Re: Applecare - impressed and not impressed

2004-09-05 Thread Al Poulin
Maybe the HD was manufactured after the date of the computer. You might get a clue by tracking System Profiler info on model and serial number and checking things from there. Or maybe you can expose a physical label with info on the HD itself. Timothy Luoma [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Except

Re: Applecare - impressed and not impressed

2004-09-05 Thread RK Rossi
On Sep 2, 2004, at 11:41, G-Books wrote: Message-Id: [EMAIL PROTECTED] From: Timothy Luoma [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Applecare - impressed and not impressed Date: Thu, 2 Sep 2004 02:06:06 -0400 Several times this form letter refers to my 'iBook' (which was really a Powerbook). TjL Hello Tim, I

Re: Applecare - impressed and not impressed

2004-09-05 Thread Jan Musil
On Sep 5, 2004, at 6:34 PM, RK Rossi wrote: It is very possible that iBook and Powerbook are grouped together too. They are not - the iBook Apple Care is much cheaper than PowerBook. They sell in different boxes. see. http://www.apple.com/support/products/ Jan -- G-Books is sponsored by

Re: Applecare - impressed and not impressed

2004-09-04 Thread Timothy Luoma
As an Apple Certified Technician I can assure you that if you sent that machine to my shop I wouldn't have looked at that printout for more than a second and then I would have gone about my merry way troubleshooting it with *real* utilities. Not lightweight consumer stuff like Techtool. Real

Re: Applecare - impressed and not impressed

2004-09-04 Thread Kyle Hansen
On 9/4/04 4:38 PM, Timothy Luoma [EMAIL PROTECTED] Spew into the Cybertrough: I'm not sure what they replaced. All I know is that they sent it back with my Crucial RAM in a baggie and a note saying that my hard drive problems were caused by 3rd party RAM because all of the problems stopped

Re: Applecare - impressed and not impressed

2004-09-03 Thread Timothy Luoma
.. Original Message ... On Thu, 02 Sep 2004 14:33:41 -0400 [EMAIL PROTECTED] [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: But if the diagnostic test doesn't show up any problem the fun begins The problem with that theory here is that TechTools reported a problem with the HD (which I printed out and sent

Re: Applecare - impressed and not impressed

2004-09-03 Thread Kyle Hansen
On 9/3/04 7:00 AM, Timothy Luoma [EMAIL PROTECTED] Spew into the Cybertrough: The problem with that theory here is that TechTools reported a problem with the HD (which I printed out and sent along) plus Finder/cp showed problems on some files which I put in one folder on the Desktop called

Re: Applecare - impressed and not impressed

2004-09-03 Thread Mark Kippert
Kyle Hansen on 9/3/04 1:27 PM wrote: As an Apple Certified Technician I can assure you that if you sent that machine to my shop I wouldn't have looked at that printout for more than a second and then I would have gone about my merry way troubleshooting it with *real* utilities. Not

Re: Applecare - impressed and not impressed

2004-09-03 Thread Tom and Lisa P
As an Apple Certified Technician I can assure you that if you sent that machine to my shop I wouldn't have looked at that printout for more than a second and then I would have gone about my merry way troubleshooting it with *real* utilities. Not lightweight consumer stuff like Techtool. Real

Re: Applecare - impressed and not impressed

2004-09-03 Thread victoria duggan
As an Apple Certified Technician I can assure you that if you sent that machine to my shop I wouldn't have looked at that printout for more than a second and then I would have gone about my merry way troubleshooting it with *real* utilities. Not lightweight consumer stuff like Techtool.

Re: Applecare - impressed and not impressed

2004-09-03 Thread Tom and Lisa P
As an Apple Certified Technician I can assure you that if you sent that machine to my shop I wouldn't have looked at that printout for more than a second and then I would have gone about my merry way troubleshooting it with *real* utilities. Not lightweight consumer stuff like Techtool.

Re: Applecare - impressed and not impressed

2004-09-03 Thread victoria duggan
From: Tom and Lisa P [EMAIL PROTECTED] Reply-To: G-Books [EMAIL PROTECTED] Date: Fri, 3 Sep 2004 15:41:19 -0400 To: G-Books [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: Applecare - impressed and not impressed As an Apple Certified Technician I can assure you that if you sent that machine to my

Re: Applecare - impressed and not impressed

2004-09-03 Thread Kyle Hansen
On 9/3/04 12:02 PM, Mark Kippert [EMAIL PROTECTED] Spew into the Cybertrough: Kyle Hansen on 9/3/04 1:27 PM wrote: As an Apple Certified Technician I can assure you that if you sent that machine to my shop I wouldn't have looked at that printout for more than a second and then I would have

Re: Applecare - impressed and not impressed

2004-09-03 Thread Kyle Hansen
On 9/3/04 2:55 PM, Tom and Lisa P [EMAIL PROTECTED] Spew into the Cybertrough: I use Apple's internal Service Diagnostics Software and a couple of Hardware Board testers and hard drive testing stations. The only retail Utilities I use are Diskwarrior and Hard Disk Speedtools. Apple has a

Re: Applecare - impressed and not impressed

2004-09-03 Thread Bruce Johnson
On Sep 3, 2004, at 3:24 PM, Kyle Hansen wrote: They are really well organized. Better than any PC company and I have many Certs on the PC side as well. That's odd, because I usually find Tums to be far more useful on the PC side... -- Bruce Johnson This is the sig who says 'Ni!' -- G-Books is

Re: Applecare - impressed and not impressed

2004-09-03 Thread Kyle Hansen
On 9/3/04 3:30 PM, Bruce Johnson [EMAIL PROTECTED] Spew into the Cybertrough: On Sep 3, 2004, at 3:24 PM, Kyle Hansen wrote: They are really well organized. Better than any PC company and I have many Certs on the PC side as well. That's odd, because I usually find Tums to be far more

Applecare - impressed and not impressed

2004-09-02 Thread Timothy Luoma
As I think I've shared, I started having problems with my hard drive a few weeks ago (about 2 I think). Errors appeared in the system log about an UNDEFINED problem in disk0s3 that coincided with the system lockups that I was having. TechTools reported Error -4 with the disk... no errors for

Re: Applecare - impressed and not impressed

2004-09-02 Thread Tim Hodgson
On Thu, Sep 2, 2004 at 2:06 am -0400, Timothy Luoma wrote: Here's the unimpressive part. The Powerbook came back with a note saying We diagnosed the problem as 3rd party hardware [a 512mb RAM chip from Crucial.com which I've had since early June]. Your iBook passed all tests after removing

Re: Applecare - impressed and not impressed

2004-09-02 Thread Thomas Ethen
If you send any computer back to Apple for any work, it should go back just as you got it RAM wise to avoid that issue with them. Tom I think placing the blame on the RAM chip sounds like a bunch of hooey to me. The RAM has been in there for months and I've never had a problem with Crucial

Re: Applecare - impressed and not impressed

2004-09-02 Thread Timothy Luoma
.. Original Message ... On Thu, 02 Sep 2004 10:05:43 -0500 Thomas Ethen [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: If you send any computer back to Apple for any work, it should go back just as you got it RAM wise to avoid that issue with them. yeah I actually forgot that it was in there, otherwise I

Re: Applecare - impressed and not impressed

2004-09-02 Thread [EMAIL PROTECTED]
On 9/2/04 11:05 AM, Thomas Ethen [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: If you send any computer back to Apple for any work, it should go back just as you got it RAM wise to avoid that issue with them. Tom I think placing the blame on the RAM chip sounds like a bunch of hooey to me. The RAM has been