Re: [FRIAM] faith

2012-09-26 Thread John Kennison
There are some things we take so completely on faith that we have great trouble even realizing that we are making an assumption. For example, when I open my eyes, I take it on faith that I am seeing an actual physical universe, and not simply recording impulses that my eyes forwarded to my

Re: [FRIAM] faith

2012-09-26 Thread Prof David West
In his biography - Sonny Barger is quoted as saying he wished the Angels had not been so closely tied to Harley - that the Japanese cruisers in particular were more reliable and much faster. He said that before the rebirth of Harley - post AMF. My Crossbones has the same reliability and overall

Re: [FRIAM] faith - take 2

2012-09-26 Thread ERIC P. CHARLES
The faith discussion seemed to fall apart, but might now be pulling itself back together - hence the slight subject change. One variant of the pragmatic dictum, using James's catchy phrasing, is that There is no difference that doesn't make a difference. In this particular situation, the there is

Re: [FRIAM] Faith

2012-09-26 Thread Prof David West
If people are really interested in the evolution of Buddhism - Jenny Quillien and I are planning a Buddha Tour - a month long study trip starting at Bodh Gaya (birthplace) then proceeding to Dharmsala (Tibetan variation) - Bangkok (Hinayana variation) - shaolin (the Taoist infusion) - Nara Japan

Re: [FRIAM] faith - take 2

2012-09-26 Thread Nicholas Thompson
Everybody, Have a look at the link, doxastic logic http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doxastic_logic , that Russ put in his note below. It’s a stunner. Nick From: friam-boun...@redfish.com [mailto:friam-boun...@redfish.com] On Behalf Of ERIC P. CHARLES Sent: Wednesday, September 26, 2012

Re: [FRIAM] faith

2012-09-26 Thread Sarbajit Roy
In the context of religious faith. doubt * belief = 1 If doubt = 0 then belief = 1/0 = singularity = God If certainty = 0 then doubt = 1/0 = noGod In most Eastern religions people are somewhere in between and see no harm in (occasionally) worshiping things they don't always believe in (sort of

Re: [FRIAM] faith

2012-09-26 Thread Nicholas Thompson
Sarbajit, Interesting. I am packing up and also somebody has suggested that I am jamming the channel here, so I wont say more now, except to thank you for your illuminating and throughtful posts. Nick -Original Message- From: friam-boun...@redfish.com

Re: [FRIAM] DEBATE about Religion and Atheism

2012-09-26 Thread Roger Critchlow
Alfredo -- Very interesting listening. One might believe that they are all very reasonable men, until you get to the very end of the video where they listen to Hitch argue that the end of world civilization is imminent unless the Islamic world is reformed of its unacceptable beliefs, a

Re: [FRIAM] faith

2012-09-26 Thread Roger Critchlow
http://www.nature.com has provoked its own discussion on faith. In August: *Sometimes science must give way to religion* http://www.nature.com/news/sometimes-science-must-give-way-to-religion-1.11244 arguing why it will always be necessary to have ways of understanding our world beyond the

[FRIAM] Buddha Tour.

2012-09-26 Thread Steve Smith
Dave and Jenny - In the spirit of living vicariously, I took a moment to map a presumed route (by Nissan Patrol, Jeepney, Motorcycle and/or foot)... with the help of course, of Google (long name for an all-knowing God?) Acquiring a Seep like this modified one

Re: [FRIAM] faith

2012-09-26 Thread Victoria Hughes
Gentlemen and Ladies- There is a big question in this endless and reiterative loop about faith and science that no one mentions. So I will. Seems to be one of my functions. To wit: Even our brains have two primary and differing sections, the hemispheres: for best health and growth of the

Re: [FRIAM] faith - take 2

2012-09-26 Thread Steve Smith
On 9/26/12 9:09 AM, Nicholas Thompson wrote: Everybody, Have a look at the link, doxastic logic http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doxastic_logic, that Russ put in his note below. It's a stunner. Nick The preferred variant of many (vocal) FRIAMers is /Dogmatic Logic/ which is the preferred

Re: [FRIAM] faith

2012-09-26 Thread Steve Smith
No, I think that would be me (jamming the channel)... Sarbajit, Interesting. I am packing up and also somebody has suggested that I am jamming the channel here, so I wont say more now, except to thank you for your illuminating and throughtful posts. Nick -Original Message- From:

Re: [FRIAM] DEBATE about Religion and Atheism

2012-09-26 Thread Steve Smith
Did you just point out that the mighty Hitch himself has come up with his own justification for an anti-Islamic Jihad? And the rest endorsed it with their silence? Alfredo -- Very interesting listening. One might believe that they are all very reasonable men, until you get to the very end

Re: [FRIAM] Buddha Tour.

2012-09-26 Thread Steve Smith
Oh Yeah...

Re: [FRIAM] faith

2012-09-26 Thread Steve Smith
Tory - Why is the idea of two differing but synergistic approaches so challenging to so many on this list? Or are you arguing for the fun of the game? I'm pretty sure both the Monkey and the Weasel are in it for the endorphins released. The Mulberry bush is an innocent bystander, if in

Re: [FRIAM] faith

2012-09-26 Thread Victoria Hughes
(A post script to my frustrated rant replying to this thread (not to this post, Roger)) None of what I said precludes the table pounding and the whiskey. Need to go on record about that. Tory On Sep 26, 2012, at 2:02 PM, Roger Critchlow wrote: http://www.nature.com has provoked its own

Re: [FRIAM] faith

2012-09-26 Thread Victoria Hughes
It's your honesty I've always loved about you, Steve. I'm going with the weasel. T On Sep 26, 2012, at 2:40 PM, Steve Smith wrote: Tory - Why is the idea of two differing but synergistic approaches so challenging to so many on this list? Or are you arguing for the fun of the game? I'm

Re: [FRIAM] faith

2012-09-26 Thread Russ Abbott
Driving home I heard a report about New Zealand gangs. Apparently there are more gang-members *per capita* in New Zealand than any other country. (Surprised me.) Some of them are terribly violent. Very scary. Some have been reformed after finding Jesus. One of the best things that religion has

Re: [FRIAM] faith

2012-09-26 Thread Douglas Roberts
Not necessarily, the religious conversion will likely reduce the kill-off rate. On the other hand, I suppose, we could encourage Islamic and Christian themed gangs and still achieve a reasonable kill-off goal. On Sep 26, 2012 4:19 PM, Russ Abbott russ.abb...@gmail.com wrote: Driving home I

Re: [FRIAM] faith

2012-09-26 Thread Roger Critchlow
On Wed, Sep 26, 2012 at 2:40 PM, Steve Smith sasm...@swcp.com wrote: Tory - Why is the idea of two differing but synergistic approaches so challenging to so many on this list? Or are you arguing for the fun of the game? I'm pretty sure both the Monkey and the Weasel are in it for the

Re: [FRIAM] DEBATE about Religion and Atheism

2012-09-26 Thread Roger Critchlow
Yes, that's one way to hear it. But on review, I now hear Dennett attempting to interject, and Hitch allowing that Dawkins disagrees. Also wondering what got edited out, since something did. But start at 1:54:00 and listen to the last three minutes and fourteen seconds, and give me your

Re: [FRIAM] faith

2012-09-26 Thread Douglas Roberts
Well, speaking from my own (apparent) semi-unique perspective: Darwin's proposition of Survival of the Fittest would seem to scream out for the elimination of degenerate components of society which threaten to bring the entire species to total extinction. And, being an engineer, I cannot but

Re: [FRIAM] faith

2012-09-26 Thread Nicholas Thompson
Darwinism only says that the least prolific will be eliminated. It says nothing about degeneracy, unless, of course profligacy is defined as advanced. Spencer was the social Darwinist, not Darwin. In fact, it was SPENCER, who coined the survival of the fittest, I believe. N From:

Re: [FRIAM] faith

2012-09-26 Thread Arlo Barnes
Thank you Nick, I was going to say the same thing. -Arlo James Barnes FRIAM Applied Complexity Group listserv Meets Fridays 9a-11:30 at cafe at St. John's College lectures, archives, unsubscribe, maps at http://www.friam.org

Re: [FRIAM] faith

2012-09-26 Thread Douglas Roberts
Still, irrespective of whomever coined that old fittest rubric, dead gang members are far more productive members of society than live ones, I suspect. On Sep 26, 2012 9:48 PM, Nicholas Thompson nickthomp...@earthlink.net wrote: Darwinism only says that the least prolific will be eliminated.

Re: [FRIAM] faith

2012-09-26 Thread Douglas Roberts
I suspect that the more sensitive members of this list will think that my last message was unnecessarily pejorative with respect to gangs, and gang members. It would probably therefore be foolish of me to suggest including child-abusing priests, scientologists, and more than a few of the military

Re: [FRIAM] faith

2012-09-26 Thread Douglas Roberts
The common theme, however, just to tie a bow on it, is societal degeneracy. On Sep 26, 2012 10:15 PM, Douglas Roberts d...@parrot-farm.net wrote: I suspect that the more sensitive members of this list will think that my last message was unnecessarily pejorative with respect to gangs, and gang

Re: [FRIAM] faith

2012-09-26 Thread Roger Critchlow
And even the least prolific might manage to survive through a generation where they deserved extinction, such can be the luck of the draw. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Illegitimi_non_carborundum, but Darwin isn't going to help you on less than geologic time scales. -- rec -- On Wed, Sep 26,

Re: [FRIAM] faith

2012-09-26 Thread Steve Smith
Doug - Pretending to be one of the more sensitive members of the list, this sounds a lot like the only good Injun is a dead Injun... But that isn't what I want to take exception to... what I want to take exception to is that you or I or anyone else gets to decide that behaviours which