Re: [FRIAM] Meta-discussion

2013-04-25 Thread glen ropella
Yeah, but at least FOAR allows top-posting! Nothing on the internet is more irrational than the bias against top-posting. And I mean it. The bias against top-posting is the lower bound of rationality. Hm. Would it be oxymoronic to claim the existence of an upper bound on irrationality? Is

Re: [FRIAM] Meta-discussion

2013-04-25 Thread Robert Holmes
A: Because it messes up the order in which people normally read text. Q: Why is top-posting such a bad thing? A: Top-posting. Q: What is the most annoying thing in e-mail? On Thu, Apr 25, 2013 at 8:05 AM, glen ropella g...@ropella.name wrote: Yeah, but at least FOAR allows top-posting!

Re: [FRIAM] Meta-discussion

2013-04-25 Thread Marcus G. Daniels
On 4/25/13 8:05 AM, glen ropella wrote: Nothing on the internet is more irrational than the bias against top-posting. On 4/25/13 8:59 AM, Robert Holmes wrote: Because it messes up the order in which people normally read text. Top-posting encourages those that don't dissect one proposition at

Re: [FRIAM] Meta-discussion

2013-04-25 Thread Nicholas Thompson
See below. From: Friam [mailto:friam-boun...@redfish.com] On Behalf Of Robert Holmes Sent: Thursday, April 25, 2013 9:00 AM To: The Friday Morning Applied Complexity Coffee Group Subject: Re: [FRIAM] Meta-discussion [NST NST] Q: Does anybody know of an algorithm that creates an

[FRIAM] bursting the placebo bubble

2013-04-25 Thread glen
The issue keeps coming up. Perhaps I'm just sensitive to it, since my S.O. is (finally!) getting her B.S. in nursing at a Catholic university ... because she works for a Catholic hospital. And I can't think of a better example of applied complexity. Here's a recent interview on the Cancer

Re: [FRIAM] bursting the placebo bubble

2013-04-25 Thread Douglas Roberts
A better question might be: why are we still teaching them these dishonest little fairy tales in the first place, which we then have to un-teach later? --Doug On Thu, Apr 25, 2013 at 10:29 AM, glen g...@ropella.name wrote: The same could be said of children, I suppose. When/how do you

Re: [FRIAM] bursting the placebo bubble

2013-04-25 Thread glen
Douglas Roberts wrote at 04/25/2013 09:44 AM: A better question might be: why are we still teaching them these dishonest little fairy tales in the first place, which we then have to un-teach later? I admit that's a more philosophical question, but not a better one. It's not clear how answering

Re: [FRIAM] bursting the placebo bubble

2013-04-25 Thread siddharth
Unrelated to the main topic here, but all the talk of DNR et al reminded me of this article earlier this week - http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-22154552 . Hmmm. On Thu, Apr 25, 2013 at 10:38 PM, glen g...@ropella.name wrote: Douglas Roberts wrote at 04/25/2013 09:44 AM: A better question

Re: [FRIAM] bursting the placebo bubble

2013-04-25 Thread Douglas Roberts
The intent was to produce a pragmatic perspective, not a philosophical one. By avoiding the telling of escapist fantasy-world fairy tails in the first place, there will be less untruth to deal with at later stages in life. --Doug On Thu, Apr 25, 2013 at 11:08 AM, glen g...@ropella.name wrote:

Re: [FRIAM] bursting the placebo bubble

2013-04-25 Thread glen
Douglas Roberts wrote at 04/25/2013 10:16 AM: The intent was to produce a pragmatic perspective, not a philosophical one. By avoiding the telling of escapist fantasy-world fairy tails in the first place, there will be less untruth to deal with at later stages in life. You're talking about a

Re: [FRIAM] bursting the placebo bubble

2013-04-25 Thread glen
siddharth wrote at 04/25/2013 10:16 AM: Unrelated to the main topic here, but all the talk of DNR et al reminded me of this article earlier this week - http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-22154552 . Hmmm. Thanks. That's definitely relevant. But the trouble with that article (and most,

Re: [FRIAM] bursting the placebo bubble

2013-04-25 Thread Marcus G. Daniels
On 4/25/13 11:36 AM, glen wrote: So, the question remains, is there a medical benefit to bursting the beliefs of a patient? If the patient is asking a for an opinion, and the nurse has no reason to think the patient's mental faculties are especially compromised, then I think it is best to

Re: [FRIAM] bursting the placebo bubble

2013-04-25 Thread siddharth
'Realistic portrayals of CPR' such as this one by the British Heart Foundation?!?! - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ILxjxfB4zNk *sigh* stomps off into the sunset On Thu, Apr 25, 2013 at 11:34 PM, glen g...@ropella.name wrote: siddharth wrote at 04/25/2013 10:16 AM: Unrelated to the main

Re: [FRIAM] [EXTERNAL] Re: bursting the placebo bubble

2013-04-25 Thread Parks, Raymond
We have a Wounded Warrior at Sandia who died three times - once on the battlefield, once in the medevac helo, and once in the field hospital. We have several WWs at Sandia - I wonder how they received the news of their injuries? Combat injuries are surely a possible research pool to answer the

Re: [FRIAM] bursting the placebo bubble

2013-04-25 Thread Nicholas Thompson
A question for Doug. Would you be so kind as to describe to me, in sufficient detail that I could mount a Pragmatic test, this god of his whose non-existence he so positively asserts? A question for the person who speaks of escorting somebody into death. I confess, being old, I quite like

Re: [FRIAM] bursting the placebo bubble

2013-04-25 Thread glen
Nicholas Thompson wrote at 04/25/2013 12:02 PM: A question for the person who speaks of escorting somebody into death. I confess, being old, I quite like the concept. But I guess we have to remember that such an escort is always a Judas steer. I could not disagree with you more. We're

Re: [FRIAM] bursting the placebo bubble

2013-04-25 Thread Douglas Roberts
If you're asking me the question, then you're probably asking the wrong person. You'd most likely be better off asking a priest. Or a psychologist. --Doug On Thu, Apr 25, 2013 at 11:36 AM, glen g...@ropella.name wrote: beliefs of a patient? And more refined, does the condition of the

Re: [FRIAM] bursting the placebo bubble

2013-04-25 Thread glen
Douglas Roberts wrote at 04/25/2013 12:09 PM: If you're asking me the question, then you're probably asking the wrong person. You'd most likely be better off asking a priest. Or a psychologist. No, I wasn't asking you. History has taught me that you won't contribute. But I do believe there

Re: [FRIAM] bursting the placebo bubble

2013-04-25 Thread Nicholas Thompson
Glen wrote: The trick is whether the _cattle_ who are heading toward their slaughter are self-aware enough to understand that they're going to die Point taken. But, you know. Just to wax philosophical in exactly the sense that enrages Doug, I don't think we know our own death's, do we?

Re: [FRIAM] bursting the placebo bubble

2013-04-25 Thread Steve Smith
Doug wrote: The intent was to produce a pragmatic perspective, not a philosophical one. By avoiding the telling of escapist fantasy-world fairy tails in the first place, there will be less untruth to deal with at later stages in life. Both of my daughters (now 31, 33) were raised under the

Re: [FRIAM] bursting the placebo bubble

2013-04-25 Thread glen
That's an excellent 3 way split. I don't have any data to suggest what percentage of patients ask for opinions. But many people seem to trust the authority of the medical industrial complex. They take the drugs they're told to take, have the surgeries their specialists recommend, etc. So, my

Re: [FRIAM] bursting the placebo bubble

2013-04-25 Thread glen
Parks, Raymond wrote at 04/25/2013 11:36 AM: We have several WWs at Sandia - I wonder how they received the news of their injuries? Combat injuries are surely a possible research pool to answer the question of tell or hide. A surgeon from either Beth Israel or Mass General said that marathon

Re: [FRIAM] bursting the placebo bubble

2013-04-25 Thread glen
No, of course not. Perhaps death escort is a misnomer and dying escort would be better? To me, as a society, we bear the responsibility to make every dying person (i.e. every person) aware of the _possibilities_ that might obtain as we approach death. Or, if the person is a higher power type,

Re: [FRIAM] bursting the placebo bubble

2013-04-25 Thread Steve Smith
Q: glen wrote: So, the question remains, is there a medical benefit to bursting the beliefs of a patient? And more refined, does the condition of the patient matter? E.g. I can see how bursting my friend, who is getting accupuncture for her neck pain, might help her. But how about a 50 year

Re: [FRIAM] bursting the placebo bubble

2013-04-25 Thread Robert Holmes
Steve's post made me think of the Roger McGough poem Let me die a youngman's death: Let me die a youngman's death not a clean and inbetween the sheets holywater death not a famous-last-words peaceful out of breath death When I'm 73 and in constant good tumour may I be mown down at dawn by a

Re: [FRIAM] bursting the placebo bubble

2013-04-25 Thread Nicholas Thompson
Oh. Ok. Thanks, glen. I was, in fact, being annoying in exactly the way Doug or Owen would accuse me of. Nick -Original Message- From: Friam [mailto:friam-boun...@redfish.com] On Behalf Of glen Sent: Thursday, April 25, 2013 2:19 PM To: The Friday Morning Applied Complexity Coffee

Re: [FRIAM] bursting the placebo bubble

2013-04-25 Thread Steve Smith
And this is roughly what I like about both of you. A strong sense of self... And Nick's good natured desire to arbitrate as well. Carry on! - Steve You know, Glen, you can be a bit of an asshole at times. History has taught me this. On Thu, Apr 25, 2013 at 1:13 PM, glen

Re: [FRIAM] bursting the placebo bubble

2013-04-25 Thread Steve Smith
+2 Robert Holmes wrote: Steve's post made me think of the Roger McGough poem Let me die a youngman's death: Let me die a youngman's death not a clean and inbetween the sheets holywater death not a famous-last-words peaceful out of breath death When I'm 73 and in

Re: [FRIAM] bursting the placebo bubble

2013-04-25 Thread Victoria Hughes
Ah…. This and Steve's preceeding note are the most useful, humane comment so far in this thread. Thanks, Robert. Tory On Apr 25, 2013, at 2:44 PM, Robert Holmes rob...@robertholmes.org wrote: Steve's post made me think of the Roger McGough poem Let me die a youngman's death: Let me die

Re: [FRIAM] bursting the placebo bubble

2013-04-25 Thread Steve Smith
Nick - As much as this crowd (the vocal subset) likes to speculate (self acutely implicated) about all kinds of things, I suspect that for many of us, this speculation is anything but idle. I don't know our precise demographics but I believe we are top loaded with many over-60's which

[FRIAM] google glass-

2013-04-25 Thread Gillian Densmore
friend of mine sent me this: http://jacksonandwilson.com/google-glass/ thought I 'd share the love for friam to consider. FRIAM Applied Complexity Group listserv Meets Fridays 9a-11:30 at cafe at St. John's College to unsubscribe

Re: [FRIAM] bursting the placebo bubble

2013-04-25 Thread Dean Gerber
Ah yes, ah yes! Better hung for a wolf than a sheep From: Victoria Hughes victo...@toryhughes.com To: The Friday Morning Applied Complexity Coffee Group friam@redfish.com Sent: Thursday, April 25, 2013 3:06 PM Subject: Re: [FRIAM] bursting the placebo bubble

[FRIAM] Separate Vacations This Summer

2013-04-25 Thread Douglas Roberts
Dear FRIAMers (even those of you who are a bit of an asshole now then) I've come to the conclusion that it is best if we take separate vacations this summer. Accordingly, I have adjusted my incoming stream of email to skillfully detect any missives that originate from the FRIAM list, and have

Re: [FRIAM] Separate Vacations This Summer

2013-04-25 Thread Nicholas Thompson
According to the Village Pragmatist, this is a defeat. We have to stick together at all cost. N From: Friam [mailto:friam-boun...@redfish.com] On Behalf Of Douglas Roberts Sent: Thursday, April 25, 2013 7:11 PM To: The Friday Morning Applied Complexity Coffee Group Subject: [FRIAM]

Re: [FRIAM] Separate Vacations This Summer

2013-04-25 Thread Stephen Guerin
Doug, Your quips will be missed in the interim. Make it a quick one. Get a tan, have some pina coladas and come back rested and ready. -S On Thu, Apr 25, 2013 at 7:11 PM, Douglas Roberts d...@parrot-farm.netwrote: Dear FRIAMers (even those of you who are a bit of an asshole now then) I've

Re: [FRIAM] Meta-discussion

2013-04-25 Thread Russell Standish
On Thu, Apr 25, 2013 at 09:28:31AM -0600, Marcus G. Daniels wrote: On 4/25/13 8:05 AM, glen ropella wrote: Nothing on the internet is more irrational than the bias against top-posting. On 4/25/13 8:59 AM, Robert Holmes wrote: Because it messes up the order in which people normally read

Re: [FRIAM] Meta-discussion

2013-04-25 Thread Russell Standish
On Wed, Apr 24, 2013 at 11:01:55PM -0600, Steve Smith wrote: Nothing I love better than being thrown out of a bar. Exchanging a few blows with the bouncers, maybe landing a rabbit punch or two on the way through the door and coming back the next night for another round! Rules for the

Re: [FRIAM] Meta-discussion

2013-04-25 Thread Steve Smith
Russel - Thanks! Actually, I didn't find anything on the description pages about banning I thought it was *your* reference to banning (or maybe Glen) that I was responding to. Top posts and all that... I myself, am probably too rambly/tangenty for any list less seasoned by my

Re: [FRIAM] DIY science

2013-04-25 Thread Steve Smith
In the spirit of Glen's offerings of DIY Science, here is one I was recently tracking... http://www.sparkbangbuzz.com/tealaser/tealaser7.htm FYI T.E.A stands for transversely excited atmospheric laser... and it essentially uses the 70+% N2 in the atmosphere as the active element... the

Re: [FRIAM] google glass-

2013-04-25 Thread Steve Smith
Gil - friend of mine sent me this: http://jacksonandwilson.com/google-glass/ Thanks for the link... I do appreciate these kinds of vision-casting... I'm sure humanity will continue to extend it's phenotype rapidly, even if it doesn't go asymptotic/singularian... and it will change who we