone?

2006-01-30 Thread Carolyn Bremer
Is it this: When "clear entries" is checked, it clears ALL of the grayed-out items. Uncheck "clear entries" to choose invidivual items. For me in FinMac2006c, this turns the gray-ed out to black, and I can then select lyrics to clear. -Carolyn On 1/30/06, Christopher Smith <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wr

Re: [Finale] rulers

2006-01-30 Thread Noel Stoutenburg
Cecil Rigby wrote: just wondering--- Why is it that when I view at 75% the rulers have inches that are correct, but at 100% view inches are one and five-eighths long? It's obvious the length is relative to view, but one would expect an inch to be the right length at 100% view, no? Would I expec

Re: [Finale] OT Contemporary music and anti-intellectualism [was: Happy 250th Birthday Mozart]

2006-01-30 Thread Raymond Horton
David Froom wrote: On 1/29/06 7:52 PM, Carl Dershem wrote: To me, the price of tickets, plus the perception of snootiness are at least as much what keep the audiences away as anything else. Carl, You are absolutely right. As a way of backing up what I say, we have a festival here in

Re: [Finale] Clear Items - some things clearable gone?

2006-01-30 Thread Raymond Horton
I, for one, did not see your earlier question. RBH Christopher Smith wrote: Hi, A repost of an earlier question that went unanswered. Am I doing this right? C. On Jan 29, 2006, at 4:59 PM, Christopher Smith wrote: Hey! What happened to Mass Edit>Clear Items... lyrics or chords? In my

Re: [Finale] OT Contemporary music and anti-intellectualism [was: Happy 250th Birthday Mozart]

2006-01-30 Thread Noel Stoutenburg
Andrew Stiller wrote: Only after some thought did I realize that you were using "contemporary" to mean "popular." To be quite frank, you shouldn't do this. Every person I've ever encountered who uses "contemporary" in this way, does so because they honestly believe that popular music *postdat

Re: [Finale] Happy 250th Birthday Mozart

2006-01-30 Thread David W. Fenton
On 30 Jan 2006 at 19:36, Owain Sutton wrote: > If you've got information on Petrucci's retail prices, a lot of people > would be interested in knowing it! Well, I believe we now have a pretty definitive survey of Petrucci's output, Stanley Boorman's "Ottaviano Petrucci: A Catalogue Raisonné":

Re: [Finale] OT Contemporary music and anti-intellectualism [was: Happy 250th Birthday Mozart]

2006-01-30 Thread David W. Fenton
On 30 Jan 2006 at 9:48, David Froom wrote: > So, Carl, yes you are exactly right. Get rid of high prices and > snootiness, and classical music of every stripe flourishes. Er, when somebody pays the musicians so that the audience doesn't have to pay. Which gets us back to the US vs. Europe comp

Re: [Finale] Happy 250th Birthday Mozart

2006-01-30 Thread Owain Sutton
I didn't realise he'd finally finished it! (Yet another reminder that I've been out of the academic loop a bit too long...) Trouble is getting my hands on a copy around here, as $250 is a bit out of my reach at the moment ;) I'm intrigued to know if he's turned up firm evidence regarding Pet

Re: [Finale] rulers

2006-01-30 Thread David W. Fenton
On 29 Jan 2006 at 18:38, Brad Beyenhof wrote: > On 1/29/06, Cecil Rigby <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > just wondering--- > > Why is it that when I view at 75% the rulers have inches that are > > correct, but at 100% view inches are one and five-eighths long? It's > > obvious the length is relative

Re: [Finale] Happy 250th Birthday Mozart

2006-01-30 Thread Éric Dussault
Le 06-01-30 à 09:20, David W. Fenton a écrit :I'm quaking in my boots at the idea that everyone is saying bad  things about me behind my back! Or on the list! Look, I've been around a long time participating in online  discussion, and I know how to hold up my end of a discussion. I'm not  afra

Re: [Finale] Happy 250th Birthday Mozart

2006-01-30 Thread David W. Fenton
On 30 Jan 2006 at 20:25, Éric Dussault wrote: > I just wish there would be a moderator on this list to kick you out. If this list were moderated it would cease to be interesting. I've seen it happen in other forums -- people complain about "rudeness" from other posters and demand a moderated li

Re: [Finale] Happy 250th Birthday Mozart

2006-01-30 Thread Éric Dussault
Le 06-01-30 à 20:43, David W. Fenton a écrit : If this list were moderated it would cease to be interesting. I've  seen it happen in other forums -- people complain about "rudeness"  from other posters and demand a moderated list. The list becomes  moderated and then nothing interesting is ever pos

Re: [Finale] Happy 250th Birthday Mozart

2006-01-30 Thread Éric Dussault
Le 06-01-30 à 20:43, David W. Fenton a écrit :And, again, you insist on drawing the thing out by posting yet again  without actually adding any useful content to the list. It completely  baffles me as to why your post needed to be made in public. I honestly don't care about the content if it is off

Re: [Finale] Happy 250th Birthday Mozart - now Finale list vs D. F.

2006-01-30 Thread Raymond Horton
I really thought we were done with all of this. As someone who has been on the receiving end of David's barbs on occasion, I have to say that the criticism of him has gone way overboard. Anyone else for calling an end to this and getting back to Finale and tangential musical discussions?

Re: [Finale] Happy 250th Birthday Mozart

2006-01-30 Thread Carl Dershem
dhbailey wrote: I have to disagree here -- to Glenn Miller, melody was supremely important. Being able to dance to the music was important as well, but melody was very important. I think it was because for the audiences for which he played, dance music had to have melody AND beat. Otherwi

Re: [Finale] OT Contemporary music and anti-intellectualism [was: Happy 250th Birthday Mozart]

2006-01-30 Thread Carl Dershem
David Froom wrote: So, Carl, yes you are exactly right. Get rid of high prices and snootiness, and classical music of every stripe flourishes. David Froom Sounds like a fun series! Does Don Patterson play with you guys? cd -- http://www.livejournal.com/users/dershem/#

Re: [Finale] Happy 250th Birthday Mozart

2006-01-30 Thread David W. Fenton
On 30 Jan 2006 at 20:48, Éric Dussault wrote: > I think you're sick David. HOW DARE YOU BE SO RUDE AND INSULTING AND OFFENSIVE!!! ;) -- David W. Fentonhttp://dfenton.com David Fenton Associates http://dfenton.com/DFA/

Re: [Finale] OT Contemporary music and anti-intellectualism [was: Happy 250th Birthday Mozart]

2006-01-30 Thread John Howell
At 5:41 PM -0500 1/30/06, David W. Fenton wrote: On 30 Jan 2006 at 9:48, David Froom wrote: So, Carl, yes you are exactly right. Get rid of high prices and snootiness, and classical music of every stripe flourishes. Er, when somebody pays the musicians so that the audience doesn't have to

Re: [Finale] Happy 250th Birthday Mozart

2006-01-30 Thread Eric Dannewitz
There should be a tag on your email saying "Don't feed the troll". David W. Fenton wrote: Finally! I've been suggesting this all along. It's how I deal with trolls in other forums whose posts I'm not interested in reading. And, again, you insist on drawing the thing out by posting yet agai

Re: [Finale] Happy 250th Birthday Mozart

2006-01-30 Thread Eric Dannewitz
Well, except for that Oboe joke. I'm sure it offended some Oboist somewhere..;-) Éric Dussault wrote: Le 06-01-30 à 20:43, David W. Fenton a écrit : If this list were moderated it would cease to be interesting. I've seen it happen in other forums -- people complain about "rude

Re: [Finale] Happy 250th Birthday Mozart

2006-01-30 Thread Eric Dannewitz
Please, just disregard him. I mean, he has lost credibility when he failed to read the manual. We really don't need to get into a Fenton diagnosis thread. I think everyone on the list knows what he is.. Éric Dussault wrote: Le 06-01-30 à 20:43, David W. Fenton a écrit : And, again, you

Re: [Finale] OT Contemporary music and anti-intellectualism [was: Happy 250th Birthday Mozart]

2006-01-30 Thread Carl Dershem
John Howell wrote: At 5:41 PM -0500 1/30/06, David W. Fenton wrote: On 30 Jan 2006 at 9:48, David Froom wrote: So, Carl, yes you are exactly right. Get rid of high prices and snootiness, and classical music of every stripe flourishes. Er, when somebody pays the musicians so that the aud

[Finale] [Fwd: Musical Humor]

2006-01-30 Thread Carl Dershem
*This collection is tough on drummers -- but, hey, somebody has to do it - lts of oldies but a few new ones.* Q: What is the difference between a drummer and a monkey? A: You can train a monkey. Q: How does a lead singer screw in a light bulb? A: He holds the bulb and the world revolves around h