Maik Justus wrote:
That would be the best. But how to know, that 1.2 would work? It looks
If version 1.2 still contains this bug it will be noticed rather quickly
and changing the test would be easy.
like, if the OpenAL Doppler effect bugs are a never ending story. And
they do not work
Hi Erik,
Erik Hofman schrieb am 28.06.2007 08:50:
Maik Justus wrote:
That would be the best. But how to know, that 1.2 would work? It looks
If version 1.2 still contains this bug it will be noticed rather quickly
and changing the test would be easy.
ok, I will test for the 1.2 and
Hi all,
here is a new patch for the Doppler effect, which should work on every OS.
Please report, if you get any error messages or hear any unexpected sound.
(Due to some debug-error-messages not intended to go into cvs)
Maik
Maik Justus schrieb am 28.06.2007 20:22:
Hi Erik,
Erik Hofman
Hi,
I forgot: only for osg/head.
Maik
Maik Justus schrieb am 28.06.2007 22:55:
Hi all,
here is a new patch for the Doppler effect, which should work on every
OS.
Please report, if you get any error messages or hear any unexpected
sound.
(Due to some debug-error-messages not intended to
* Melchior FRANZ -- Tuesday 26 June 2007:
There's no release imminent for fg/osg, and we have time to clear
matters and don't need to rush in a workaround for a (potentially)
long fixed bug.
I guess things are clear now. Read through this thread:
Melchior FRANZ wrote:
So it's now also clear that we have to fix FlightGear's broken
sound ourselves for 0.9.11 (fg/plib branch). If it can be done
in a way that doesn't break the current framework and makes clear
which parts are the workaround (by using #ifdefs and comments,
as is the case
Hi Erik,
Erik Hofman schrieb am 27.06.2007 09:04:
Melchior FRANZ wrote:
So it's now also clear that we have to fix FlightGear's broken
sound ourselves for 0.9.11 (fg/plib branch). If it can be done
in a way that doesn't break the current framework and makes clear
which parts are the
* Erik Hofman -- Tuesday 26 June 2007:
Since it seems to be a Windows problem it's not a matter of depending on
a svn build or not.
Im must say, though, that my reluctance to commit that was based
on the assumption that Doppler is really only functional in fg/osg,
but not fg/plib. There's no
Maik Justus wrote:
If you have any argument against the patch, please let us know.
As the original author of the FlightGear sound class and the one who put
the directional code in FlightGear I'm opposed to this patch.
Let's just wait what the OpenAL developers have to say before we
continue
Hi Erik,
Erik Hofman schrieb am 25.06.2007 08:30:
Maik Justus wrote:
If you have any argument against the patch, please let us know.
As the original author of the FlightGear sound class and the one who put
the directional code in FlightGear I'm opposed to this patch.
Let's just wait
Maik Justus wrote:
Yes, no problem to wait for an answer on the OpenAL-devel list. I read
through the archive and found a long thread in september 2005, where
they fixed some Doppler bugs. Probably it was our bug. Don't know, when
this will go into a release. Do we really want to depend on
Maik,
Maik Justus wrote:
The enclosed patch switches of the Doppler calculation of OpenAL and
adds a own Doppler calculation.
I doubt that this is the intention of those people who introdced OpenAL
to FlightGear.
Once you put this, well, 'hack' into FlightGear, will there still be
someone
Hi Martin,
Martin Spott schrieb am 24.06.2007 11:04:
Maik,
Maik Justus wrote:
The enclosed patch switches of the Doppler calculation of OpenAL and
adds a own Doppler calculation.
I doubt that this is the intention of those people who introdced OpenAL
to FlightGear.
Maybe
* Maik Justus -- Sunday 24 June 2007:
It seems that (at least) on windows there is a bug within OpenAL
calculating the Doppler effect.
The enclosed patch switches of the Doppler calculation of OpenAL and
adds a own Doppler calculation.
The patch is not designed for cvs (now).
As I said on
Hi Melchior,
Melchior FRANZ schrieb am 24.06.2007 17:42:
* Maik Justus -- Sunday 24 June 2007:
It seems that (at least) on windows there is a bug within OpenAL
calculating the Doppler effect.
The enclosed patch switches of the Doppler calculation of OpenAL and
adds a own
Hi Maik,
Maik Justus wrote:
[...]
But I won't wait for the bug fixed in OpenAL, if the way to get
realistic Doppler effect is as simple as it is.
Did you compare the price that FlightGear pays for knowingly
introducing and carrying along such a 'hack' on one side with the net
benefit for the
Hi Martin,
Martin Spott schrieb am 24.06.2007 23:27:
Hi Maik,
Maik Justus wrote:
[...]
But I won't wait for the bug fixed in OpenAL, if the way to get
realistic Doppler effect is as simple as it is.
Did you compare the price that FlightGear pays for knowingly
introducing and
Hi,
at the osg branch, the directional sound and doppler effects should work
since two days.
It seems that (at least) on windows there is a bug within OpenAL
calculating the Doppler effect.
Either there is no Doppler Effect (like I have) or it is totally wrong
(as aerotro has with the same
18 matches
Mail list logo
